Research on the deformation laws of buildings adjacent to shield tunnels in clay strata

Liping Cai, Kang Shi, Feng Jiang, Guanyi Chen, Zhiyong Xiao, Chengcheng Zheng, Shuai Zhang, Yue WuScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how shield tunneling for the Beijing Metro Line 17 impacts nearby buildings in clay-heavy soil. By combining real-world field monitoring with 3D numerical simulations, the researchers identified that tunnel spacing is the most critical factor affecting building stability, followed by burial depth and the soil's internal friction angle.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As urban areas become more crowded, engineers are increasingly forced to build subway tunnels in close proximity to existing infrastructure. Shield tunneling is often preferred for its efficiency, but in "soft" clay strata, the excavation process inevitably disturbs the surrounding soil. This disturbance leads to surface settlement, building inclination (tilting), and twisting (distortion), which can cause structural cracks or even collapse.

The authors sought to move beyond simple observations to establish the "deformation laws"—the mathematical and physical patterns—that govern how specific engineering and geological factors influence building damage. Their goal was to provide a reliable framework for predicting risks and implementing control measures during construction.

Methods

The researchers employed a dual-track approach:

  1. Field Monitoring: They collected detailed survey and monitoring data from a section of the Beijing Metro Line 17, specifically tracking a 6-story reinforced concrete office building located just 9.2 meters from the tunnel path.
  2. Numerical Simulation: Using a 3D finite element model (comprising over 160,000 elements), they simulated the excavation process. They used the Moulton-Coulomb model for soil behavior and a linear elastic model for the building and tunnel segments.
  3. Sensitivity Analysis: A key feature of the paper is the use of a sensitivity coefficient to rank which variables (burial depth, tunnel spacing, and internal friction angle) have the greatest impact on building settlement.

Datasets

The study relies on a primary dataset generated from the Beijing Metro Line 17 project (Ciqu Station to Ciqu North Station). This includes:

  • Geological drilling data (identifying 9 distinct soil layers).
  • Construction monitoring data (surface settlement, building tilt, and soil pressure).
  • Shield machine parameters (thrust force, torque, and boring speed).

No external public benchmarks were used; the study serves as a site-specific validation of numerical models against real-world engineering data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "W-Shape" Curve: For twin-tunnel construction, the surface settlement doesn't follow a simple trough. Instead, it forms a "W" shape, with the maximum settlement occurring directly above the center line of the tunnels.
  • Dynamic Tilt: Building inclination isn't a static result of construction; it's a dynamic wave. The longitudinal tilt increases as the shield machine approaches and reaches a peak when the machine is roughly 76.8 meters into the excavation before slightly receding.
  • Twisting vs. Depth: Interestingly, the "twisting" (distortion) of a building isn't necessarily worse at greater depths. Instead, it is primarily driven by the differential settlement—the difference in how much one corner of a building sinks compared to another—which is most volatile when the tunnel is at a specific distance from the foundation.
  • The Hierarchy of Risk: Through sensitivity analysis, the authors proved that tunnel spacing is the most influential factor on building settlement, followed by burial depth, with the internal friction angle of the soil having the least (though still significant) impact.

Key Results

  • Model Validation: The simulation predicted a maximum settlement of 8.63 mm, while the actual field measurement was 10.12 mm. This 14.7% difference indicates the model is a reliable proxy for real-world conditions.
  • Sensitivity Coefficients: The study quantified the influence of different factors:
  • Spacing: ~2.6 (Highest sensitivity)
    • Burial Depth: ~1.8
    • Internal Friction Angle: ~1.3
  • Critical Intervals: The most dangerous period for building distortion occurs when the shield is in the 48–86.4 meter interval relative to the building, where twisting deformation reaches its peak.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several simplifying assumptions in their model that could be addressed in future research:

  • Soil Complexity: The model assumes soil is homogeneous and isotropic, whereas real-world clay strata are often anisotropic and layered inconsistently.
  • Environmental Factors: The study did not account for groundwater seepage or the "creep" (time-dependent deformation) of the soil, both of which can significantly affect long-term settlement.
  • Building Rigidity: The building was modeled as a linear elastic body; future work could explore non-linear models to better simulate how cracks actually form and propagate in the structure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Earth pressure shields are widely used in tunnel construction due to their low environmental impact and mechanized operations. However, ensuring the stability of the excavation surface during the construction process is crucial. Any instability in the excavation surface can lead to soil destruction, such as body collapse or surface uplift. Additionally, the tunneling process can cause deformation disturbances to nearby buildings. In the case of Beijing Metro Line 17, detailed survey data and construction monitoring data were collected through field surveys and tests. The study combined theoretical analysis and numerical simulations to investigate the impact of shield tunneling in clay layers on neighboring buildings. The focus was on analyzing the physical deformation and the response law of influencing factors, such as stratum parameters and engineering effects on surface settlement, building inclination, and distortion. Furthermore, sensitivity analysis of the deformation impact was conducted, and corresponding measures for deformation control were proposed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cai2024research,
  author = {Liping Cai and Kang Shi and Feng Jiang and Guanyi Chen and Zhiyong Xiao and Chengcheng Zheng and Shuai Zhang and Yue Wu},
  title = {{Research on the deformation laws of buildings adjacent to shield tunnels in clay strata}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-50855-1},
}
Figure