Research on the Reliability of a Core Control Unit of Highway Electromechanical Equipment Based on Virtual Sensor Data

Shan Lin, Mi Luo, Jun Niu, Hongke Xu2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how vibrations from vehicle-road interactions affect the reliability of critical electronic components (PCBs) in roadside highway equipment. By simulating these vibrations and analyzing PCB deformation, they demonstrate that proximity to traffic significantly increases the risk of component failure, leading to an optimized PCB design that enhances resilience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Highway electromechanical equipment, crucial for modern transportation infrastructure, is constantly exposed to vibrations generated by vehicle-road interactions. While the impact of these vibrations on pavement and adjacent structures is well-studied, their specific effect on the reliability of the electronic components within roadside equipment, particularly Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs), remains less understood. PCBs are the "brains" of these systems, and their failure can lead to the malfunction of the entire equipment. This paper aims to quantify the risk posed by vehicle-road coupling vibrations to PCB reliability and propose design improvements to mitigate these risks.

Methods

The study employs a multi-stage simulation approach:

  • Vehicle-Road Dynamics: A 1/4 vehicle model was used to simulate the dynamic load of a vehicle tire interacting with the road. This involved establishing vehicle and road equilibrium equations and solving them using the Newmark-β iterative algorithm.
  • Road Vibration Simulation: A finite element model of a semi-rigid asphalt pavement was created in ANSYS Workbench. The dynamic tire load from the vehicle model was applied to this pavement model to simulate road deformation and generate vibration acceleration data.
  • Virtual Sensing: Virtual acceleration sensors were placed on the roadside in the finite element model to collect vibration data, simulating real-world sensor placement.
  • Power Spectral Density (PSD) Analysis: The collected acceleration data was transformed using Fourier transform to obtain the power spectral density, which characterizes the frequency content of the vibrations.
  • PCB Reliability Analysis: A simplified PCB model was developed, incorporating material properties and a total mass equivalent method. This model was subjected to the derived PSD as an excitation source in ANSYS Workbench to analyze its dynamic response, specifically focusing on deformation and equivalent stress.
  • Optimization: Based on the deformation analysis, the PCB layout was optimized by repositioning large components to minimize stress in high-deformation areas. The optimized PCB's modal frequency and deformation response were then re-evaluated.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated through finite element modeling and established vehicle dynamics models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Proximity Matters: The attenuation of road vibrations as they travel from the road surface to the roadside is significant. When the vehicle is driving on the central axis of the lane, the vibrations reaching the equipment are considerably weaker. However, when the vehicle drives close to the roadside, the vibrations are much stronger and directly impact the equipment.
  • Deformation as a Failure Indicator: The study highlights that excessive deformation of the PCB, particularly in the Z-direction, is a critical indicator of potential component failure. This deformation can lead to components detaching from the PCB substrate.
  • Optimization Reduces Risk: Repositioning large components on the PCB can effectively shift them away from areas of maximum deformation, thereby reducing the risk of breakage and improving the overall reliability of the PCB under vibration.
  • Virtual Sensing for Real-World Problems: The paper demonstrates the utility of virtual sensors within finite element platforms to simulate and analyze real-world environmental impacts on electronic equipment, providing a cost-effective way to assess reliability before physical prototyping.

Key Results

  • When a vehicle drives close to the roadside, the maximum Z-direction deformation of the PCB can reach 0.17 mm (within a 3 Sigma probability range). This value exceeds the calculated allowable displacement (0.134 mm) based on the Steinberg method, indicating a risk of fatigue failure.
  • The equivalent stress on the PCB under roadside excitation was found to be around 5.5675 MPa, which is significantly lower than the tensile strength of the FR-4 material (340 MPa). This suggests that while stress is not the primary failure mode in this scenario, deformation is the critical factor.
  • After optimization, the first-order modal frequency of the PCB increased by 5.4% (from 48.89 Hz to 51.56 Hz).
  • The optimized PCB design effectively distributes large components outside the maximum deformation zones, significantly reducing the risk of component detachment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Models: The study uses simplified models for both the vehicle (1/4 model) and the PCB (removing small components). While this aids computational efficiency, it might not capture all real-world complexities.
  • Simulated Data: The analysis relies entirely on simulated data. The authors plan to conduct future work involving the collection of actual vibration data from highway pavements using roadside sensors to validate their findings and further analyze the influence of real-world vibrations.
  • Specific Road Conditions: The study focuses on a Class B road surface. The impact of different road surface types and conditions on vibration generation and transmission could be explored further.
  • Component-Level Analysis: While the study focuses on PCB deformation, a more detailed analysis of individual component solder joint reliability under these specific vibration conditions could provide deeper insights.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{lin2022research,
  author = {Shan Lin and Mi Luo and Jun Niu and Hongke Xu},
  title = {{Research on the Reliability of a Core Control Unit of Highway Electromechanical Equipment Based on Virtual Sensor Data}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22207755},
}
Figure