Research on the Relationship between Auditor’s Gender and Audit Fees

Jie M. ZhangEconomic 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Does an auditor’s gender influence the bill a company receives? This study of over 2,000 Chinese listed firms suggests the answer is yes: female auditors are associated with significantly higher audit fees, likely due to higher levels of risk aversion and a more meticulous approach to the auditing process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In an era of increasingly complex financial systems and high-profile corporate frauds, the "human element" of auditing has come under the microscope. While traditional research often focuses on macro-level factors like firm size or industry regulations, this paper dives into behavioral auditing.

The authors tackle a specific question: How do an auditor’s personal traits—specifically gender—affect their response to audit risk and, consequently, the fees they charge? The underlying tension is that auditors are often blamed when they fail to catch financial irregularities. If certain auditors are more cautious or risk-averse, they may put in more "socially necessary labor time," leading to higher costs for the client.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative empirical approach using a fixed-effects multiple linear regression model.

To isolate the impact of gender, they defined the dependent variable as the natural logarithm of audit fees (to stabilize the data). The primary independent variable was auditor gender, which they coded creatively to account for teams:

  • Gender_order: A multinomial variable (0, 1, 2, or 3) representing the number of female CPAs on a specific audit engagement.
  • Gender_dummy: A binary variable used to compare all-female teams against all-male teams to avoid the "noise" of mixed-gender combinations.

They controlled for several financial health indicators of the audited companies, including inventory levels, accounts receivable, leverage, liquidity, and Return on Assets (ROA). The analysis was performed using Excel and Stata 15.

Datasets

The study utilized the CSMAR (China Stock Market & Accounting Research) database, a standard benchmark in Chinese financial research.

  • Sample Size: 2,098 companies listed on the Shenzhen and Shanghai Stock Exchanges.
  • Timeframe: A ten-year window from 2013 to 2022.
  • Total Observations: 20,980 data points (firm-year observations).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Risk-Aversion Hypothesis: Drawing on psychological literature, the authors argue that female auditors tend to be more risk-averse and cautious. In the high-stakes world of auditing, this translates to a lower tolerance for error and a greater inclination to gather more evidence.
  • Effort Equals Expense: Because female auditors may be more "devoted and take their work seriously" (per the paper's literature review), they likely invest more time and resources into the audit. Since audit fees are essentially a price on labor and risk premiums, more effort leads to a higher bill.
  • The "CPA Mix" Matters: The study suggests that the audit fee increases in proportion to the number of female auditors on the team. This implies that gender diversity or a female-heavy team composition directly impacts the firm's pricing strategy to offset perceived audit risks.

Key Results

The regression analysis confirmed a significantly positive relationship between female auditors and audit fees.

  • Coefficient of Association: 0.0128 (significant at the 10% level).
  • Directionality: As the number of female auditors on a project increases, the audit fees rise.
  • Control Variables: Factors like inventory levels (Inv) and ROA also showed significant correlations with fees, confirming that the model was successfully capturing broader economic realities alongside the gender variable.

The authors conclude that female auditors charge higher fees because they provide "higher-quality audits" characterized by greater caution, which reduces the likelihood of stock price declines or audit failures for the client.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify several areas where the research could be expanded:

  • Geographic and Market Scope: The study is strictly limited to Chinese listed firms. The "gender premium" might manifest differently in different regulatory environments or cultures.
  • Data Depth: The research relies on secondary data (CSMAR). It doesn't directly measure the personality of the auditors, only using gender as a proxy for traits like risk aversion.
  • Unlisted Firms: The study excludes non-listed corporations, where personal traits of auditors might have even more (or less) visibility.
  • Longitudinal Trends: While the study covers ten years, the authors suggest that future research should look at even longer-term trends to see how these behavioral patterns evolve as the industry changes.

Summary updated

Abstract

This thesis aims at how the auditors’ gender affects audit fees. Due to the economic system’s ongoing innovation in recent years, auditing has become a sophisticated and professional activities with rising hazards. Auditors are to blame for failing to identify these issues in a timely manner, as there has been a substantial rise in the number of investors and lenders who have lost money because of business bankruptcies or financial fraud in recent years. Auditors would increase audit fees when they consider the auditees are at high risk. Moreover, more and more academics then started to focus their research on the micro level, looking at the connection between an auditor’s personality traits and their response to audit risk. Studies on behavioral auditing have shown that auditor characteristics have a big impact on how well auditors perform. Based on the agency theory of audit demand, the hypotheses development is put forward between audit fees and auditors’ gender in this study. The study collects secondary data and analyze it completely. Besides, all the data processing and calculation process of the empirical study were completed by excel and stata15 which is elaborated. The CSMAR database is the sole source of information for this study. At last, 2,098 China listed companies in Shenzhen and Shanghai Stock Exchange whose accounting deadline is from 2013 to 2022 are selected as the research samples. It is concluded that Audit fees charged by female auditors are much higher, therefore auditors’ gender has a significantly positive effect on the audit fees. Strategists, regulators, and users of financial information can all profit from the findings. This study can offer a useful foundation for the development of an industry team and the training of auditor talent.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024research,
  author = {Jie M. Zhang},
  title = {{Research on the Relationship between Auditor’s Gender and Audit Fees}},
  booktitle = {Economic},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.62381/e244616},
}
Figure