Research on the Status of Intangible Cultural Heritage Bearers in the Human Capital Perspective

Jing Zhao, Zhong Wang, Chenyu Wang, Liming Han, Yaohui Ruan, Zhounan Huangfu, Shuai Zhou, Lei ZhouFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Intangible cultural heritage (ICH) is a human-based cultural transmission that shapes morality, character, and wisdom through practice. This study analyzes the status attainment of ICH bearers through the lenses of human capital (HC), social capital (SC), and psychological capital (PC). Using a status acquisition model, the research introduces occupational identity, job satisfaction, and entrepreneurial ability as mediating variables. Based on interviews and a survey of 506 bearers, the results indicate that most hypotheses were supported, notably that psychological capital and entrepreneurial ability are key drivers of status, while human capital and career identity show more complex or non-significant relationships with status outcomes.

The Challenge of the ICH Bearer

Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH) is unique because it exists only through human transmission; if the "bearers" stop practicing, the culture dies. While much research focuses on preserving the traditions themselves, very little looks at the people behind them as professionals.

In many regions, ICH bearers face an "embarrassing situation" where they are culturally revered but socially or economically marginalized. This research addresses a critical gap: What specific factors allow an ICH bearer to move from being a mere practitioner to achieving recognized social status? By moving beyond simple demographics, the study examines "capital stocks"—the resources an individual accumulates—and how these resources translate into career success.

Methodology and Framework

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach to explore these dynamics. Qualitative interviews with experts and bearers established a foundational understanding, followed by a quantitative questionnaire survey of 506 ICH bearers in China. The sample was 61.9% male, with a majority aged 36–59 and over half having a high school education or less.

To analyze the complex relationships between capital inputs and status outputs, the team used Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) via Smart PLS 3.2.8. They tested 14 hypotheses within a conceptual model that links human, social, and psychological capital to status attainment through mediators like job satisfaction and entrepreneurial ability.

Theoretical framework of the study showing the relationships between capital types, mediating variables, and status attainment.

The measurement scales for these constructs were validated for reliability and consistency, ensuring the robustness of the findings.

Construct validity and reliability metrics for the measurement scales used in the study.

Key Insights: Mindset and Markets

The study revealed several critical insights into how traditional artisans navigate modern social structures:

  • Psychological Capital (PC) is the Engine: PC—defined by resilience, optimism, hope, and self-efficacy—was a significant driver for almost every positive outcome. Bearers with high PC were more likely to have a strong career identity, higher job satisfaction, and better entrepreneurial skills.
  • The Human Capital Paradox: Interestingly, while Human Capital (education and skills) helped bearers feel more identified with their craft and improved their entrepreneurial ability, it had no significant impact on job satisfaction. Simply being highly skilled doesn't necessarily make a traditional artisan happy.
  • Identity vs. Status: One of the most surprising findings was that Career Identity does not lead to Status Attainment. Feeling like a "master" of your craft in your own mind doesn't automatically translate to social prestige or economic income in the eyes of society.
  • Entrepreneurship as the Bridge: Entrepreneurial ability was the strongest predictor of status attainment ($\beta = 0.499$). For an ICH bearer to gain status, they must be able to navigate the market and "create or accomplish new things" rather than just repeating traditional patterns.

Results Summary

The structural model showed a "Goodness of Fit" (GOF) of 0.60, indicating a substantial impact size. Out of 14 hypotheses, 11 were supported. The strongest direct paths to status were Entrepreneurial Ability ($\beta = 0.499, p < 0.001$) and Job Satisfaction ($\beta = 0.274, p < 0.001$). Conversely, some expected paths were rejected: human capital did not significantly impact job satisfaction, social capital did not necessarily boost career identity, and professional identity alone did not grant social status.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The study's findings are rooted in the specific cultural context of China, where Confucian values and rapid urbanization play significant roles. Future research could explore these dynamics in different economic or cultural settings. Additionally, as this was a cross-sectional study, longitudinal research could better track how a bearer's status evolves over a career.

From a policy perspective, the authors suggest that government intervention should shift from merely "protecting" heritage to "cultivating" the talent of bearers. This involves fostering entrepreneurial skills and psychological resilience, ensuring that the people behind the traditions can thrive in a modern economy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Culture is the bloodline of the nation and the spiritual home of the people. Intangible cultural heritage (ICH) belongs to the field of culture, and the transmission of ICH is a kind of human-based cultural transmission, which is the shaping of people's morality, character, sentiment, will, ideals and beliefs, value orientation, humanistic cultivation, artistic taste, way of thinking, wisdom, and ability in the practice of production and life of various ethnic groups. Based on the status acquisition model, this study analyzed the human capital (HC), social capital (SC), and psychological capital (PC) of ICH bearers from three perspectives. In addition to the conventional socio-demographic factors such as gender, age, place of residence, and education level as control variables, status attainment was introduced as a dependent variable, and occupational identity, job satisfaction, and entrepreneurial ability were introduced as mediating variables to construct a conceptual model in the hope of exploring the multiple influencing factors of status attainment among ICH bearers. Interviews were used to gain, the feelings and knowledge of experts, scholars, and ICH bearers, to lay a solid qualitative research foundation for this study. A questionnaire survey was also conducted to obtain basic information and professional experiences of ICH bearers to provide real support for the research analysis and discussion. As per the results of this research, all the hypotheses were supported except, HC did not have any significant impact on JS. Furthermore, SC was not in a significant association with career identity. Moreover, career identity and status attainment did not have a significant relationship.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2022research,
  author = {Jing Zhao and Zhong Wang and Chenyu Wang and Liming Han and Yaohui Ruan and Zhounan Huangfu and Shuai Zhou and Lei Zhou},
  title = {{Research on the Status of Intangible Cultural Heritage Bearers in the Human Capital Perspective}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.850780},
}
Figure