Research on Rotorcraft Blade Tip Vortex Identification and Motion Characteristics in Hovering State

Hai Du, Wenjie Kong, Yan Wang, Wenjing Liu, Mingqi Huang, Weiguo Zhang, Min TangSymmetry 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the complex flow dynamics of rotorcraft blade tip vortices during hovering flight using time-resolved particle image velocimetry (TR-PIV). By employing and comparing different vortex identification methods (vorticity, Q criterion, and Ω criterion), the study reveals how these vortices evolve radially and axially, and how their characteristics change with collective pitch, offering valuable insights for rotorcraft aerodynamics and control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rotorcraft aerodynamics are inherently complex due to rotational forces and the resulting intricate flow fields. A critical component of this complexity is the blade tip vortex, a strong swirling flow generated at the blade tip that significantly impacts rotor performance, vibration, and acoustics. Understanding the precise formation, motion, and evolution of these vortices is crucial for improving rotorcraft design and efficiency. However, accurately identifying and quantifying these vortex structures, especially in the dynamic wake environment, presents a significant challenge. Existing vortex identification methods often have limitations, such as requiring subjective threshold selection or lacking clear physical interpretations, necessitating further research into robust and accurate identification techniques for rotorcraft applications.

Methods

The study utilizes Time-Resolved Particle Image Velocimetry (TR-PIV) to capture high-resolution, time-dependent flow field data around a rotor model in a hovering state. This technique involves seeding the flow with tracer particles and illuminating them with a laser sheet, then capturing sequential images with a high-speed camera to track particle displacement and derive velocity vectors.

To identify and analyze the blade tip vortices, three distinct methods were employed:

  • Vorticity: This fundamental measure quantifies the local rotation of the fluid.
  • Q Criterion: Proposed by Hunt et al., this method identifies vortices as regions where the second invariant of the velocity gradient tensor is positive, balancing rotational and strain rates.
  • Ω Criterion: Developed by Liu et al., this method quantifies the degree of rigid body rotation of fluid elements, offering a more objective threshold for vortex identification by estimating the ratio of rotational to strain rates.

The paper details the mathematical formulations for each criterion and discusses their application to the experimental data.

Datasets

The study does not introduce new datasets or benchmarks. Instead, it relies on experimental data generated from a T-REX 450 L helicopter model under controlled laboratory conditions. The experiments were conducted at a fixed rotor rotation speed of 2100 r/min with two collective pitch angles: 6° and 9°. Flow field data was collected at six different azimuth angles (22.5°, 54°, 85.5°, 117°, 148.5°, and 180°) to capture the vortex evolution over a rotor revolution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Vortex Dynamics in Hover: Blade tip vortices exhibit a clear trend of radial contraction towards the hub and axial downward movement as the rotor blade progresses through its rotation (azimuth angle increases).
  • Influence of Collective Pitch: Increasing the collective pitch angle leads to a stronger blade tip vortex. This manifests as increased blade tension, a more pronounced downwash, more significant radial contraction, and faster axial displacement of the vortex.
  • Vortex Dissipation: Over time (as azimuth angle increases), the intensity and boundary of the blade tip vortex gradually decrease, attributed to viscous dissipation within the fluid.
  • Vortex Core Growth: Counterintuitively, the vortex core radius tends to increase over time, while the vortex boundary shrinks. This is explained by the initial formation of a concentrated vortex, followed by dissipation that leads to a decrease in circulation and a subsequent increase in the core radius due to reduced centrifugal forces.
  • Method Comparison: While all three identification methods (vorticity, Q, and Ω) show similar trends in vortex trajectory, the Ω criterion demonstrates a smaller deviation and appears to be more robust in accurately identifying vortex core radius and boundaries compared to the others. This suggests its potential as a preferred method for quantitative vortex analysis in such flows.

Key Results

  • Trajectory Visualization: Figures 6-18 visually demonstrate the formation, movement, and dissipation of blade tip vortices under varying azimuth angles and collective pitches, using vorticity contours, Q criterion, and Ω criterion visualizations.
  • Quantitative Trajectory Data: Figures 8, 11, and 14 present the radial and axial trajectories of the blade tip vortex, showing consistent radial contraction and axial descent. The data confirms that increasing collective pitch enhances both radial contraction and axial displacement.
  • Boundary and Core Size: Figures 15-18 illustrate how the vortex boundary generally decreases with increasing azimuth angle, while the vortex core size increases. Importantly, a higher collective pitch leads to a larger vortex boundary and core size.
  • Methodological Comparison: Figure 19 quantitatively compares the vortex trajectories obtained by the three methods, highlighting the closer agreement between the Ω criterion and the vorticity criterion, with the Q criterion showing some divergence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focuses on a specific rotor speed and limited collective pitch angles, which may not represent all operational conditions.
  • The experiments were conducted in a controlled environment, and ground effects were minimized but not entirely eliminated.
  • The paper acknowledges that different vortex identification methods yield certain deviations in vortex center identification, indicating that a universally perfect method may not exist.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that the obtained results can provide a basis for the study of rotor complex flow fields and vortex wake modeling and control.
  • Further research is needed to accurately define and identify vortex structures and analyze their interaction mechanisms, particularly for complex rotorcraft configurations.
  • The paper implies that the Ω criterion shows promise for accurate vortex identification, suggesting its further application and validation in more complex scenarios.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{du2020research,
  author = {Hai Du and Wenjie Kong and Yan Wang and Wenjing Liu and Mingqi Huang and Weiguo Zhang and Min Tang},
  title = {{Research on Rotorcraft Blade Tip Vortex Identification and Motion Characteristics in Hovering State}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/sym12020196},
}
Figure