Abstract. The spatial distribution pattern of producer service firms is a significant part of the spatial distribution of industry. In this paper a strategy to get the spatial distribution pattern of producer service firms was proposed by using cartographic generalization, the local Getis-Ord $G_i^*$ statistic and overlay method. First, a basic geographic layer, main contained road and residential, should be drawn utilizing cartographic generalization. Second, an enterprise thematic layer, shown the agglomeration effect of producer service firms, was drawn using the local Getis-Ord $G_i^*$ statistic. Finally, get the spatial distribution pattern of producer service firms overlaying the basic geographic layer with enterprise thematic layer. Taking urban Harbin, China as a case study, an empirical study was conducted with data of producer service firms in 2016. The results indicated four distribution regions: (i) it showed the high hot agglomeration effect in centre urban Harbin; (ii) it appeared hot agglomeration effect in both north and south of centre urban Harbin; (iii) some of producer service firms randomly distributed in the surrounding area; and (iv) a fraction of producer service firms scattered in the peripheral area.
Introduction
Understanding the spatial distribution of industry is vital for urban planning and economic policy. While much research has focused on global metropolises like Beijing or Shanghai, second- and third-tier cities like Harbin are often overlooked. This paper presents a spatial analysis of producer service firms—businesses that provide services to other businesses (e.g., finance, law, tech)—within Harbin, China.
The challenge lies in transforming raw, tabular enterprise data (addresses) into meaningful spatial patterns. The authors address the need for a robust methodology to visualize "agglomeration effects"—the phenomenon where firms cluster together to reduce transaction costs and facilitate face-to-face exchanges—within a specific regional context.
Methods
The researchers developed a GIS-based strategy using the local Getis-Ord $G_i^*$ statistic to identify "hot spots" of producer service firms. The authors proposed a seven-step workflow integrating Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and spatial statistics:
- Cartographic Generalization: Simplifying complex road and settlement data to create a clean "basic geographic layer."
- Fuzzy Geocoding: Converting text-based addresses into latitude/longitude coordinates using a "similarity indicator" (MI) to handle naming inconsistencies.
- Grid-based Analysis: Dividing the study area into a $1\text{ km} \times 1\text{ km}$ grid to standardize the unit of analysis.
- Local Getis-Ord $G_i^*$ Statistic: This is the core analytical tool. It identifies statistically significant spatial clusters of high values (hot spots) and low values (cold spots).
- Overlay Method: Combining the enterprise thematic layer with the geographic base layer to interpret the results in the context of the city's physical layout.
Datasets
The study utilized two primary datasets from 2016:
- Geographical Data: Vector data for roads, settlements, and county boundaries provided by the China Cartographic Publishing House.
- Enterprise Data: A tabular dataset of 41,482 producer service firms from the National Administration for Code Allocation to Organization. This included data on finance, real estate, commercial services, software/IT, scientific research, transport, and education/media.
Key Results and Insights
The analysis successfully categorized the city into five zones: high heat, heat, random, cold, and high cold. The fuzzy geocoding method was highly effective, with 98.7% of data matched within a 1000m positional error, which is acceptable for a 1km grid analysis.
The findings reveal a hierarchical distribution across four regions:
- High Hot Agglomeration: Concentrated in the urban center (Nangang, Xiangfang, Daowai, and Daoli districts). The Nangang district emerged as the clear economic heart, hosting over 17,000 firms.
- Secondary Hot Spots: Emerging clusters in the north (Songbei district) and south (Acheng and Pingfang districts).
- Random Distribution: Firms scattered in the immediate surrounding areas of the core.
- Peripheral Scarcity: A fraction of firms scattered thinly in the far outskirts.
These results reinforce the theory that high-end producer services remain highly centralized in the Central Business District (CBD) because they require frequent, high-stakes interpersonal interaction. However, the appearance of secondary hot spots suggests that improved transportation and communication are allowing some firms to move outward to reduce costs.
Limitations and Future Work
The current model treats every firm as a single point, lacking data on firm size, such as turnover or employee count. A small consultancy and a massive bank headquarters are currently weighted equally. Future work should incorporate these attributes to provide a more nuanced view of economic density and utilize longitudinal data to observe how these clusters evolve over time.
Summary updated