Abstract
This study systematically evaluates the operational efficiency of academic journals in the field of journalism and publishing in China based on the three-stage DEA model, and finds that the efficiency of journals shows significant differentiation characteristics. The research shows that four journals, including Acta Editologica, continuously maintain DEA effectiveness, demonstrating excellent management efficiency. Twelve journals, such as Editors' Friend, have improved their comprehensive efficiency after excluding environmental factors, indicating that their management potential is restricted by external conditions. Four journals, including Editorial Research, have decreased their comprehensive efficiency after excluding environmental factors, indicating that external conditions can promote their management potential. Further analysis reveals that the number of geographical distributions, the citation half-life, and the years of publication are the key environmental factors affecting efficiency. Based on this, the study proposes differentiated improvement strategies: highly efficient journals should deepen digital transformation and establish an intelligent manuscript review system; environmentally sensitive journals need to optimize regional resource allocation and establish a collaborative editing center; and low-efficiency journals should achieve structural reforms through process reengineering and content innovation.
Introduction
Measuring the success of academic journals typically relies on static metrics like Impact Factors or citation counts. However, these figures fail to account for the efficiency with which a journal utilizes its resources—such as publication volume and funding—to achieve its results. Furthermore, a journal's performance is often conflated with external "environmental factors" beyond its immediate management control, such as its age or geographical reach. This research employs a three-stage Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) model to isolate true management efficiency by filtering out environmental variables and random statistical noise, providing a clearer picture of operational excellence in the journalism and publishing sector.
Methodology and Data
The study utilizes a robust Three-Stage DEA Model to evaluate 20 representative Chinese academic journals using data from the "China Science and Technology Journal Citation Reports" (2013–2020).
- Stage 1 (BCC Model): Initial evaluation of comprehensive technical efficiency.
- Stage 2 (SFA Model): Stochastic Frontier Analysis is used to analyze "slacks" against environmental variables (regional distribution, citation half-life, and years in publication), adjusting input data to create a "level playing field."
- Stage 3 (Adjusted BCC): The model is re-run with cleaned data to reveal actual management capability.
The indicators used for these calculations are detailed in the table below:
The Impact of Environmental Factors
The analysis reveals that environmental factors significantly distort perceived efficiency. After adjusting for these variables, 12 journals saw their efficiency scores increase, suggesting their true performance was previously masked by unfavorable external conditions. Conversely, 4 journals saw a decrease, indicating their high status was partially a "dividend" of favorable external factors rather than superior management.
Key findings regarding environmental variables include:
- Geographical Dispersion: High regional distribution of authors and readers actually increases management costs, acting as a drag on efficiency.
- Journal Age: While a long history eventually provides a "time dividend," newer journals face significant initial hurdles.
- Citation Half-Life: A longer half-life for articles generally boosts efficiency, as "classic" content provides a stable output baseline.
Efficiency Evaluation Results
The results highlight a clear differentiation among the journals. Four journals—Acta Editologica, Modern Communication, Journalism & Communication, and News and Writing—emerged as industry benchmarks, maintaining perfect efficiency scores (1.0) across all stages.
As shown in the radar chart, the adjustment in Phase Three reveals the "true" efficiency of several journals. For instance, journals like Editors' Friend showed marked improvement once environmental noise was removed, highlighting latent management potential that was previously suppressed.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The three-stage DEA model provides a more nuanced understanding of journal performance than traditional metrics. High-efficiency journals are encouraged to lead in digital transformation and intelligent review systems. Meanwhile, "environmentally sensitive" journals should focus on optimizing regional resources.
Future research should explore the efficiency of digital tools and apply this model to interdisciplinary journals to better understand how cross-disciplinary "noise" impacts knowledge exchange efficiency. The establishment of a "High-Efficiency Journal Alliance" could facilitate the sharing of management best practices across the industry.
Summary updated