Research on the Influence of International Cooperation of ESI Highly Cited Papers Based on CNCI

Ying Tan, Yan Zhang, Mei Tang, Wanxin Zhao2023 · DOI

Abstract: ESI highly cited papers represent the top level of global scientific research papers, and their influence also represents the scientific research strength of institutions. Taking the highly cited papers of Northwest Polytechnical University (NWPU) as a case study, this paper analyzes the distribution and impact of international cooperation using the Category Normalized Citation Impact (CNCI) metric to determine if global partnerships consistently yield higher research quality.

Introduction

In the competitive landscape of global academia, "Highly Cited Papers"—those ranking in the top 1% of their field—serve as a primary indicator of research excellence. Institutions frequently prioritize international collaboration as a strategic lever to increase these outputs. However, the actual impact of such partnerships is often obscured by traditional metrics like raw citation counts, which fail to account for field-specific citation behaviors or the age of a publication. This study addresses this gap by utilizing the Category Normalized Citation Impact (CNCI) to evaluate whether international cooperation truly enhances the quality of high-level research at NWPU.

Methodology

The study employs a bibliometric analysis centered on the CNCI metric, which normalizes a paper's impact against the global average for its specific field, publication year, and document type. A CNCI of 1.0 denotes the global average; values exceeding this indicate superior influence.

Data was retrieved from the Web of Science (WOS) and Essential Science Indicators (ESI) for a 10-year window (2012–2022), totaling 622 highly cited papers. The analysis utilized Clarivate’s InCites platform, employing an equal weighting method where each participating institution receives one point per paper to ensure an unbiased assessment of collaborative contributions.

Results and Analysis

The Collaboration Paradox

A primary finding of the study is the "Domestic Edge" paradox. While internationalization is often equated with higher quality, the data reveals that NWPU’s international collaborations (CNCI 12.08) actually underperform compared to its domestic (CNCI 13.13) and internal (CNCI 14.84) partnerships.

Figure 1: Distribution of collaboration types and their respective CNCI values at NWPU.

As shown in Figure 1, internal collaborations within the university yield the highest normalized impact, suggesting that deep, localized expertise may sometimes outweigh the benefits of broad international reach.

The Multilateral Multiplier

While simple international partnerships (unilateral) are the most frequent, they do not necessarily provide the highest impact. The study identifies a "multilateral multiplier" effect: as the number of collaborating countries increases, so does the normalized citation impact.

Figure 5: Impact of collaboration complexity on CNCI.

According to the data in Figure 5, papers involving four or more countries achieve a significantly higher CNCI (14.45) compared to unilateral or bilateral efforts. This suggests that complex, multi-country networks are more effective at driving global research influence than simple bilateral exchanges.

Geographically, the USA remains the most frequent partner (104 papers), but partnerships with Canada (CNCI 14.90), Japan (CNCI 14.85), and Italy (CNCI 14.41) yield higher normalized impact scores. Disciplinarily, while Materials Science and Engineering dominate in volume, the highest impact scores are found in Mathematics (CNCI 16.54) and Physics (CNCI 15.42).

Conclusion

The analysis indicates that while international cooperation is a vital component of NWPU's research strategy, its effectiveness is nuanced. To maximize global influence, the university should shift its focus from the quantity of international papers to the quality and complexity of partnerships. Specifically, fostering multilateral collaborations and targeting high-impact regional hubs can provide a more substantial boost to institutional prestige than broad, unilateral internationalization. Future efforts should also aim to bridge the gap in less internationalized fields like the Social Sciences by leveraging successful models from the physical sciences.

Summary updated

Abstract

ESI highly cited papers represent the top level of global scientific research papers, and their influence also represents the scientific research strength of institutions. Taking the highly cited papers of Northwest Polytechnical University in May 2022 as an example, this paper analyzes the distribu
BibTeX
@misc{tan2023research,
  author = {Ying Tan and Yan Zhang and Mei Tang and Wanxin Zhao},
  title = {{Research on the Influence of International Cooperation of ESI Highly Cited Papers Based on CNCI}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.4108/eai.6-1-2023.2330262},
}
Figure