Research on the Influence of Carbonation on the Content and State of Chloride Ions and the Following Corrosion Resistance of Steel Bars in Cement Paste

Hui Wang, Ailian Zhang, Linchun Zhang, Junzhe Liu, Yan Han, Jianmin WangCoatings 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how carbonation affects chloride ion behavior and steel bar corrosion in cement paste, particularly when using fly ash (FA) and blast furnace slag (BFS) as admixtures. The findings reveal that carbonation generally increases free chloride ions, accelerating corrosion, but higher BFS content (over 20%) can enhance corrosion resistance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reinforced concrete, a ubiquitous construction material, is susceptible to corrosion, especially in aggressive environments. Chloride ions are a primary culprit, attacking the protective passive film on steel bars and accelerating their degradation. While the alkaline nature of concrete typically offers protection, carbonation, driven by increased atmospheric CO2, reduces this alkalinity, making the steel more vulnerable. Furthermore, the interaction between carbonation and chloride ions, and how this impacts the state (free vs. bound) of chloride ions within the cement matrix, remains an area needing deeper understanding. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining how carbonation influences chloride ion distribution and, consequently, the corrosion resistance of embedded steel bars, especially when mineral admixtures like fly ash and blast furnace slag are incorporated.

Methods

The researchers prepared cement paste samples with varying proportions of fly ash (FA) and blast furnace slag (BFS), along with a control group. These samples were then subjected to either standard curing or a carbonation environment for an extended period (240 days).

Key experimental techniques included:

  • Chloride Ion Analysis: The concentration of both free and solidified chloride ions was determined. Free chloride ions were extracted using deionized water and analyzed with a chlorine and sulfate analyzer. Solidified chloride ions were calculated by subtracting free chloride from the total added chloride.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): This technique was used to analyze the crystal structures of the cement paste samples, identifying phases like calcium hydroxide (CH) and calcium carbonate (CaCO3), and how they change under carbonation and with admixture additions.
  • Electrical Resistance and AC Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS): These electrochemical methods were employed to assess the corrosion resistance of steel bars embedded within the cement paste. Higher electrical resistance and specific EIS responses are indicative of better corrosion resistance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes self-prepared cement paste samples with controlled compositions and curing conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Admixture Influence on Chloride Binding: Both FA and BFS, due to their large specific surface areas, initially enhanced the solidification (binding) of chloride ions in cement paste. However, this effect was dose-dependent.
  • BFS's Dual Role: While lower BFS content (below 20%) hindered chloride solidification, higher BFS content (above 20%) actually promoted it, suggesting a complex interaction.
  • Carbonation's Detrimental Effect: Carbonation consistently reduced the amount of solidified chloride ions and increased free chloride ions, thereby accelerating the potential for steel bar corrosion. This is a critical finding, as it highlights how a common environmental factor can exacerbate existing material vulnerabilities.
  • BFS as a Corrosion Protector: Despite the general trend of carbonation increasing corrosion risk, cement pastes with BFS content higher than 20% demonstrated improved corrosion resistance for the embedded steel bars. This suggests that BFS can offer a protective mechanism that counteracts some of the negative effects of carbonation.
  • Electrochemical Methods as Indicators: The study successfully correlated electrical resistance and EIS measurements with the corrosion resistance of steel bars, validating these techniques for assessing material performance under corrosive conditions.

Key Results

  • Chloride Ion Distribution: Carbonation led to a decrease in solidified chloride ions and an increase in free chloride ions.
  • Admixture Effects:
    • FA addition generally increased free chloride ions and decreased solidified chloride ions.
  • BFS addition showed a more complex behavior: free chloride ions initially increased then decreased with increasing BFS content, while solidified chloride ions showed the opposite trend.
  • BFS content > 20% promoted chloride solidification.
  • Corrosion Resistance Ranking: Based on electrical resistance and EIS, the corrosion resistance of the specimens decreased in the order: Carbonation-BFS > Carbonation-FA > Plain (standard cured) > Carbonation-Plain. This indicates that BFS-modified concrete under carbonation offered the best protection, while plain concrete under carbonation was the most vulnerable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complex BFS Behavior: The paper notes that the complex reasons behind the solidified rate's behavior with BFS under carbonation require further study.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest that further investigation into the complex reasons for the observed trends, particularly concerning BFS, is warranted. The study also implicitly points towards the potential of optimized BFS content for enhancing the durability of concrete structures in carbonated environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the changes of free chloride ion concentration and bound chloride concentration in cement paste with different total and proportion of mineral admixtures under carbonation were studied. Moreover, the following corrosion resistance of steel bars buried in cement paste under carbonation was researched by testing the electrical resistance and alternating current (AC) impedance spectroscopy of reinforced cement paste. Results indicated that fly ash and granulated blast furnace slag powder with the content less than 20% by mass ratio of total binder hindered the solidification of chloride ions in cement-based materials, and blast furnace slag powder with the content higher than 20% promoted the solidification of chloride ions in cement paste. The carbonation effect was able to decrease the amount of solidified chloride ion and increase the amount of free chloride ions leading to accelerating the corrosion of reinforcement. Meanwhile, the blast furnace slag powder with the content higher than 20% could effectively promote the corrosion resistance of steel bars.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020research,
  author = {Hui Wang and Ailian Zhang and Linchun Zhang and Junzhe Liu and Yan Han and Jianmin Wang},
  title = {{Research on the Influence of Carbonation on the Content and State of Chloride Ions and the Following Corrosion Resistance of Steel Bars in Cement Paste}},
  booktitle = {Coatings},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/coatings10111071},
}
Figure