TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel five-dimensional sustainability evaluation framework for China's coal supply chain, specifically designed to align with the "dual circulation" economic strategy. By employing a multi-granularity unbalanced decision-making approach combined with TOPSIS, the study provides a scientific method to assess and improve the sustainability of this critical industry, offering actionable insights for policy and practice.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China's economic growth is shifting towards a higher-quality, intensive model, encapsulated by the "dual circulation" strategy, which emphasizes domestic demand while integrating with international markets. This paradigm shift necessitates a re-evaluation of key industrial supply chains, including coal, which is a cornerstone of China's energy sector. Existing sustainability evaluations for the coal supply chain are often limited in scope, lack systematic rigor, or are not fully adapted to the new "dual circulation" context. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a comprehensive and scientifically grounded evaluation system that considers both domestic and international dimensions, ultimately promoting a more sustainable and resilient coal supply chain.
Methods
The core methodological contribution lies in the development of a novel evaluation framework and model. The authors propose a five-dimensional sustainability evaluation index system for the coal supply chain: Economy, Innovation, Green, Coordination, and Safety. This system comprises five first-level indicators and twenty-five second-level indicators, designed to capture the complexities of the coal supply chain within the "dual circulation" context.
To determine the weights of these indicators, the paper employs a sophisticated approach:
- Multi-granularity Unbalanced Decision-Making: This method is used to handle linguistic variables and the inherent uncertainty and differing cognitive levels of multiple experts. It allows for the conversion of diverse linguistic assessments into a consistent format.
- TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution): This multi-criteria decision-making technique is then applied to rank the alternatives (in this case, the evaluation indicators) based on their proximity to an ideal solution and distance from a negative-ideal solution.
The paper also incorporates a revision of index importance based on expert scoring of "core competitiveness" and "degree of domestic circulation," further refining the weights.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on expert evaluations rather than pre-existing datasets for its empirical analysis.
Key Insights and Ideas
- "Dual Circulation" as a Guiding Principle: The paper successfully integrates the "dual circulation" strategy into the sustainability evaluation framework, recognizing that domestic market strength and international integration are intertwined for the coal sector's future.
- Innovation as a Primary Driver: The evaluation highlights "Innovation" as the most critical dimension for the coal supply chain's sustainability, underscoring its role in driving efficiency, green development, and risk management.
- Interconnectedness of Dimensions: The five dimensions (Economy, Innovation, Green, Coordination, Safety) are presented as interconnected and mutually reinforcing, suggesting that improvements in one area can positively impact others.
- Expert Consensus on Key Indicators: The empirical study reveals specific indicators within each dimension that are deemed most crucial for sustainability, such as R&D investment, talent attraction, sustainable development capacity, and coal supply stability.
- Balancing Domestic and International Aspects: The framework explicitly considers both domestic market dynamics (e.g., asset stock, domestic circulation) and international engagement (e.g., transnational operations, foreign investment), reflecting the "dual circulation" strategy.
Key Results
The study's empirical research, conducted on a coal supply chain in central China, yielded the following key results:
- Prioritized Dimensions: The importance of the first-level indicators was ranked as: Innovation > Economy > Green > Safety > Coordination.
- Top Priority Indicators: The most critical second-level indicators identified for immediate attention were:
- Innovation: R&D investment (0.1027) and attracting high-caliber talent (0.0977).
- Economy: Sustainable development capacity (0.0879).
- Green: Major air pollutant emissions and carbon emission levels (0.0490).
- Safety: Coal supply stability (0.0531).
- Coordination: Degree of upstream and downstream information connectivity (0.0361).
- Actionable Recommendations: Based on these findings, the paper proposes specific policy recommendations, such as optimizing talent policies, increasing R&D investment, focusing on core competitiveness, accelerating breakthroughs in clean coal technologies, and enhancing information sharing platforms.
Limitations and Future Work
- Expert Dependency: The methodology relies heavily on expert evaluations, which, while structured by multi-granularity decision-making, are inherently subjective. The accuracy of the results is contingent on the quality and representativeness of the expert panel.
- Data Availability: The paper does not present specific quantitative data for the coal supply chain beyond expert assessments, limiting direct comparison with objective performance metrics.
- Generalizability: While the study focuses on a central China coal supply chain, further research could explore the applicability of this framework to other regions or different types of energy supply chains.
- Dynamic Nature: The authors acknowledge the dynamic nature of the coal industry and the evolving "dual circulation" strategy, suggesting that continuous updates and refinements to the evaluation system may be necessary. Future work could involve longitudinal studies to track changes in sustainability performance over time and explore the impact of specific policy interventions.
Summary updated