TL;DR
This paper investigates the long-term deformation behavior of coal gangue used as subgrade filler under cyclic loading. Researchers developed and refined a residual deformation model for coal gangue, finding that compaction and confining pressure significantly reduce deformation, while particle size distribution has a lesser impact. This work provides crucial data for the safe and effective utilization of coal gangue in civil engineering projects.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Coal gangue, a byproduct of coal mining, presents a significant waste disposal challenge. While it has potential as a subgrade filler due to its engineering properties, its long-term performance under repeated traffic loads is a concern. Specifically, the accumulation of residual deformation (permanent settlement) can lead to structural instability and safety hazards in roadbeds. Existing models for predicting this deformation, like the Shenzhujiang model, have shown limitations when applied to materials like coal gangue, particularly under extensive cyclic loading. This paper aims to address this gap by establishing a more accurate residual deformation model for coal gangue and identifying the key factors influencing its behavior.
Methods
The study employed large-scale triaxial tests to simulate the conditions experienced by subgrade fillers under cyclic loading. Key aspects of their methodology include:
- Specimen Preparation: Coal gangue samples were collected and processed, with particles larger than 60 mm removed. Three different gradations (particle size distributions) were prepared, characterized by a parameter 'A'.
- Compaction: Samples were compacted to simulate different degrees of subgrade filling (90%, 93%, and 95% compaction), reflecting under-, standard-, and over-compaction scenarios.
- Large-Scale Triaxial Testing: A specialized DJSZ-150 dynamic and static triaxial test system was used. This system can apply both static and cyclic loads, measuring axial and volumetric deformation.
- Cyclic Loading: Specimens were subjected to 30,000 cycles of loading at a frequency of 1 Hz, simulating long-term traffic effects.
- Model Development and Modification: The study initially evaluated the Shenzhujiang residual deformation model. Based on experimental observations, they proposed a modified model to better capture the nonlinear behavior of coal gangue.
- Grey Correlation Analysis: This statistical method was used to quantify the influence of various factors (confining pressure, compaction degree, and gradation parameters) on the residual deformation.
Datasets
The study utilized coal gangue samples sourced from the Xiangtan Tangjiashan coal mine. The material primarily consisted of sandstone, limestone, shale, and mudstone. The researchers prepared three distinct particle size gradations for their experiments. Additionally, they referenced data from previous studies (Gong and Yang) for comparative analysis of deformation behavior under different conditions.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Nonlinear Deformation Growth: Coal gangue deformation under cyclic loading isn't linear. It initially increases rapidly and then slows down, eventually tending towards a constant value. This behavior is more pronounced in the early stages of loading.
- Model Limitations and Improvements: The standard Shenzhujiang model, while useful, struggled to accurately predict the deformation of coal gangue, especially over a large number of cycles. The researchers successfully modified this model to better account for the nonlinear nature of the material's response.
- Compaction is King: The degree of compaction is the most critical factor influencing residual deformation. Higher compaction significantly reduces both axial and volumetric strain, making it a key parameter for ensuring subgrade stability.
- Confining Pressure Matters: Increased confining pressure also leads to reduced residual deformation. This is intuitive, as higher confining pressure generally leads to greater particle interlocking and stiffness.
- Gradation's Subtle Role: While particle size distribution (gradation) does influence deformation, its impact is less significant than compaction or confining pressure. An increase in coarse particle content generally leads to smaller cumulative deformation, potentially due to better drainage and particle interlocking.
- Practical Implications for Engineering: The findings provide a strong basis for using coal gangue as a subgrade filler. The research highlights the importance of achieving high compaction levels and understanding the influence of confining pressure for optimal performance.
Key Results
- The study found that increasing confining pressure and compaction degree consistently reduced the final residual deformation of the coal gangue specimens.
- Conversely, an increase in the content of coarse particles in the gradation led to smaller cumulative deformation.
- Grey correlation analysis revealed a clear ranking of influencing factors: confining pressure (X₁) had the highest correlation with residual strain, followed by compaction degree (X₂), and then gradation parameters (X₃). This ranking held true for both axial and volume residual strains.
- The modified residual deformation model demonstrated improved accuracy in predicting the behavior of coal gangue filler under extensive cyclic loading compared to the original Shenzhujiang model.
Limitations and Future Work
- Model Parameterization: While the study proposes an improved model, it notes that further research is needed for specific fitting of model parameters for various engineering scenarios, especially considering the dynamic environment.
- Data Availability: The datasets generated in this study are not publicly available due to privacy or ethical restrictions, but can be obtained from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
- Future Research: The authors suggest that future work could focus on more detailed parameter fitting and exploring the model's applicability to other coarse-grained materials. The study also implicitly points to the need for further investigation into the long-term performance and durability of coal gangue subgrades under various environmental conditions.
Summary updated