TL;DR
This study investigates how different floating wind turbine platform types (spar buoy, semi-submersible, tension leg) affect wake characteristics and overall wind farm power output compared to fixed-bottom turbines. The findings reveal that spar buoys, with their more dispersed rotor movement and wake, lead to the highest wind farm power output, especially at lower wind speeds, due to more efficient wake recovery.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
As wind energy development pushes into deeper waters, floating offshore wind turbines are becoming crucial. However, the inherent motion of these platforms introduces complexities to wake effects, which significantly impact the power output of downstream turbines in a wind farm. Unlike fixed-bottom turbines, the six degrees of freedom of floating platforms mean their rotor movements and subsequent wake patterns can vary considerably. This paper aims to quantify these differences across three common floating platform types (spar buoy, semi-submersible, tension leg) and compare them to a fixed-bottom monopile turbine, addressing a gap in understanding how platform design influences wind farm performance.
Methods
The researchers employed a numerical approach using the FAST.Farm code, a tool developed by NREL for simulating wind farm performance. This code integrates OpenFAST for aero-hydro-servo-elastic modeling of individual turbines, coupled with wake dynamics modeling. The study simulated three types of floating wind turbines (Semi, Spar, TLP) and a fixed-bottom monopile (Mnpl) turbine, all based on the NREL 5-MW reference wind turbine. A line-like arrangement of nine turbines (1x9) with an 8D spacing was used to maximize wake effects. Simulations were conducted across a range of wind speeds (9-20 m/s) and under specific sea conditions derived from real-world data. The analysis focused on rotor movement, wake characteristics (dispersion, velocity loss), and ultimately, the power output of individual turbines and the entire wind farm.
Datasets
The study utilized meteorological data from a 13-year wind and wave statistics dataset for northeastern Scotland from BMT AR-GOSS. This data was used to define sea conditions, including wave height and spectral peak period, and to generate wind data files using the Turbsim tool. No new datasets were introduced; rather, existing, publicly available data was leveraged for the simulations.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Platform Design Dictates Wake Behavior: The fundamental difference in platform design (e.g., spar buoy's deep draft vs. TLP's tensioned mooring) directly translates into distinct rotor movements and, consequently, wake characteristics.
- Dispersion is Key to Efficiency: Greater dispersion of the rotor's center position and the wake itself (observed in spar buoys) leads to more effective energy exchange between the wake and free-flow regions, resulting in faster wake recovery.
- Low Wind Speeds Highlight Differences: The impact of platform type on wake effects and power output is most pronounced at lower wind speeds, where wake losses are more significant relative to the total available wind energy.
- Floating Turbines Outperform Fixed in Wake: Generally, floating wind farms exhibit higher power output than fixed-bottom farms, particularly in the wake-affected regions, due to the dynamic response of the platforms.
Key Results
- Rotor Movement: Spar buoy and semi-submersible turbines showed more scattered rotor positions compared to TLP and monopile turbines. The spar buoy exhibited the largest displacement range, particularly in the Y-axis direction.
- Wake Dispersion: The spar buoy type had the most dispersed wake center, followed by the semi-submersible, then TLP and monopile. This dispersion was quantified by the area encompassing the wake region at 7D downstream.
- Wake Velocity Loss: While differences were minor, the spar type generally showed slightly lower wake velocity loss.
- Power Output:
- Individual Turbines: At low wind speeds, the spar buoy and semi-submersible turbines generally produced higher power in downstream positions (T2-T9) compared to TLP and monopile. However, the first turbine (T1), unaffected by wake, sometimes showed higher output for the monopile due to its lack of tilt.
- Wind Farms: The spar buoy wind farm consistently yielded the highest power output across various wind speeds, followed by the semi-submersible, TLP, and then the fixed-bottom monopile. At a wind speed of 12 m/s, the spar farm produced 5.16% more power than the monopile farm. At higher wind speeds (above rated), wake effects diminished, and power outputs became more similar across all types.
Limitations and Future Work
- Simplified Wind Farm Layout: The study used a 1x9 line-like arrangement to maximize wake effects. Future work could explore more complex, staggered layouts.
- Specific Sea Conditions: While based on real data, the simulations used a single set of sea conditions. Investigating a wider range of wave and current scenarios would be beneficial.
- Focus on Specific Platform Types: The analysis was limited to three dominant floating platform types. Other emerging designs could be included.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that understanding and utilizing the load characteristics of floating wind turbines is crucial for their operation and control. Further research could also focus on optimizing the layout of floating wind farms, controlling wakes, and selecting the most suitable turbine types for specific environments.
Summary updated