Research on the Model of the Integration between Industry and Education in Application-oriented Universities - Taking the Tourism Management as an Example

Wei GaoJournal of Tourism Management 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the systemic disconnect between academic training and industry requirements within tourism management programs at application-oriented universities. It proposes a strategic framework to bridge this gap by incentivizing enterprise participation, establishing collaborative governance, and cultivating a "double-qualified" faculty capable of balancing theory with real-world practice.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "ivory tower" effect remains a significant hurdle for application-oriented universities, which are specifically tasked with producing job-ready graduates. In the context of tourism management, the author identifies a critical misalignment: while the industry is growing rapidly, the educational model is lagging.

The core challenges include:

  • Motivation Gaps: Enterprises often see little short-term economic benefit in partnering with schools, leading to a lack of enthusiasm for deep collaboration.
  • Governance Friction: There is a lack of clear mechanisms for sharing responsibilities, risks, and benefits between academic institutions and corporate partners.
  • Outdated Pedagogy: Curricula remain overly theoretical, and teaching methods are often "tedious" and disconnected from the fast-paced changes of the tourism market.
  • The Faculty Paradox: Most instructors move directly from their own doctoral or graduate studies into teaching roles without ever having worked in the industry they are teaching, leading to "cognitive biases" regarding how the industry actually operates.

Methods

The paper employs a qualitative situational analysis, using tourism management as a representative case study for application-oriented education. The author performs a diagnostic review of current industry-education integration models and synthesizes a "practical path" forward. This framework is built on four pillars: motivational policy, collaborative governance, pedagogical innovation, and human resource development.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The research is a theoretical and policy-oriented analysis rather than an empirical study based on a specific quantitative dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Double-Qualified" Teacher: One of the paper's most vital points is the need for "double-qualified" (dual-ability) teachers. These are educators who possess both high-level theoretical knowledge and verified practical experience in the tourism industry. Without this, the integration of industry and education remains superficial.
  • Information Asymmetry: A primary reason for failed collaborations is the lack of timely communication. The paper suggests that the "information asymmetric" nature of school-enterprise relations can only be solved through dedicated information-sharing platforms that release teaching trends and industry needs in real-time.
  • Mutual Employment Mechanisms: To solve the staffing crisis, the author proposes a "mutual employment" model where teachers are encouraged to take on temporary roles in tourism enterprises, while industry experts are invited to lead course design and textbook compilation.
  • Risk-Benefit Balancing: For integration to be sustainable, it cannot rely on the goodwill of enterprises alone. The paper emphasizes the need for a "benefit-sharing and risk-sharing mechanism" to ensure that companies see a return on their investment in student training.

Key Results

The author outlines a comprehensive roadmap for reform:

  1. Government Intervention: Recommends tax relief and financial support to lower the "weighed costs" for enterprises engaging in education.
  2. Collaborative Governance: Suggests establishing joint management systems that clarify the "responsibilities, authorities, and participation scales" for both sides.
  3. Curriculum Reform: Advocates for "case teaching" and "project teaching," where students work on actual industry problems rather than abstract scenarios.
  4. Supervision: Proposes the introduction of third-party evaluation institutions to monitor the quality and effect of the integration, ensuring that "application-oriented" isn't just a buzzword.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper is primarily conceptual and descriptive. While it provides a robust theoretical framework, it does not provide quantitative data or longitudinal studies to prove the efficacy of the proposed "practical path."

Future research could focus on:

  • Quantitative Validation: Measuring the impact of "double-qualified" teachers on student employment rates.
  • ROI Analysis: Developing models to calculate the specific economic return for tourism enterprises that participate in deep integration.
  • Scalability: Testing whether this tourism-centric model can be effectively mapped onto other application-oriented fields like engineering or digital media.

Summary updated

Abstract

The main goal of application-oriented universities is to cultivate application-oriented personnel with professional skills and professionalism, and the model of the integration between industry and education is an important way to achieve this goal. This article takes the tourism management as an example to analyze the development status of the integration between industry and education model in the tourism management. In response to the problems such as insufficient driving force for industry-education integration, lack of collaborative governance mechanism, backwardness of collaborative education model, and insufficient construction of teaching staff, a practical path for the integration between industry and education applied in application-oriented universities is proposed, in order to provide references for the personnel training in these universities.
BibTeX
@article{gao2024research,
  author = {Wei Gao},
  title = {{Research on the Model of the Integration between Industry and Education in Application-oriented Universities - Taking the Tourism Management as an Example}},
  journal = {Journal of tourism management.},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.62517/jtm.202413209},
}
Figure