Research on safety early warning of abnormal A-annular pressure of “three-high” gas wells based on data mining

Hongqiao Yan, Junliang Qi, Shun-Cheng Wu, Shun‐Yi Wang, B. T. ZhongFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a dynamic early-warning strategy for "three-high" gas wells that identifies abnormal pressure build-up in the A-annulus—the space between the production tubing and casing. By using data mining to filter out "normal" thermal fluctuations, the proposed method can detect potential well integrity failures up to 82 hours earlier than traditional monitoring systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the oil and gas industry, "three-high" wells—those characterized by High Pressure (HP), High Temperature (HT), and High Hydrogen Sulfide (HHS) content—are among the most dangerous to operate. A critical indicator of well health is the pressure in the A-annulus. While some pressure change is normal (caused by the "physical reaction" of thermal expansion as hot gas flows), abnormal pressure often signals a breach in the wellbore's safety barriers, such as a leak in the production casing or tubing.

Current industry standards rely on Distributed Control Systems (DCS), which typically use static thresholds (e.g., triggering an alarm only when pressure hits 80% of the well's rated capacity). The problem is that by the time these thresholds are reached, a major safety incident may already be inevitable. The authors sought a way to move from reactive monitoring to proactive, trend-based early warning.

Methods

The authors developed a data mining strategy that focuses on the relationship between instantaneous gas volume, wellhead temperature, and annular pressure. Their approach follows a multi-step logical filter:

  1. Stability Check: The system first calculates the variance ($S_1, S_2$) of gas volume and wellhead temperature over a specific period ($T$). If these values are fluctuating wildly (during well opening or adjustment), the model waits. It only proceeds when the well is in a "stable" state (stable production or shutdown).
  2. Trend Analysis: Once stability is confirmed, the model uses the Least Squares Method to fit a trend line to the A-annular pressure data.
  3. Derivative Calculation: The system calculates the derivative ($\alpha$) of this trend line. If the derivative is positive ($\alpha > 0$) while the other parameters are stable, it indicates an abnormal upward pressure trend that cannot be explained by thermal expansion.
  4. Optimization Loop: The framework includes a feedback mechanism where field technicians verify warnings. This data is used to adjust the variance limits ($\delta_1, \delta_2$) and the analysis period ($T$) to reduce false positives and improve accuracy over time.

Datasets

The study utilized historical production data from a specific well, identified as well 08#, spanning from May 2015 to May 2016.

  • Sample 1: Data from a stable production phase (July 2015) where pressure rose from ~30 MPa to ~46 MPa over 434 hours.
  • Sample 2: Data from a shutdown period (September 2015) where pressure rose from ~40 MPa to ~56 MPa.

These real-world "abnormal" samples were used to benchmark the new algorithm against existing DCS strategies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Filtering the "Noise" of Physics: The core innovation isn't just detecting a pressure rise, but identifying a rise that shouldn't be happening based on the laws of thermodynamics. By ensuring gas volume and temperature are stable first, the model effectively filters out "normal" pressure changes caused by thermal expansion.
  • The Value of Time: In high-risk environments, the difference between a controlled maintenance shutdown and a catastrophic blowout is measured in hours. The shift from "threshold-based" to "trend-based" logic buys operators days of lead time.
  • Dynamic vs. Static: Unlike traditional systems that require a fixed "danger" number, this model is dynamic. It looks for the symptom of a failure (the rate of change) rather than waiting for the result of a failure (high pressure).

Key Results

The proposed strategy significantly outperformed the traditional DCS approach in head-to-head testing:

  • Earlier Detection: For "Abnormal Sample 2," the traditional DCS system only triggered an alarm after 106 hours. The data mining strategy identified the trend in just 24 hours—providing an 82-hour head start for safety interventions.
  • Sensitivity: In "Abnormal Sample 1," the pressure never actually hit the 56 MPa DCS threshold, meaning the traditional system failed to discover the abnormality entirely. The new strategy successfully flagged it.
  • Production Safety: The authors demonstrated that by setting the analysis period ($T$) to 24 hours, they could reliably identify leaks while maintaining a manageable rate of false alarms through the optimization mechanism.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a significant limitation: the current model is only suitable for stable production and shutdown phases. During transient phases—such as opening a well, closing it, or adjusting production levels—the relationship between temperature and pressure is too complex to be modeled by simple variance and linear trends.

Future research is needed to develop more sophisticated quantitative models that can handle these "unstable" transition periods, potentially using more advanced machine learning techniques to account for the non-linear thermal dynamics of the wellbore.

Summary updated

Abstract

A major safety accident will be triggered when the A-annular pressure value of high pressure, high productivity and high sulfur gas well exceeded the maximum allowable value. The A-annular pressure value of high pressure high productivity and high sulfur gas well once exceeded the allowable value will trigger a major safety accident. Therefore, this paper proposed a data mining based the gas well early warning strategy by analyzing the annular pressure mechanism and the change in the pattern of instantaneous gas volume, well temperature, and annular pressure in various conditions. To summarize, the law of gas well abnormal A-annular pressure is aimed at constructing a gas well safety warning rule for gas well stable production stage and shutdown period where the initial parameters setting in the early warning rule and adjustment optimization mechanism is also determined. Lastly, with the use of historical abnormal samples, the gas well early warning strategy bought up in this paper was verified. The example shown that compared with the traditional DCS system warning strategy, the gas well safety early warning strategy can identify the abnormal A-annular pressure phenomenon 82 h in advance thus achieving production safety management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yan2023research,
  author = {Hongqiao Yan and Junliang Qi and Shun-Cheng Wu and Shun‐Yi Wang and B. T. Zhong},
  title = {{Research on safety early warning of abnormal A-annular pressure of “three-high” gas wells based on data mining}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2022.1048968},
}
Figure