Research on the Influence of the Material Removal Profile of a Spherical Polishing Tool on the Mid-Spatial Frequency Errors of Optical Surfaces

Zhaohao He, Kuo Hai, Kailong Li, Jiahao Yu, Lingwei Wu, Lin Zhang, Xing Su, Lisheng Cai, Wen Huang, Wei HangMicromachines 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the shape of a polishing tool's material removal profile affects mid-spatial frequency (MSF) errors in optical surfaces. They found that a Gaussian-like removal profile significantly reduces MSF errors compared to "W" or trapezoidal shapes. The researchers also developed an optimized path spacing strategy to balance MSF error reduction with polishing efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-precision optical components are crucial for advanced technologies like lithography and space telescopes. Polishing is the final step to achieve this precision. While sub-aperture polishing with elastic spherical tools is efficient and conforms well to curved surfaces, it often introduces mid-spatial frequency (MSF) errors. These errors, which are essentially ripples on the surface, can degrade the performance of optical systems by causing scattering and reducing image contrast. Existing research has focused on optimizing polishing paths or tool design, but this paper specifically examines the influence of the material removal profile itself on MSF error generation and proposes a method to mitigate it.

Methods

The core of this research lies in modeling and simulating the material removal process.

  • Material Removal Modeling: They used a model based on the Preston equation, which relates material removal depth to pressure, relative velocity, and dwell time. This model was adapted to describe the material removal profile of a spherical polishing tool.
  • Convolution Effect Analysis: The paper highlights that MSF errors arise from the overlapping of material removal "ribbons" created by adjacent polishing paths. This overlap, governed by the convolution of the tool's influence function (TIF) and the dwell time, leads to periodic ripples.
  • Material Removal Profile Simulation: They simulated different material removal profile shapes (Gaussian-like, "W" shape, and trapezoidal) by varying the precession angle of the polishing tool. These profiles were then used in simulations to predict MSF error generation.
  • Path Spacing Optimization: Recognizing that smaller path spacing reduces MSF errors but increases polishing time, they developed an optimization method. This method iteratively finds the largest path spacing that keeps the root-mean-square (RMS) error below a desired threshold, balancing efficiency and error control.
  • Experimental Validation: The simulation results were validated through experiments on fused silica and single-crystal silicon using a six-axis CNC machine and a Zygo laser interferometer for surface measurement.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from their own polishing experiments and simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shape Matters: The shape of the material removal profile is a critical, often overlooked, factor in MSF error generation. A smooth, Gaussian-like profile leads to more uniform material removal and significantly fewer ripples than sharper, more complex profiles like the "W" shape.
  • Convolution is Key: The paper clearly illustrates how the overlapping of individual polishing paths (a convolution effect) is the direct cause of MSF errors. Understanding this overlap is crucial for controlling ripples.
  • Serrated RMS Trend: The RMS error doesn't decrease smoothly as path spacing gets smaller. Instead, it exhibits a "serrated" trend, indicating that specific path spacings can be more effective than others, even at smaller values. This observation is the foundation for their optimization strategy.
  • Balancing Act: Achieving high precision doesn't always mean the smallest possible path spacing. An optimized path spacing can maintain acceptable MSF error levels while drastically improving polishing efficiency, a critical factor in manufacturing.

Key Results

  • Profile Performance: Simulations and experiments showed that the Gaussian-like removal profile resulted in significantly lower MSF errors (e.g., RMS values of 17.39 nm vs. 32.56 nm for the "W" shape at 1mm path spacing).
  • Path Spacing Optimization: The proposed optimization method successfully identified a path spacing (e.g., 0.4 mm) that kept RMS errors below 2 nm for fused silica, while allowing for greater efficiency compared to smaller spacings.
  • Experimental Verification: Experiments on single-crystal silicon confirmed that the optimized path spacing strategy, combined with a Gaussian-like profile, effectively controlled MSF errors (RMS of 1.33 nm at 0.36 mm path spacing) while maintaining polishing efficiency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study primarily focuses on spherical polishing tools and specific materials (fused silica, single-crystal silicon).
  • The optimization method relies on pre-determined RMS thresholds, which might need adjustment for different applications.
  • The "W" shape removal profile, while shown to be less effective, was still investigated, and its specific characteristics might be relevant in other contexts.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest applying the path spacing optimization method to other materials and polishing scenarios.
  • Further investigation into the dynamic behavior of the polishing process and its impact on the removal profile could be beneficial.
  • Exploring more complex material removal models that account for factors like tool wear or slurry dynamics could enhance prediction accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Elastic spherical polishing tools effectively conform to the polishing surface and exhibit high efficiency in the removal of materials, so they are extensively used in the sub-aperture polishing stages of optical components. However, their processing is often accompanied by significant mid-spatial frequency (MSF) errors, which critically degrade the performance of optical systems. To suppress the MSF errors generated during polishing with spherical tools, this study investigates the influence factor of MSF errors during the polishing process through an analysis of the convolution effect in material removal. A material removal profile model is established, and a uniform removal simulation is conducted to assess the influence of different shape material removal profiles on MSF errors. Simulation and experimental results show that a Gaussian-like shape material removal profile is more effective in suppressing the MSF errors during polishing compared to the "W" and trapezoidal shape material removal profiles. In addition, based on the characteristics of the RMS decreasing in a serrated trend with the decrease in path spacing, a path spacing optimization method considering the polishing efficiency is proposed to improve the polishing efficiency while controlling the MSF errors, and the effectiveness of the path spacing optimization method is verified by comparing the MSF error at the maximum theoretical path spacing and the path spacing that is less than this. Finally, the path spacing optimization method is used to polish single-crystal silicon to further illustrate its practicality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2024research,
  author = {Zhaohao He and Kuo Hai and Kailong Li and Jiahao Yu and Lingwei Wu and Lin Zhang and Xing Su and Lisheng Cai and Wen Huang and Wei Hang},
  title = {{Research on the Influence of the Material Removal Profile of a Spherical Polishing Tool on the Mid-Spatial Frequency Errors of Optical Surfaces}},
  booktitle = {Micromachines},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/mi15050654},
}
Figure