Research on the Construction of a Comprehensive Evaluation Model of Psychological Factors in Coal Mine Workers' Safety: Investigation and Analysis of 1,500 Miners in East China

Junqi Zhu, Xue Wang, Li Yang, Zhiyuan Qin, Jichao Geng, Xuesen ZhangFrontiers in Public Health 2022 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Public Health, develops a comprehensive structural model to evaluate the psychological factors driving safety among coal miners in China’s rapidly evolving economic landscape. By analyzing data from 1,500 miners, the researchers discovered that "emotional attribution"—a sense of belonging and social identity—has surpassed material needs as the most critical factor influencing safety psychology in the modern era.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coal mining remains a high-risk industry where human error is a leading cause of accidents. Traditionally, safety research has focused on "hard" factors like equipment quality or basic "soft" factors like salary and training. However, as China’s economy develops, miners' living standards and safety conditions have improved significantly.

The authors argue that this "new era" has shifted the psychological demands of workers. Old safety models may no longer be accurate because they don't account for how improved material conditions change a worker's priorities. The paper seeks to bridge this gap by identifying the modern "demand structure" of miners and quantifying how environmental factors (like management) and self-regulating factors (like emotional state) interact to produce safe behavior.

Methods

The researchers utilized Koffka’s cognitive psychology theory, which posits that behavior is the result of the interaction between one's behavioral environment and self-regulation.

To quantify this, they employed Second-order Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). While standard factor analysis often looks at variables in isolation, this second-order approach allows for a hierarchical understanding:

  1. 18 Observation Variables: Specific metrics like "salary and welfare," "family relations," and "code of conduct."
  2. 6 Potential Variables: Broader categories including Material Satisfaction, Non-skill Internal Causes, Professionalism, Emotional Attribution, Safety Atmosphere, and Organizational Management.
  3. Comprehensive Model: A 3-tier structure that integrates these factors to see how they influence the overall "Miners’ Safety Psychology."

Datasets

The study is based on a primary dataset collected through a 9-month empirical investigation (2018) involving:

  • Participants: 1,500 coal miners (with 1,170 valid responses) from six different mining enterprises in East China.
  • Sampling Method: A "Probability-Proportional-to-Size" (PPS) sampling method was used to ensure the sample was representative of the 54,000 total workers in those mines.
  • Demographics: The cohort was 86.1% male, largely married (91.2%), and highly experienced, with 88.4% having worked in the industry for over four years.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Shift to Higher-Level Needs: In a major departure from older studies, Emotional Attribution (influencing factor: 0.93) was the most significant driver of safety. This suggests that as basic needs (pay, food) are met, miners' spiritual needs—such as professional identity and a sense of belonging—become the primary motivators for following safety protocols.
  • Management as an Indirect Catalyst: Organizational management (0.89) was the second most influential factor. Interestingly, the model showed that good management doesn't just enforce rules; it has a strong positive "mediation effect" on material satisfaction and internal self-regulation.
  • The "Resilient Miner" Surprise: Contrary to expectations, non-skill internal factors (like physiological state or temporary mood) had the lowest impact (0.29). The authors hypothesize that long-term work in high-pressure environments may have led these miners to develop high levels of emotional stability and physiological adaptability.
  • The Power of Professionalism: Occupational literacy and a sense of responsibility were found to be leading indicators of safety, suggesting that "professionalizing" the workforce is more effective than simple top-down policing.

Key Results

The structural model was validated with strong fit indices (e.g., GFI = 0.925, Chi-square/DOF = 1.637), indicating the model accurately reflects the reality of the survey data.

  • Top Influencer: Emotional Attribution (0.93).
  • Secondary Influencer: Organizational Management (0.89).
  • Strong Impactors: Safety Atmosphere (0.69) and Material Satisfaction (0.63).
  • Weakest Impactor: Non-skill internal factors (0.29).

Qualitatively, the results suggest that "perfect organizational management" can effectively regulate the physiological functions and negative emotions of employees, creating a virtuous cycle of safety.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic Bias: The study focused exclusively on East China. Miners in less developed regions may still prioritize material satisfaction over emotional attribution.
  • Model Non-Uniqueness: While the 3-tier model fits the data well, the authors note that other "model paths" could potentially explain the interactions, and the weight settings are specific to this study's context.
  • Future Directions: The researchers suggest expanding the sample to different regions and mining types (e.g., non-coal) to build a more universal evaluation model. They also recommend that mine managers shift their focus from "punishment-based" management to "service-based" management that fosters social recognition and professional pride.

Summary updated

Abstract

With China's economic and social development entering a new era, the improvement of miners' living standards and safety production conditions in coal mine are bound to have a new impact on the safety needs of miners. In order to explore the structural changes of miners' safety demands in the new era, this research adopts the second-order confirmatory factor analysis method to investigate miners from six coal mining enterprises based on Koffka's cognitive psychology theory. Firstly, according to the interaction between the behavioral environment and the self-regulation of coal miners, six potential variables affecting miners' safety psychology, such as material satisfaction, non-skill internal causes, professionalism, emotional attribution, safety atmosphere, and organizational management, are selected. Then, each potential variable is subdivided into 3 observation variables, for a total of 18 observation variables, and a 3-tier comprehensive structural model of miners' safety psychology is constructed that takes into account both evaluation and path integration. The results showed that, affected by the interaction of various potential variables, the degree and intensity of the influence of each factor on miners' safety psychology were different. Among them, emotional attribution was the most significant factor affecting miners' safety psychology, while the influence of organizational management was slightly less important than emotional attribution. Organizational management had a positive impact on material satisfaction and non-skill internal factors. Occupational literacy, material satisfaction, and safety atmosphere had strong impacts on miners' safety psychology. But the impact of non-skill factors on miners' safety psychology was lower than other factors, which is different to previous studies on this aspect.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2022research,
  author = {Junqi Zhu and Xue Wang and Li Yang and Zhiyuan Qin and Jichao Geng and Xuesen Zhang},
  title = {{Research on the Construction of a Comprehensive Evaluation Model of Psychological Factors in Coal Mine Workers' Safety: Investigation and Analysis of 1,500 Miners in East China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.849733},
}
Figure