Abstract
Industrial transformation and upgrading are critical components of China's supply-side structural reform under the "new normal" economic phase. Historically, government investment has played a pivotal role in shaping industrial landscapes. However, the Chengdu-Chongqing Economic Zone faces significant challenges due to industrial homogeneity and redundant competition. This paper analyzes the manufacturing structures of Sichuan and Chongqing, highlighting the need for a shift from administrative-led investment to market-oriented "industry guidance funds." By fostering regional division of labor and leveraging market mechanisms, the two regions can transition from rivals to a coordinated industrial cluster, supporting national strategies like the "One Belt and One Road" initiative.
Introduction
The Chengdu-Chongqing Economic Zone stands as a cornerstone of China's western development. As the nation navigates the "new normal"—characterized by a shift from high-speed growth to high-quality development—industrial transformation and upgrading have become paramount. While government investment has historically driven development in these regions, the current model often leads to localized competition rather than regional synergy. This paper investigates the investment cooperation between Sichuan Province and Chongqing Municipality, proposing a new path for manufacturing integration through market-led mechanisms.
The Homogeneity Trap
A central challenge in the Chengdu-Chongqing Economic Zone is the "homogeneity trap." Analysis of industrial data from 1978 to 2015 reveals a persistent and problematic overlap in manufacturing portfolios. The industrial similarity coefficient between the two regions started at a high of 0.83 in 1978. Although it saw fluctuations over the decades, it remained at 0.65 as of 2015.
Notably, a "bounce" effect occurred between 2005 and 2008, where similarity increased despite previous efforts at diversification. This overlap is particularly evident in the electronics and automobile sectors. The Chengdu-Chongqing Economic Zone encompasses 39 of the 40 national industrial categories, creating a comprehensive but highly redundant industrial base. Such redundancy leads to inefficient resource allocation and prevents the formation of a specialized regional division of labor.
The Automobile Industry Paradox
The automobile industry serves as a prime example of failed regional synergy. Chongqing is a national powerhouse in auto manufacturing, hosting 11 of the top 50 industrial enterprises in the region. Ideally, Sichuan would focus on the upstream supply chain—producing parts and components to support Chongqing's assembly lines. Instead, Sichuan pursued its own finished-automobile industry, introducing major players like Toyota to compete directly with Chongqing. This "zero-sum" competition exemplifies how administrative boundaries can hinder economic logic, leading to redundant investments that fail to enhance the region's overall competitiveness.
A New Investment Paradigm: Industry Guidance Funds
Traditional inter-governmental cooperation has relied heavily on fiscal funds and administrative mandates. However, fiscal funds are inherently tied to local administrative jurisdictions, making cross-regional investment difficult and often incentivizing local protectionism. Between 2001 and 2016, multiple cooperation agreements were signed, yet a standardized, efficient system for coordination remains elusive.
To break these silos, we propose the "Industry Guidance Fund" model. In this approach:
- Seed Capital: The government provides initial funding to signal strategic priorities.
- Market Management: Funds are managed by professional market entities rather than government bureaus.
- Cross-Border Investment: These funds can transcend administrative borders, investing in projects based on economic viability and regional strategic fit.
This shift from "administration" to "capital" allows for a more flexible and efficient allocation of resources across the economic zone, bypassing the limitations of local fiscal budgets.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
Realizing the transformation and upgrading of manufacturing in Sichuan and Chongqing requires moving beyond sporadic cooperation. Future policy work should focus on:
- Institutionalization: Establishing a standardized system for regular mutual visits and coordination conferences to ensure long-term policy consistency.
- Innovation Clusters: Exploring the "Guang'an model" as a potential template for multi-level cooperation within the economic zone, where different cities find specific roles within a broader value chain.
- Breaking Administrative Barriers: Addressing the institutional obstacles that prevent local governments from investing across borders.
By leveraging market mechanisms to guide government investment, the Chengdu-Chongqing Economic Zone can overcome its historical friction and emerge as a unified engine for China's future growth.
Summary updated