Research on situation assessment of active distribution networks considering cyberattacks

June Li, Jiaqi Liang, Quanying Liu, Donglian Qi, Jianliang Zhang, Yangrong ChenFrontiers in Energy Research 2022 · DOI

Abstract

With the rapid development of integrated energy systems, the large-scale and high-permeability access of distributed generations (DGs) is transforming traditional distribution networks into active distribution networks (ADNs). This increased complexity also increases vulnerabilities to cyberattacks. It is a new challenge to evaluate the situation of an ADN to support grid control decision-making under potential attack conditions. This paper proposes a situation assessment method for ADNs considering cyberattacks. The method consists of two parts: 1) An index system including DG stability, security risk under cyberattacks, and traditional safety metrics. 2) An operating situation assessment method based on the entropy weight method and grey correlation analysis. The framework is verified using 12 attack scenarios on a modified IEEE 33-node standard distribution system.

Introduction: The Vulnerability of Modern Grids

Traditional distribution networks were characterized by simple, unidirectional power flow from substations to consumers. Modern ADNs are far more complex, featuring bidirectional flows from Distributed Generations (DGs) like solar and wind, alongside controllable loads (CLs) like smart appliances and EV chargers.

While this complexity improves efficiency, it creates a massive "attack surface." Malicious actors can exploit communication protocols to tamper with DG outputs or manipulate household loads, potentially causing voltage collapses or frequency oscillations. Existing grid assessment tools are often not designed to evaluate operational safety specifically under the lens of an active cyberattack. There is a critical need to translate "network anomalies" into "operational risk levels" to help grid operators make split-second decisions.

Methodology: A Multi-Dimensional Assessment Framework

The authors developed a two-part assessment engine designed to quantify grid health in real-time.

1. The Multi-Dimensional Index System

Instead of just tracking whether the lights are on, the system monitors three categories of data to provide a holistic view of the grid:

  • Safety Indexes: Traditional metrics like voltage qualification rates and load rates.
  • DG Stability: Metrics for output volatility and penetration rates.
  • Cyber-Risk Indexes: A novel addition called "Mutation Severity." This measures sudden, unnatural spikes or drops in power supply and load that typically signal a malicious override rather than a natural fluctuation (like a cloud passing over a solar farm).
The Situation Assessment Index System for ADNs, highlighting safety, DG stability, and cyber-risk metrics.

2. The Assessment Algorithm

The framework uses the Entropy Weight Method to objectively assign "importance" to each index, ensuring that if a specific metric starts behaving wildly, it automatically carries more weight in the final risk score. The core of the evaluation is Grey Correlation Analysis, which compares the current state of the grid against a "normal operation" reference scenario. This allows the system to assign a risk grade from 0 (Normal) to 5 (Critical).

Experimental Setup: The IEEE 33-Node Testbed

The study utilizes the IEEE 33-node standard distribution system as its testing ground. To modernize it for the ADN era, the authors modified the simulation by connecting Photovoltaic (PV) arrays to nodes 18 and 22 and adding micro gas turbine units to node 33.

The modified IEEE 33-node standard distribution system used to simulate various cyberattack scenarios.

Twelve distinct attack scenarios were established, ranging from simple DG removals to coordinated strikes that simultaneously cut power generation while spiking consumer demand.

Key Results and Insights

The framework successfully categorized the 12 attack scenarios into risk levels:

  • Critical Threats (Level 5): Scenarios involving the synchronous removal of all DGs or coordinated attacks (cutting DGs while increasing load) reached the highest risk level.
  • Location-Dependent Risk: The results highlight that where an attack happens matters. Removing a DG far from the main power source is significantly riskier than removing one close to it, as distant nodes have a more critical task in maintaining local power balance.
  • Quantifiable Deviation: The correlation degree ($r$) provided a clear numerical scale. For example, a normal grid has an $r$ of 1.0, while the most severe attack dropped the correlation to 0.357.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research reinforces that in modern infrastructure, cybersecurity and operational safety are no longer separate silos. While the current model focuses on data integrity attacks, future work will explore "Availability" attacks (like DDoS) and transition from static snapshots to situation projection—predicting where the grid will be in the next 10–30 minutes to provide even earlier warnings.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid development of integrated energy system, the large-scale and high-permeability access of distributed generations (DGs) is making the distribution networks develop into active distribution networks (ADNs). The increased complexity of ADNs also increases the vulnerabilities for cyberattacks. It is a new challenge how to evaluate the situation of an ADN so as to support the decision-making of grid control policies in the condition of cyberattacks probably occur. Hence, in this paper, we proposed a method of situation assessment for ADNs considering cyberattacks. This method is aggregated by two parts. 1) An index system is presented, which includes the indexes of DGs stability, the indexes of security risk considering cyberattacks along with the traditional safety indexes. 2) The entropy weight method is used to assign weights to each index, and taking the normal operation status of ADNs as the reference scenario, an operating situation assessment method for ADNs is proposed based on grey correlation analysis method. Finally, in order to verify the effectiveness of the proposed index system and assessment method, 12 attack scenarios are established from three categories: attacks on DGs, attacks on controllable loads and attacks on both of them, and the situation of the ADN, a case based on IEEE 33-node standard distribution system, is evaluated under each scenario.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022research,
  author = {June Li and Jiaqi Liang and Quanying Liu and Donglian Qi and Jianliang Zhang and Yangrong Chen},
  title = {{Research on situation assessment of active distribution networks considering cyberattacks}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.971725},
}
Figure