Researching product-service systems for consumers : insights from a systematic literature review

Steven Day, Donato Masi, Janet Godsell, Wanrong ZhangWarwick 2018

Abstract

Product-service systems (PSSs) have the potential to integrate a variety of sustainability strategies as producers are incentivised to design and market less material-intensive products and prolong use-cycles. While diffusion of PSSs in industrial cases is well reported, consumer acceptance remains a key barrier to more ambitious use-and result-oriented PSS outside of niche markets. This paper systematically reviews the literature on B2C PSSs to synthesise four factors impacting on consumer acceptance of PSSs and their hypothesised relationships. Further it is argued that considering the impact of all four factors would strengthen evaluative research on B2C cases.

Introduction

In our current "take-make-use-dispose" economy, sustainability advocates have long championed Product-Service Systems (PSS) as a viable alternative. PSS models shift the focus from selling physical products to selling "utility"—for instance, offering car-sharing memberships instead of car ownership, or pay-per-wash services instead of washing machine sales. Theoretically, this model incentivizes manufacturers to produce long-lasting, efficient goods.

However, a significant gap exists between industrial and consumer applications. While business-to-business (B2B) PSS is a mature field (e.g., "power-by-the-hour" jet engines), business-to-consumer (B2C) PSS remains confined to niche markets. This research addresses the "black box" of consumer acceptance, identifying why consumers often prefer ownership over subscription-based models.

Methodology

The study employed a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) following a rigorous five-step methodology: question formulation, locating studies, selection and evaluation, analysis and synthesis, and reporting.

The systematic literature review process, filtering 2,356 initial results down to 79 final articles.

The selection process involved searching five major databases (including Web of Science and SCOPUS) and applying strict inclusion/exclusion criteria. For instance, papers focusing solely on supply chains or B2B cases were excluded to ensure a dedicated focus on consumer behavior. This rigorous approach minimizes bias compared to traditional reviews.

The final dataset comprised 79 peer-reviewed articles published between 2000 and 2018. A key finding is the dominance of the Journal of Cleaner Production, which published nearly half (35) of the reviewed papers.

Distribution of PSS research articles by year and journal, showing a significant increase in publication volume after 2012.

The data reveals a clear evolution in the field: around 2015, research shifted from purely conceptual "what if" discussions to empirical studies investigating real-world consumer perceptions and behaviors.

The Four-Factor Framework for Consumer Acceptance

The review synthesizes four critical pillars that determine whether a PSS will be accepted by consumers:

  1. The PSS Offer: The specific balance of value versus perceived risk (e.g., hygiene concerns in shared clothing or the reliability of a service).
  2. Existing Alternatives: The ease and cost of traditional ownership compared to the service offering.
  3. The Consumer: Individual factors including personal values, demographics, and specific "use-regimes" (frequency of need).
  4. The Environment: The surrounding infrastructure, such as urban parking for car-sharing or the legal and regulatory backdrop.

A major psychological barrier identified is the "Ownership Trap." Consumers frequently associate ownership with freedom, status, and autonomy. Transitioning to a PSS can feel like a sacrifice of control, even if the service is more economical or environmentally friendly.

Key Results and Discussion

Quantitatively, the field has matured significantly, growing from sporadic publications in the early 2000s to a consistent output of 14-16 papers per year by 2017. Qualitatively, perceived risk emerged as the most significant recurring theme. Even when a PSS is demonstrably more sustainable or cost-effective, the uncertainty surrounding long-term contracts or the novelty of the service model creates a psychological barrier.

Trust also plays a vital role; because PSS models are often complex, consumers may not fully grasp the technical benefits. In such cases, high trust in the provider serves as a necessary substitute for comprehensive product knowledge. Furthermore, the "Green Fallacy"—the idea that environmental benefits alone drive adoption—has been debunked by empirical data. While consumers acknowledge the sustainability of PSS, they rarely choose it unless the functional value and risk profile are superior to traditional ownership.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the four factors of acceptance have been identified, their interactions remain poorly understood. Most existing studies examine these factors in isolation. Future research should adopt a more holistic approach, evaluating all four pillars simultaneously to identify the primary "deal-breakers" for consumers. Additionally, current successful PSS cases are largely limited to wealthy, educated, urban demographics; expanding these models to a broader consumer base is the next major challenge for the circular economy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Product-service systems (PSSs) have the potential to integrate a variety of sustainability strategies as producers are incentivised to design and market less material-intensive products and prolong use-cycles.While diffusion of PSSs in industrial cases is well reported, consumer acceptance remains a key barrier to more ambitious use-and resultoriented PSS outside of niche markets.This paper systematically reviews the literature on B2C PSSs to synthesise four factors impacting on consumer acceptance of PSSs and their hypothesised relationships.Further it is argued that considering the impact of all four factors would strengthen evaluative research on B2C cases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{day2018researching,
  author = {Steven Day and Donato Masi and Janet Godsell and Wanrong Zhang},
  title = {{Researching product-service systems for consumers : insights from a systematic literature review}},
  booktitle = {Warwick},
  year = {2018},
}

Loading related content...

Figure