Research on the Sustainable Renewal of Architectural Heritage Sites from the Perspective of Extenics—Using the Example of Tulou Renovations in LantianVillage, Longyan City

Xianli You, Yanqin Zhang, Zhigang Tu, Linxin Xu, Liyi Li, Rong Lin, Kaida Chen, Shunhe Chen, Wei RenInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach to the sustainable renovation of architectural heritage sites, specifically Fujian Tulou buildings, by applying the principles of "extenics." By systematically analyzing and resolving inherent contradictions in design, condition, and objectives, this method offers a structured framework for innovative and effective revitalization, ensuring the long-term viability of these cultural treasures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fujian Tulou buildings, iconic examples of Chinese vernacular architecture and cultural heritage, face a significant challenge: abandonment and decay. While some are recognized as UNESCO World Heritage sites, many others lack the attention and funding needed for preservation. Their unique structures and historical significance present considerable limitations for modern renovation, often leading to a lack of innovative solutions. This results in a disconnect between their historical value and their ability to meet contemporary living needs, pushing communities to abandon them. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a systematic and innovative methodology for their renovation and reuse, ensuring their sustainable future.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the application of extenics, a discipline focused on studying the possibility of expanding things and innovating through the resolution of contradictory problems. The authors employ several extenics methods:

  • Divergent Tree Analysis: Used to break down complex objects (like Tulou buildings) into their constituent elements and explore their internal structure and potential for innovation.
  • Conjugate Pair Analysis: Examines things through four pairs of opposing attributes (virtual/real, soft/hard, potential/obvious, positive/negative) to understand their composition and identify areas for transformation.
  • Correlative Net Analysis: Identifies and analyzes the relationships between different elements to understand how changes in one affect others, aiding in problem-solving.
  • Implied System Analysis: A hierarchical approach to analyze objectives and conditions, working from higher-level goals to lower-level solutions.
  • Split-Merge Chain Analysis: Allows for the decomposition of complex entities into simpler components and their subsequent recombination to create new forms with novel characteristics.

These methods are integrated into a comprehensive design system for Tulou building renovations, aiming to provide a structured, formal, and intuitive approach to addressing renovation challenges.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses case examples of Tulou renovations in Lantian Village, Longyan City, specifically the Yude Building and the Zhenchun Building, as the basis for their analysis and verification.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Extenics as a Contradiction Resolver: The fundamental insight is that extenics provides a powerful framework for systematically identifying and resolving the inherent contradictions in architectural heritage renovation, which are often complex and multifaceted.
  • Beyond Traditional Renovation: The paper advocates for moving beyond conventional renovation approaches by embracing innovative thinking facilitated by extenics, leading to more adaptive and sustainable outcomes.
  • The Importance of "White-Box" Design: By formalizing the design process, extenics transforms it into a "white-box" process, making it transparent, understandable, and reproducible, which is crucial for heritage conservation.
  • Community Participation is Key: The research highlights that spontaneous and induced participation of local communities, rather than top-down approaches, leads to the most effective and sustainable regeneration of Tulou buildings.
  • Tulou as a "Living" Heritage: The goal is not just to preserve the physical structure but to revitalize Tulou buildings, enabling them to continue serving as active community spaces and cultural hubs.

Key Results

The study successfully demonstrates the feasibility and effectiveness of applying extenics methods to the renovation of Tulou buildings. The authors developed a design system that:

  • Provides a structured approach to identifying and analyzing renovation problems.
  • Facilitates the generation of innovative renovation strategies by resolving contradictions.
  • Offers a more intuitive and rigorous design process compared to traditional methods.
  • The case studies of the Yude and Zhenchun Buildings illustrate how these methods can be applied to specific renovation scenarios, leading to improved functionality and preservation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Focus on Basic Elements: The study primarily utilized the basic element theory and extension transformation method of extenics, suggesting that further exploration of other extenics methodologies could enrich the approach.
  • Limited Scope: The research focused on Tulou buildings in Lantian Village, Longyan City, and the authors suggest that further studies are needed to test the universality and replicability of the proposed design system across different regions and types of architectural heritage.
  • Integration of Quantitative Methods: While extenics is inherently analytical, the authors suggest that integrating quantitative methods, such as priority degree evaluation, could further enhance the scientific rigor of the renovation design process.

Future work should involve a multi-level analysis of Tulou renovations and other heritage sites, a systematic validation of the design system's effectiveness and replicability, and a deeper exploration of quantitative extenics methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fujian Tulous in China are important international architectural heritage sites that reflect precious human cultural heritage. Currently, only a small number of Tulou buildings have been listed as world cultural heritage sites, resulting in a lack of attention and financial support for most Tulou buildings. Thus, it is difficult to effectively renovate and repair Tulou buildings to adapt to modern life, and therefore they are facing the severe challenge of abandonment and desolation. Due to the special conditions of Tulou buildings, there are significant limitations in renovation and repair work, with a number of problems such as the lack of innovative renovations. Therefore, through a problem model analysis of a design system for Tulou renovations, in this study, we adopt the methods of divergent tree, conjugate pair, correlative net, implied system, and split-merge chain analyses in extenics to carry out extension transformation and solve the problem and we verify its feasibility using the example of the Tulou renovation projects in Lantian Village, Longyan City. We explore an innovative methodology for scientific renovation of Tulou buildings, and we establish a design system for Tulou building renovations that enriches and supplements original renovation methods; thus, we provide a basis for the repair and reuse of Tulou buildings, to extend their service life and to realize the sustainable development of Tulou buildings. The research results show that extenics can be implemented in innovative renovations of Tulou buildings, and it is concluded that the essence of achieving sustainable renewal in Tulou building renovations is to solve contradictory problems, including contradictions in conditions, objectives, and design. This study verifies the possibility of applying extenics in the design of Tulou building renovations, makes corresponding contributions to the application of extension methods in the renovation and renewal of Tulou buildings, and also contributes to the renovation, renewal, and protection of other types of architectural heritage sites.
BibTeX
@article{you2023research,
  author = {Xianli You and Yanqin Zhang and Zhigang Tu and Linxin Xu and Liyi Li and Rong Lin and Kaida Chen and Shunhe Chen and Wei Ren},
  title = {{Research on the Sustainable Renewal of Architectural Heritage Sites from the Perspective of Extenics—Using the Example of Tulou Renovations in LantianVillage, Longyan City}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20054378},
}
Figure