Research on the Load Transfer Law of Cross-Sections of Pile-Supported Reinforced Embankments Based on the Finite Element Method

Xin Wang, Xizhao Wang, Guangqing Yang, Yang Xiang, Da ZhangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how loads are distributed in pile-supported reinforced embankments, crucial for infrastructure on soft soils. By combining field tests and finite element analysis, it reveals how factors like pile length and embankment height influence load transfer, highlighting that pile cap width is the most critical design parameter.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Building stable embankments on soft, compressible soils is a significant engineering challenge. Traditional methods often struggle with the complex interactions between soil, piles, and reinforcing materials. Pile-supported reinforced embankments offer a solution, but understanding precisely how loads are transferred through the system – specifically, the interplay between the "soil arching effect" (where soil above piles forms an arch) and the "membrane effect" (from reinforcing geogrids) – is complex. Existing simplified models don't fully capture these interactions, leading to a need for more comprehensive analysis, especially considering the varying conditions across an embankment's cross-section (from the center to the shoulders).

Methods

The researchers employed a dual approach:

  • Field Testing: A real-world test section of a pile-supported reinforced embankment was instrumented to collect data on pile-soil stress ratios and settlement over time. This provided crucial ground truth.
  • Finite Element Method (FEM): A detailed 2D FEM model was developed using ABAQUS. This model incorporated various soil layers, piles, pile caps, and geosynthetic reinforcement. The model was calibrated against the field test data to ensure its accuracy.
  • Parametric Study: Once validated, the FEM model was used to systematically vary key design parameters (pile length, pile spacing, pile cap width, and embankment height) to analyze their impact on load transfer efficacy and load sharing ratios.
  • Theoretical Comparison: The FEM results were compared against five different established theoretical calculation methods (Chinese Specification, BS8006-1, EBGEO, Nordic Guidelines, and German Standard) to evaluate their applicability and accuracy.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a field test conducted on the Rongwu Expressway in Xiong'an New Area, China. This field test served as the primary dataset for validating the numerical model. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pile Cap Width is King: The study unequivocally shows that the width of the pile cap has the most significant impact on the overall load transfer efficacy. A wider pile cap leads to better load distribution.
  • Shoulder vs. Center: Load transfer efficacy and the "soil arching effect" are strongest at the embankment's center and diminish towards the shoulders. This is attributed to the different stress states and larger geogrid deformation at the shoulders, where the "membrane effect" becomes more pronounced.
  • Interplay of Effects: The "soil arching effect" is the primary mechanism for load transfer, with the "membrane effect" providing supplementary support. The relative contribution of each varies across the cross-section.
  • Differential Settlement Drives Arching: The degree to which the soil arching effect is mobilized is directly linked to the differential settlement between the piles and the soil.
  • Theoretical Method Applicability Varies: Different theoretical calculation methods are more suitable for specific design scenarios. For instance, the Chinese specification and BS8006-1-1 showed good agreement with the simulated results, with specific recommendations for different pile spacing and embankment height conditions.

Key Results

  • Influencing Factors: Increasing pile length, pile cap width, and embankment height, while decreasing pile spacing, generally improves load transfer efficacy.
  • Load Distribution: Load transfer efficacy decreases from the subgrade center towards the shoulder, with a significant drop at the shoulder (2.5-7.5% reduction compared to the center).
  • Load Sharing: The soil arching effect contributes 65-90% of the load at the embankment center and 51-88% at the shoulder.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: Pile cap width was found to be the most sensitive factor influencing load transfer efficacy (SAF = 2.03), followed by pile spacing (SAF = 1.43). Pile length (SAF = 0.17) and embankment height (SAF = 0.27) had less impact.
  • Model Validation: The FEM model's predictions for subgrade settlement closely matched field measurements, with a maximum error of 16% at the shoulder.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D Model: The study used a 2D finite element model, which simplifies the complex 3D behavior of embankments. Future work could extend this to 3D analysis.
  • Specific Site Conditions: The findings are based on a specific site with soft soil conditions. While the principles are general, site-specific variations might influence results.
  • Theoretical Method Nuances: The paper highlights that theoretical methods have different underlying assumptions and applicability ranges. Further research could refine these methods or develop hybrid approaches that better capture the complex interactions.
  • Economic Optimization: While the study identifies key influencing factors, future work could focus on optimizing designs for both performance and cost-effectiveness based on these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Combining field test research with finite element numerical analysis, this paper studies the mechanical behavior of pile-supported reinforced embankments in soft soil areas. We analyze and compare the variation law of load transfer efficacy at the subgrade center, the right side of the centerline, and the road shoulder; the variations of the load sharing ratios of the soil arching effect and the load sharing ratios of the membrane effect; and the load variation law of wide subgrade cross-sections. Then, the model calculation results are compared with the calculation results of the five theoretical methods and the applicability of the various methods is evaluated. The results show that: increasing the pile length, pile cap width, and embankment height and reducing the pile spacing will increase the pile load transfer efficacy; pile cap width has the greatest influence on the load transfer efficacy; regarding the variation law of the load sharing ratios of subgrade cross-sections, the load-sharing ratio of the soil arch effect at the shoulder is smaller than that at the center of the subgrade, indicating that the deformation of the geogrid at the shoulder is large and the membrane effect is significant; and, regarding the load variation law of subgrade cross-sections, from the subgrade center to the shoulder direction, the pile load transfer efficacy decreases gradually and the load transfer efficacy at the shoulder decreases significantly.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022research,
  author = {Xin Wang and Xizhao Wang and Guangqing Yang and Yang Xiang and Da Zhang},
  title = {{Research on the Load Transfer Law of Cross-Sections of Pile-Supported Reinforced Embankments Based on the Finite Element Method}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14137831},
}
Figure