Research Progress on the Solder Joint Reliability of Electronics Using in Deep Space Exploration

Qilong Guan, Chunjin Hang, Shengli Li, Dan Yu, Ying Ding, Xiuli Wang, Yanhong TianChinese 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The spacecraft for deep space exploration missions face extreme environments, including cryogenic temperatures, intense radiation, wide-range temperature variations, and combinations of these conditions. These harsh environments lead to solder joint degradation or failure, potentially damaging onboard electronics. Research into high-reliability solder joints for extreme environments is critical for reducing the weight of protection devices and improving overall spacecraft reliability. This paper reviews the reliability of SnPb, Sn-based lead-free, and In-based solder alloys in extreme environments and offers suggestions for future studies.

Introduction

Deep space exploration probes, such as those sent to the lunar surface or the poles of Mars, operate in environments that challenge the fundamental physics of electronic components. Spacecraft electronics must withstand "multi-extreme" conditions: cryogenic temperatures as low as -246°C (e.g., for the James Webb Space Telescope), rapid thermal cycling (the Moon's surface swings from 120°C to -230°C), and constant high-energy radiation bombardment.

Historically, engineers have relied on heavy shielding and active thermal control systems to protect sensitive electronics. However, these solutions significantly increase launch costs and reduce the payload ratio. Developing solder joints that are inherently reliable under these conditions would allow for the removal of heavy shielding, making missions more efficient. This review evaluates the current state of SnPb (Tin-Lead), Sn-based lead-free, and In-based (Indium) alloys in the context of deep space survival.

Methodology and Microstructure Evolution

This comprehensive review synthesizes nearly a century of metallurgical research and recent experimental data. Reliability is evaluated through three primary lenses:

  1. Microstructure Evolution: Utilizing Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) to track the growth of Intermetallic Compounds (IMCs). These brittle layers form where the solder meets the copper or nickel pad and are often the site of failure.
  2. Mechanical Testing: Analyzing tensile strength, shear force, and impact resistance across a temperature gradient from room temperature down to -196°C (liquid nitrogen).
  3. Irradiation Studies: Reviewing how gamma rays and high-energy particles create micro-voids and lattice displacements within the solder matrix.
SEM image (c) showing a crack propagating near the brittle Ni3Sn4 and Au0.5Ni0.5Sn4 intermetallic layers.

Key Insights: The Challenges of the Void

The "Tin Disease" Threat

At low temperatures, tin can undergo a phase transition from $\beta$-Sn (metallic) to $\alpha$-Sn (a brittle powder). While lead (Pb) inhibits this, many modern lead-free solders are highly susceptible, representing a significant risk for long-term cryogenic missions.

The IMC Brittle Villain

In almost every failure scenario, the culprit is the growth of Intermetallic Compounds (such as $Cu_6Sn_5$ or $Ni_3Sn_4$). These layers are hard and brittle. Under thermal shock, the mismatch in the Coefficient of Thermal Expansion (CTE) between the IMC and the bulk solder causes the joint to fracture.

Radiation as a Structural Stressor

Radiation does not only damage silicon chips; it physically degrades solder. Gamma irradiation can knock atoms out of place, creating micro-voids that reduce a joint's shear strength by over 20%.

Key Results and Performance Benchmarks

  • Sn37Pb Performance: Under extreme thermal shock (-196°C to 150°C), Sn37Pb BGA joints showed a characteristic lifetime of only 304 cycles before brittle fracture occurred at the IMC interface.
  • Radiation Degradation: After 960 hours of $\gamma$-ray irradiation, the shear force of Sn50Pb49Sb1 joints decreased by 22%, while AuSn20 joints saw a 37.23% drop.
  • Lead-Free Fragility: The popular SAC305 alloy undergoes a ductile-to-brittle transition (DBTT) between -70°C and -80°C, making it unsuitable for Mars missions where winter temperatures reach -143°C.
  • Indium as the Cryogenic Superstar: Unlike tin-based solders, Indium-based alloys maintain excellent ductility at cryogenic temperatures. They do not suffer from "tin disease" and can effectively relax internal stresses caused by thermal cycling. In3Ag/Cu joints achieved a maximum shear strength of 67.5 MPa at -196°C.
SEM image (b) illustrating a significant crack at the interface between the Ni layer and the solder after exposure to extreme conditions.

Limitations and Future Outlook

A critical gap in current research is the lack of "multi-extreme coupling" tests. Most studies test one stressor at a time (e.g., only cold or only radiation), whereas space environments present these factors simultaneously. A solder joint weakened by radiation may fail significantly faster during a thermal cycle.

Future research should focus on:

  1. Coupled Stress Testing: Simultaneous radiation and cryogenic cycling.
  2. High-Low Temperature Bridges: Developing alloys that can bridge the gap between high-power semiconductors (operating at 600°C) and the cold of space.
  3. Nano-Doping: Exploring how nanoparticles or rare earth elements can stabilize microstructures and prevent brittle IMC growth.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The spacecraft for deep space exploration missions will face extreme environments, including cryogenic temperature, intense radiation, wide-range temperature variations and even the combination of conditions mentioned above. Harsh environments will lead to solder joints degradation or even failure, resulting in damage to onboard electronics. The research activities on high reliability solder joints using in extreme environments can not only reduce the use of onboard protection devices, but effectively improve the overall reliability of spacecraft, which is of great significance to the aviation industry. In this paper, we review the reliability research on SnPb solder alloys, Sn-based lead-free solder alloys and In-based solder alloys in extreme environments, and try to provide some suggestions for the follow-up studies, which focus on solder joint reliability under extreme environments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guan2023research,
  author = {Qilong Guan and Chunjin Hang and Shengli Li and Dan Yu and Ying Ding and Xiuli Wang and Yanhong Tian},
  title = {{Research Progress on the Solder Joint Reliability of Electronics Using in Deep Space Exploration}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1186/s10033-023-00834-4},
}
Figure