Residents’ Willingness to Participate in Green Infrastructure: Spatial Differences and Influence Factors in Shanghai, China

Yang Yu, Hui Xu, Xiaohan Wang, Jiahong Wen, Shiqiang Du, Min Zhang, Qian KeSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates Shanghai residents' willingness to adopt green infrastructure (GI) for urban flood management, revealing a preference for public space implementation and distinct influencing factors for private vs. public spaces. Understanding these spatial differences and drivers is crucial for effective GI policy and urban sustainability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban areas worldwide face increasing challenges from pluvial flooding and the urban heat island effect, exacerbated by rapid urbanization and climate change. Green infrastructure (GI) offers a nature-based solution to mitigate these issues, but its successful implementation hinges on public participation. However, a significant gap exists in understanding how and why residents are willing (or unwilling) to participate in GI, particularly considering the spatial variations within a city and the differing contexts of public versus private spaces. This paper aims to fill this gap by exploring the spatial distribution of residents' willingness to participate in GI implementation in Shanghai and identifying the key factors influencing this willingness in both public and private domains.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach combining quantitative and qualitative techniques.

  • Questionnaire Survey: A structured questionnaire was administered to residents, gathering data on socio-economic attributes, cognition of GI, perception of pluvial flood risk, and attitudes towards various GI influence factors (policy, technology, funding, etc.). Participants also indicated their willingness to adopt specific GI measures in both private (e.g., balconies, courtyards) and public (e.g., streets, parks) spaces using a five-point Likert scale.
  • GIS Spatial Analysis: Kriging interpolation was used to map the spatial distribution of residents' willingness, GI cognition, and flood risk perception across Shanghai at a township scale.
  • Multivariate Regression Analysis: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was first used to categorize 30 influence variables into four components (Fac_Technology, Fac_Support, Fac_Limit, Fac_Improve). Subsequently, multivariate linear regression models were employed to identify the statistically significant factors influencing residents' willingness to participate in GI implementation in both private and public spaces. Weighted Least Squares (WLS) regression was used to address heteroscedasticity.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study was derived from a questionnaire survey conducted among Shanghai residents from June to October 2018. The survey included 598 participants, with 588 valid responses. Participants were residents aged 12 years or older who had lived in Shanghai for more than one year. The survey covered typical urban communities across the inner city, suburban areas, and outer suburban areas of Shanghai.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Public Space Preference: Residents overwhelmingly prefer implementing GI in public spaces over private ones. This suggests that while individuals may see the value of GI, the practicalities and perceived benefits are more aligned with community-level initiatives.
  • Spatial Disparities in Private GI: Willingness to implement GI in private spaces is significantly higher in the inner city compared to suburban areas. This is attributed to the poorer environmental quality and lack of green space in older inner-city areas, making residents more eager for improvements.
  • Uniformity in Public GI Willingness: Interestingly, spatial differences in willingness to implement GI in public spaces are less pronounced, indicating a more generalized positive sentiment towards community-level GI projects across the city.
  • Divergent Determinants: The factors influencing GI participation differ markedly between private and public spaces. This highlights the need for tailored engagement strategies.
  • Low GI Awareness: Despite the importance of GI, residents' overall cognition of GI and perception of pluvial flood risk are low. This underscores a critical need for public education and awareness campaigns.

Key Results

  • Participation Levels: 23% and 41% of residents expressed strong willingness or willingness to participate in public GI, compared to 8% and 23% for private GI.
  • GI Preferences: In private spaces, residents favor roof greening and rain barrels. In public spaces, tree planting is the most preferred GI measure.
  • Spatial Willingness: Inner-city residents show higher willingness for private GI implementation, while suburban and outer suburban areas show lower willingness. Public GI willingness is more uniformly high across the city.
  • Influence Factors (Private Space): Deterministic factors include gender (females more willing), education level (higher education more willing), and floor level (lower floors more willing). Free time, GI cognition, flood risk perception, supportive factors (Fac_Support), and environment-improving factors (Fac_Improve) also play significant roles.
  • Influence Factors (Public Space): Deterministic factors include building age (newer buildings more willing). Common factors influencing both private and public space participation include free time, GI cognition, flood risk perception, supportive factors (Fac_Support), and environment-improving factors (Fac_Improve).
  • Model Fit: The inclusion of socio-economic attributes, GI cognition, flood risk perception, and influence factors significantly improved the models' goodness of fit, demonstrating their importance in explaining residents' willingness.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low Cognition and Perception: The study highlights that residents' cognition of GI and perception of pluvial flood risk are generally low. This suggests that a primary focus for future interventions should be on public education and awareness campaigns to increase understanding of GI benefits and flood risks.
  • Policy and Support Gaps: The research points to a need for stronger supportive factors, including technology, funding, and regulatory support. Future work could explore specific policy interventions, such as in-kind subsidies for GI materials or streamlined processes for implementing green roofs.
  • Spatial Location Impact: While the study found spatial differences in private GI willingness, further research could delve deeper into the specific urban planning and environmental characteristics of different areas that drive these differences.
  • Engagement Strategies: The findings suggest that tailored engagement strategies are needed for private versus public space participation. Future research could explore the effectiveness of different communication channels and incentive structures for each context.

Summary updated

Abstract

Green infrastructure (GI) plays a fundamental role in achieving urban pluvial flood management, mitigating urban heat island effect, and improving living suitability. Residents’ participation is the main driving force of GI implementation. Based on semi-structured interviews, GIS spatial analysis, and multiple regression, we investigated residents’ willingness to participate in the implementation of GI in public and private space and identified the influence factors in Shanghai, China. The results show that, compared with private space, residents prefer to implement GI in public space, where they have different preferences of GI measures. On urban scale, residents’ willingness to participate in the implementation of GI in private space is characterized as “high in the inner city, low in the suburban areas”, while the spatial difference is insignificant for public space. In addition, the factors affecting residents’ willingness to participate in the implementation of GI are different in private and public space. The deterministic factors of GI participation are gender, education level, and floor for private space, while only include building age for public space, in addition to the common factors of free time, cognition of GI, perception of pluvial flood risk, supportive factors, and environment-improving factors that can influence both private and public space GI participation. Our analysis therefore provides valuable information for policymakers concerning nature-based solutions to climate change adaptation and urban sustainability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2019residents,
  author = {Yang Yu and Hui Xu and Xiaohan Wang and Jiahong Wen and Shiqiang Du and Min Zhang and Qian Ke},
  title = {{Residents’ Willingness to Participate in Green Infrastructure: Spatial Differences and Influence Factors in Shanghai, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11195396},
}
Figure