TL;DR
This paper investigates the feasibility of consolidating two critical communication networks in smart substations – the Sampled Measured Value (SMV) and Generic Object Oriented Substation Event (GOOSE) networks – into a single, shared network. By analyzing potential challenges like network load and real-time data delivery, the authors propose and validate a solution using priority control, VLANs, and GMRP to ensure reliable and efficient communication, potentially reducing costs and simplifying substation infrastructure.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Modern smart substations rely on sophisticated communication networks to monitor and control electrical power systems. Traditionally, the networks carrying Sampled Measured Value (SMV) data (for analog measurements) and Generic Object Oriented Substation Event (GOOSE) data (for critical binary events like tripping commands) are kept physically separate. This separation, while ensuring high reliability and isolating potential faults, leads to a complex network infrastructure with multiple Ethernet interfaces required on substation devices. This complexity increases costs and can hinder efficient data exchange, particularly for devices like busbar differential and transformer protection systems that need to communicate across multiple bays. The paper addresses the challenge of simplifying this infrastructure by exploring the viability of a shared SMV and GOOSE network.
Methods
The authors tackle the problem by first analyzing the potential issues arising from a shared network. These include:
- Network Load: The combined traffic of SMV and GOOSE data could overwhelm network devices and intelligent terminals.
- Processing Capacity: Bay-level devices (like protection devices and BCUs) need sufficient processing power to handle the increased data volume.
- Real-time Data Delivery: Ensuring that critical GOOSE messages (like tripping commands) are delivered within strict time constraints is paramount.
- Network Fault Impact: A single network fault could simultaneously disable both critical SMV and GOOSE communication.
To address these challenges, the paper proposes several technical solutions:
- Message Priority Control (IEEE 802.1p): Prioritizing critical data like tripping commands over less time-sensitive data to ensure timely delivery.
- Virtual Local Area Networks (VLANs): Segmenting the network to isolate data traffic by bay or function, thereby limiting the scope of data dissemination and reducing interference.
- GARP Multicast Registration Protocol (GMRP): An automatic multicast configuration protocol that allows devices to inform switches about the scope of multicast messages, enabling dynamic optimization of network flow.
- Reduction of Switch Ports: Strategically reducing the number of switch ports per bay to limit the impact of a switch failure to a single bay.
The feasibility of the shared network was then evaluated through experimental comparison with a separate-network setup.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper describes an experimental setup using simulated merging units, intelligent terminal units, and protection devices, rather than relying on pre-existing datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Consolidation is Achievable and Beneficial: The core idea is that a shared SMV and GOOSE network is technically feasible and offers significant advantages in terms of cost savings and simplified substation architecture, especially for lower voltage substations.
- Network Load is a Primary Concern: The combined data flow from SMV and GOOSE can be substantial, requiring careful management to avoid impacting intelligent device performance.
- Intelligent Device Limitations: While switches can handle high loads, the processing capabilities of intelligent devices (network cards and CPUs) are a critical bottleneck that needs to be addressed.
- Real-time Performance is Non-Negotiable: The success of a shared network hinges on its ability to maintain the strict real-time delivery requirements of GOOSE messages.
- Layered Security and Isolation are Key: Techniques like VLANs and GMRP are crucial for segmenting traffic, controlling data flow, and mitigating the impact of faults.
- Priority Matters: Implementing a robust priority scheme is essential to ensure that the most critical operational data is always delivered first, even under heavy network load.
Key Results
The experimental comparison between separated and shared networks demonstrated that:
- The maximum transmission time delay for both SV and GOOSE messages in the shared network was 10 µs.
- No packets were lost during the experiments.
- These results indicate that the shared-network of SV and GOOSE is feasible under the tested conditions.
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations: * The paper acknowledges that while the technical basis for a shared network exists, achieving mature implementation requires absorbing practical operational experience and addressing encountered problems. * The processing capacity of bay-level devices, particularly for busbar and transformer protection, remains a technical challenge that requires high-speed network cards and CPUs.
Future Work: * The authors suggest that further practical operation and inspection in experimental units are necessary to mature the technology. * The paper implies that continued research and development in intelligent device hardware and software will be crucial for wider adoption of shared networks.
Summary updated