Research on Urban Flood Risk Assessment Based on Improved Structural Equation Modeling (ISEM) and the Extensible Matter-Element Analysis Method (EMAM)

Lin Yan, Lihong Zhang, Weichao Yang, Caixia Chen, Jianxin Lin, Zhe Chen, Xuefeng Jiang, Hao Liang, Peijiang Cong, Jiangang Gao, Tao XueWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, integrated approach for urban flood risk assessment by combining an improved Structural Equation Modeling (ISEM) for weight calculation with the Extensible Matter-Element Analysis Method (EMAM) for risk assessment. This method significantly enhances the accuracy of flood risk assessment by addressing indicator correlations, leading to a more robust and reliable framework for disaster prevention and management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban flood events are becoming more frequent and severe globally, posing significant threats to lives and property. Accurate and scientific risk assessment is crucial for effective disaster prevention and mitigation. Existing methods often struggle with:

  • Lack of comprehensiveness: Indicator systems may not fully capture all relevant factors, especially regional shelter capabilities.
  • Ignoring indicator correlations: Traditional weight calculation methods often overlook the interdependencies between indicators, leading to inaccurate risk assessments.
  • Limited physical process consideration: Some approaches rely solely on statistical indicators without fully integrating hydrological processes.

This study aims to address these limitations by developing a more comprehensive and accurate urban flood risk assessment framework.

Methods

The paper proposes a novel, integrated approach comprising three main stages:

  1. Flood Risk Index System Establishment: A multi-dimensional index system is developed, incorporating four core components:
  2. Hazard: Assessed using hydrological-hydrodynamic modeling (SWTM, coupling SWMM and TELEMAC-2D) to simulate maximum inundation depth and velocity.
  3. Exposure: Evaluated using elevation, slope, and impervious surface rate derived from DEM and land-use data.
  4. Vulnerability: Quantified by GDP density, population density, and proximity to Points of Interest (POIs).
  5. Regional Shelter Capability: Measured by disaster prevention and mitigation capabilities (shelter point density) and flood control/drainage capacity (pipe network density).
  6. Improved Structural Equation Modeling (ISEM) for Weight Calculation:
    • Standardization: Indicator variables are normalized to a [0,1] range.
  7. Variable Validation: Reliability (Cronbach's Alpha) and validity (KMO test) are assessed.
  8. Model Construction: A structural equation model is built to hypothesize relationships between variables.
  9. Weight Revision: Crucially, Pearson's correlation coefficient is used to revise indicator weights, effectively eliminating correlations among variables and enhancing the accuracy of weight determination. This is a key novelty, addressing a limitation of standard SEM.
  10. Extensible Matter-Element Analysis Method (EMAM) for Risk Assessment:
    • Matter-Element Matrix Construction: The system's features (indicators) and their measured values are represented.
  11. Classical and Interval Domain Determination: Defining the range of values for different risk levels.
  12. Relevance Degree Calculation: Quantifying the correlation between matter-elements and risk levels.
  13. Risk Level Determination: Comprehensive relevance degrees are calculated to assign final risk levels and generate risk zoning maps.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from the Liwan District in Guangzhou City, China. Specific data sources include:

  • Hydrological-hydrodynamic model simulation results: From SWMM and TELEMAC-2D models for hazard factors (max inundation depth and velocity).
  • Geospatial data: DEM data from the National Geomatics Center of China.
  • Land use data: Acquired from geospatial data clouds.
  • Pipe network data: Collected through on-site measurements.
  • Statistical data: From the Guangzhou Statistical Yearbook and other sources for vulnerability and regional shelter capability factors.
  • POI data: From Gaode Map.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing data was integrated and analyzed using the proposed methodology.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Correlation Matters: The most significant insight is the demonstration that accounting for correlations between flood risk indicators is crucial for accurate assessment. Ignoring these correlations can lead to misrepresentation of risk.
  • ISEM as a Powerful Weighting Tool: The integration of Pearson's correlation coefficient into SEM (ISEM) provides a robust method for deriving indicator weights that are both statistically sound and reflective of real-world interdependencies.
  • EMAM for Robust Risk Quantification: EMAM proves effective in handling the inherent uncertainties and complexities of flood risk assessment, providing a structured way to translate indicator values into distinct risk levels.
  • Holistic Approach: The framework's strength lies in its comprehensive consideration of hazard, exposure, vulnerability, and shelter capacity, offering a more complete picture of urban flood risk.

Key Results

  • Improved Accuracy: The integrated ISEM-EMAM approach demonstrated a significant enhancement in urban flood risk assessment accuracy, achieving a 23.69% increase in grid matching degree compared to methods without weight modification.
  • Weight Revisions: The ISEM method revealed that maximum inundation depth (MaxD) and maximum inundation velocity (MaxV) are the most influential factors in determining flood risk weights, receiving higher emphasis after correlation correction.
  • Risk Zoning: The study successfully generated a detailed flood risk level zoning map for the Liwan District, identifying high-risk areas primarily in the southern and central-eastern regions due to low elevations, building density, and limited shelter capacity.
  • Model Validation: The SWTM model used for hazard simulation showed high accuracy, with Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency coefficients generally above 0.7 for both pipe network and inundation simulations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability: The authors acknowledge that obtaining comprehensive data for all indicators, particularly for investment in disaster prevention and mitigation measures, can be challenging and may lead to a lack of completeness in the indicator system.
  • Survey Data Accuracy: Some indicator values, like regional shelter capability, were quantified through questionnaire surveys, which can introduce potential inaccuracies.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future studies should focus on constructing a more complete and representative risk indicator system to further reduce research errors and improve the accuracy of assessment results. This could involve exploring additional data sources or more advanced data collection methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid development of the global economy, urban flood events are occurring more frequently. Scientific risk assessment methods are of great significance in reducing the loss of life and property. This study is devoted to developing an integrated urban flood risk assessment approach based on improved structural equation modeling and the extensible matter-element analysis method. Firstly, a flood risk assessment index system containing four dimensions (hazard, exposure, vulnerability, and regional shelter capability) is established according to a hydrological–hydrodynamic model and a literature survey. Subsequently, improved structural equation modeling (ISEM) coupled with Pearson’s correlation coefficient is introduced to determine indicator weights while eliminating correlations among indicator variables, thereby enhancing the accuracy of the weight calculation. Finally, the extensible matter-element evaluation analysis method (EMAM) is employed to conduct the urban flood risk assessment, providing a more scientific evaluation of urban flood risks through the calculation results of the correlation degree between index factors and risk levels. The integrated flood risk assessment approach was applied in the Liwan District in Guangzhou City, China, and the results demonstrated that the novel approach effectively enhances the accuracy of urban flood risk assessment by 23.69%. In conclusion, this research offers a novel and high-precision methodology for risk assessment, contributing to decision-making in disaster prevention and control.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yan2025research,
  author = {Lin Yan and Lihong Zhang and Weichao Yang and Caixia Chen and Jianxin Lin and Zhe Chen and Xuefeng Jiang and Hao Liang and Peijiang Cong and Jiangang Gao and Tao Xue},
  title = {{Research on Urban Flood Risk Assessment Based on Improved Structural Equation Modeling (ISEM) and the Extensible Matter-Element Analysis Method (EMAM)}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/w17132025},
}
Figure