Research Progress on Preparation Methods of Single-atom Catalysts

Shujuan Sun, Nannan Zheng, H. Pan, Meng Ma, Jun Chen, Xiubing HuangJournal of Inorganic Materials 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Single-atom catalysts (SACs) are revolutionizing catalysis with their unparalleled atom utilization and unique properties. This review meticulously details the diverse strategies for preparing SACs, from traditional bottom-up and top-down approaches to emerging quantum dot cross-linking/self-assembly methods, offering a comprehensive guide for researchers and a roadmap for future advancements in this critical field.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ever-increasing global demand for energy and the urgent need to address environmental challenges necessitate the development of highly efficient and sustainable chemical processes. Catalysts play a pivotal role in this, and the pursuit of improved catalytic materials is a constant endeavor. Traditional heterogeneous catalysts, while stable and easy to recover, often suffer from low atom utilization and complex active sites. Homogeneous catalysts offer high atom utilization and uniform active sites but are difficult to recover and can lead to pollution. Single-atom catalysts (SACs) emerge as a promising solution, offering the best of both worlds: the high atom utilization and uniform active sites of homogeneous catalysts, coupled with the stability and ease of recovery of heterogeneous catalysts. This paper addresses the critical challenge of how to effectively and precisely synthesize these SACs, exploring various preparation methods to unlock their full potential in energy, environmental, and organic catalysis.

Methods

The paper categorizes SAC preparation strategies into three main approaches:

  • Bottom-up Synthesis: This involves depositing metal precursors onto a support material, followed by reduction or other treatments to form single atoms. Methods discussed include:
  • Co-precipitation: A traditional method where metal ions are precipitated from a solution onto a support.
  • Electrochemical Deposition: Utilizes an external electric field to drive metal ions to deposit onto an electrode surface.
  • Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD): A highly precise technique that relies on self-limiting surface reactions to deposit materials layer by atomic layer, offering excellent control over morphology and uniformity.
  • Immersion Method: Involves soaking the support material in a precursor solution.
  • Ball Milling: A mechanical method that uses high-energy collisions to mix and reduce materials.
  • Photochemical Method: Employs light energy to drive reduction and anchoring of metal atoms.
  • Top-down Synthesis: This approach starts with bulk materials or nanoparticles and breaks them down into single atoms. Key methods include:
  • High-Temperature Atom Thermal Transfer: Leverages high temperatures to induce thermal motion of surface atoms, leading to their migration and anchoring onto a support. This often involves "reverse Ostwald ripening."
    • High-Temperature Pyrolysis: Involves thermal decomposition of precursor materials at high temperatures, often in a controlled atmosphere.
  • Quantum Dots Cross-linking/Self-Assembly: This emerging strategy utilizes the rich binding sites of materials like graphene quantum dots (GQDs) to achieve high-density, well-dispersed single atoms, overcoming limitations of traditional methods in achieving high metal loading and preventing aggregation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on synthesis methodologies rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Sweet Spot" of SMSI: While Strong Metal-Support Interaction (SMSI) is crucial for stabilizing single atoms and preventing aggregation, it can sometimes lead to the single atoms existing in an ionic state rather than their desired atomic form, impacting catalytic performance. Optimizing SMSI is a delicate balancing act.
  • Beyond Single Atoms: The Rise of Dual-Atom Catalysts: The paper highlights that single active sites can lead to adsorption energy barriers. Dual-atom catalysts, as an extension of SACs, offer increased metal loading, more active sites, and diverse binding modes, potentially overcoming SAC limitations.
  • The Power of Defects: Surface defects on support materials are increasingly recognized as crucial anchoring sites for single atoms, promoting their stability and uniform distribution.
  • ALD's Precision vs. Cost: Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) offers unparalleled control over SAC synthesis, leading to highly uniform and stable catalysts. However, its high cost and low yield remain significant hurdles for industrial scalability.
  • Emerging Strategies for High Loading: The quantum dot cross-linking/self-assembly approach shows significant promise for achieving much higher metal loadings of single atoms compared to traditional methods.

Key Results

The paper reviews numerous studies demonstrating the effectiveness of various SAC preparation methods across different applications:

  • High Activity and Selectivity: SACs prepared using these methods have shown superior activity and selectivity in a wide range of catalytic reactions, including energy conversion (e.g., oxygen evolution reaction, hydrogen evolution reaction), environmental catalysis (e.g., CO oxidation, VOC oxidation), and organic synthesis.
  • Enhanced Atom Utilization: The fundamental advantage of SACs, achieved through precise synthesis, leads to maximum utilization of expensive metal atoms, significantly reducing catalyst costs.
  • Improved Stability: Many of the discussed methods, particularly ALD and high-temperature pyrolysis, result in SACs with enhanced stability against aggregation and sintering, crucial for long-term catalytic performance.
  • Scalability Potential: While some methods like ALD face scalability challenges, others like co-precipitation, electrochemical deposition, and ball milling offer pathways towards industrial-scale production of SACs.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Scalability and Green Synthesis: Current top-down methods can be difficult to scale up and may involve toxic volatile gases. Future work should focus on developing greener, simpler, and more scalable synthesis processes for industrial applications.
  • Precise Control of Coordination Environment: Fine-tuning the coordination number and local atomic structure of single-atom active sites is crucial for optimizing catalytic activity.
  • Understanding Metal-Support Interactions: Further research is needed to optimize the metal-support interaction (SMSI) to ensure the atomic state of the metal and enhance stability without compromising catalytic performance.
  • Preventing Aggregation: Despite advancements, preventing single-atom aggregation during reactions remains a challenge. Designing catalysts to mitigate this is essential.
  • Exploring Dual-Atom and Beyond: The exploration of dual-atom catalysts and other multi-atom active sites is a promising avenue to overcome the limitations of single-atom catalysts.
  • Advancements in Synthesis Techniques: Continued development of diverse and refined synthesis methods, including ALD, spatial confinement strategies, and chemical anchoring, is crucial.
  • Sustainable and Functionalized Supports: The use of more diverse and functionalized support materials is a key trend for enhancing SAC performance.
  • Integration of Theory and Experiment: The synergy between theoretical calculations and experimental validation is vital for accelerating the progress of SAC research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{sun2024research,
  author = {Shujuan Sun and Nannan Zheng and H. Pan and Meng Ma and Jun Chen and Xiubing HUANG},
  title = {{Research Progress on Preparation Methods of Single-atom Catalysts}},
  journal = {Journal of Inorganic Materials},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.15541/jim20240302},
}
Figure