Research on Village Type Identification and Development Strategy under the Background of Rural Revitalization: A Case of Gaochun District in Nanjing, China

Lingling Dai, Weifeng Qiao, Ting Feng, Yuan-Fang LiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the critical need for nuanced village classification to guide China's Rural Revitalization Strategy. By developing a novel method that combines static development levels with dynamic reconstruction intensity, the study identifies five distinct village types in Gaochun District, Nanjing, and proposes tailored development strategies for each, offering a practical framework for targeted rural development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, and particularly in China, rapid urbanization has led to rural decline, characterized by land use imbalances and functional disparities. To counteract this, China has launched a Rural Revitalization Strategy aimed at integrated urban-rural development. However, effective implementation requires understanding the diverse characteristics and needs of rural areas. Existing village classification methods often rely on single dimensions or static perspectives, failing to capture the complex, dynamic nature of rural development. This paper tackles this gap by proposing a more comprehensive, multi-dimensional approach to village type identification that considers both current development status and the intensity of past and future reconstruction, thereby enabling more targeted and effective revitalization strategies.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach to village classification. First, it constructs two key index systems: one for village development level (static, reflecting long-term accumulation and current situation) and another for village reconstruction intensity (dynamic, capturing changes and future potential). These systems are built upon existing research and national planning frameworks, incorporating dimensions like village scale, geographic conditions, industrial development, natural resources, and public services.

A novel aspect is the use of the polygon area method to calculate a comprehensive score for each village, integrating multiple indicators. This method, visualized as a polygon in a multi-dimensional space, aims to provide a more holistic assessment than simple weighting. The village types are then identified through a three-step process:

  1. Characteristic Protection Type: Identified based on inclusion in lists of traditional villages, famous towns, or characteristic villages.
  2. Urban-Suburban Integration Type: Determined by proximity to urban built-up areas, town centers, or development zones.
  3. Differentiated Types (Agglomeration & Upgrading, Improvement & Development, Relocation & Merger): These are classified based on the combined scores of development level and reconstruction intensity (high/high, high/low, low/high, low/low). A priority is given to the "relocation and merger" type if there's a conflict with "urban-suburban integration" due to lack of development prospects.

Datasets

The study utilizes several datasets for the Gaochun District:

  • Land use change data: From 2009 and 2018, used for analyzing changes in per capita arable land and forest coverage.
  • Socio-economic data: From village-level statements and the National Bureau of Statistics for 2015 and 2018.
  • Road network data: From the 2019 national census of basic geography for accessibility analysis.
  • Ecological protection red line data: From the 2020 version for measuring planned ecological locations.
  • Official lists: Such as the "List of Traditional Chinese Villages" and "List of Famous Towns and Villages with Chinese Characteristics for Landscape Tourism" were used for identifying characteristic villages.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The synergy of static and dynamic is crucial: Simply looking at a village's current state (development level) isn't enough. Understanding how it has changed and its potential for future change (reconstruction intensity) provides a much richer picture for effective planning.
  • Polygon Area Method offers a more holistic score: Moving beyond simple weighted averages, the polygon area method attempts to capture the interplay of multiple development factors, potentially providing a more nuanced understanding of a village's overall status.
  • Gaochun District's unique profile: The study highlights that while Gaochun District has a medium overall development level, it exhibits a high overall reconstruction intensity. This suggests a region undergoing significant transformation, with a notable number of villages having low development but high potential for reconstruction.
  • Five distinct village archetypes emerge: The classification into characteristic protection, urban-suburban integration, agglomeration and upgrading, improvement and development, and relocation and merger types provides a practical framework for tailoring interventions.

Key Results

  • Village Development Level: Gaochun District generally shows a medium development level, with 73 low-value villages and 53 high-value villages. High development is concentrated in areas like Qiqiao Street and Yaxi Street.
  • Village Reconstruction Intensity: The district exhibits high reconstruction intensity, with 93 villages scoring high and 33 scoring low. High intensity is observed in areas like Yangjiang Town and Yaxi Street, indicating strong development trends.
  • Village Type Distribution: The study identified:
  • 12 Characteristic Protection villages
    • 23 Urban-Suburban Integration villages
    • 29 Agglomeration and Upgrading villages
    • 54 Improvement and Development villages (the most numerous type)
    • 11 Relocation and Merger villages
  • Strategic Recommendations: The paper proposes differentiated strategies for each type, emphasizing protection for characteristic villages, integration for urban-suburban types, upgrading for agglomeration types, focused development for improvement types, and targeted relocation/merger for the remaining villages.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Index System Applicability: The authors acknowledge that the index system, while tailored for Gaochun, may not be directly applicable to other regions due to variations in natural endowments, economic development, and urban-rural contexts. Future research may need to adjust indicators for different areas.
  • Data Limitations: The study relied on village-level data from 2015 and 2018, which was challenging to collect and may lack timeliness. Future work should prioritize more up-to-date and comprehensive data.
  • Dynamic Policy Adaptation: The proposed development strategies are based on the current stage of village development. As internal and external factors evolve, these strategies will need continuous adjustment and refinement.
  • Further Improvement of Weighting: While a combination of AHP and entropy weight methods was used, the authors suggest further improvement in index weight calculation.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the context of rural revitalization, it is of great significance for the implementation of a Rural Revitalization Strategy to carry out the research on scientifically identifying village types and clarifying the differences and pluralistic trends within villages. Taking Gaochun District of Nanjing in China as an example, this paper constructs an index system of development level and reconstruction intensity from a dynamic and static perspective, uses the polygon area method to calculate the comprehensive score of each index, divides village types based on the combination of development level and reconstruction intensity, and then puts forward the differentiated development strategies of various villages. The results show that the identification method of village types based on combined features is multi-dimensional and comprehensive, and the recognition results are more in line with the objective reality. Villages in Gaochun district have a medium overall development level and high overall reconstruction intensity. There are a large number of low-value villages with development level and high-value villages with reconstruction intensity. According to the three-step strategy of village type identification, the list of characteristic villages, the location of villages and the characteristics of index combination, five village types were identified: the characteristic protection type, the urban-suburban integration type, the agglomeration and upgrading type, the improvement and development type, and the relocation and merger type.
BibTeX
@article{dai2022research,
  author = {Lingling Dai and Weifeng Qiao and Ting Feng and Yuan-Fang Li},
  title = {{Research on Village Type Identification and Development Strategy under the Background of Rural Revitalization: A Case of Gaochun District in Nanjing, China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19116854},
}
Figure