Research on Risk Measurement of China’s Carbon Trading Market

Yanzhi Duan, Chunlei He, Yao Li, Yue Wang, Nan Tang, Wang ZhongEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the crucial challenge of accurately measuring risk in China's burgeoning carbon trading market. By employing an advanced EGARCH-EVT-VaR model, the researchers provide a more precise assessment of potential losses compared to traditional methods, revealing significant regional differences in risk profiles and offering policy recommendations for market stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the world grapples with climate change, carbon trading markets are emerging as key economic tools to incentivize emission reductions and foster low-carbon development. China, a major emitter, has established a national carbon market alongside several pilot markets. However, the inherent risks within these markets, such as price volatility and external shocks, can distort carbon price signals, hindering investment in low-carbon technologies and potentially jeopardizing national emission reduction goals. Accurately quantifying these risks is therefore paramount for the healthy and sustainable development of these markets. This paper aims to address this by providing a robust method for measuring and analyzing the risks associated with China's carbon trading market.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach to risk measurement:

  • HP Filter for Trend Decomposition: To isolate the volatility component of carbon price returns from the underlying trend, the Hodrick-Prescott (HP) filter is used. This allows for a clearer focus on the market risk associated with price fluctuations.
  • EGARCH Model: The Exponential Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity (EGARCH) model is utilized to capture the asymmetric nature of volatility. This is important because external shocks (positive or negative) can have different impacts on price fluctuations.
  • Extreme Value Theory (EVT) and Peak-Over-Threshold (POT) Model: To specifically address extreme risks and tail events, which are common in financial markets and can lead to substantial losses, the study incorporates EVT. The Peak-Over-Threshold (POT) model is chosen for its ability to effectively quantify losses associated with these extreme events.
  • Value at Risk (VaR): Both static and dynamic VaR are calculated. Static VaR provides a single estimate of potential loss at a given confidence level, while dynamic VaR tracks these potential losses over time, offering a more nuanced view of evolving market risk.
  • Kupiec Failure Frequency Test: To validate the effectiveness of the EGARCH-EVT-VaR model, the Kupiec test is used to assess whether the model's predictions of losses align with actual observed breaches.

The novelty lies in the combination of these techniques, particularly the integration of EVT with EGARCH to provide a more comprehensive measure of extreme risks in the carbon market.

Datasets

The study utilizes daily closing prices from eight Chinese carbon trading pilot markets (Hubei, Guangdong, Shenzhen, Shanghai, Beijing, Chongqing, Fujian, and Tianjin) and China's national carbon market. Data for the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EU-ETS) is also included for comparative analysis. The time frame for the Chinese markets ranges from their establishment to August 2022, while for EU-ETS, it covers the period from the start of its third phase to August 2022.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Asymmetrical Shocks Matter: External shocks don't affect carbon prices equally. Positive shocks, in particular, seem to have a stronger influence on price fluctuations, suggesting a degree of market sensitivity that needs careful monitoring.
  • EVT is Crucial for Extreme Risks: Traditional VaR methods might miss the mark when it comes to rare but severe price swings. EVT, by focusing on the "tails" of the distribution, offers a more robust way to capture these extreme risks, which is vital for financial stability.
  • China's Carbon Markets are Diverse: There isn't a one-size-fits-all risk profile across China's carbon markets. Some, like Hubei and Guangdong, show relatively lower risk, while others exhibit higher volatility, highlighting the need for tailored risk management strategies.
  • EU-ETS is a Benchmark for Stability: The established EU-ETS market demonstrates significantly more stability than most Chinese markets, with lower dynamic VaR values. This suggests that mature markets with well-developed structures and policies can better manage price volatility.

Key Results

  • The EGARCH-EVT-VaR model effectively captures the volatility and extreme risks in China's carbon markets.
  • Hubei and Guangdong carbon markets exhibit relatively small risks, with dynamic VaR values around ±0.2.
  • The EU-ETS market is more stable, with dynamic VaR values generally within ±0.1, significantly lower than most Chinese markets.
  • The Kupiec failure frequency test indicates that the EGARCH-EVT-VaR model provides reliable risk estimates for the Chinese carbon markets.
  • The study found that external shocks have an asymmetric effect on carbon price returns, with a tendency for long-term memory and a stronger reaction to positive shocks.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The paper notes that for the Fujian carbon market, data was limited for certain periods, hindering a complete analysis of its risk dynamics.
  • Regional Disparities: The significant differences in risk profiles across Chinese carbon markets suggest that a unified approach to risk management might not be optimal.
  • Future Work: The authors propose policy implications for the healthy development of China's carbon market, including strengthening experience sharing from leading markets like Hubei and Guangdong, establishing robust risk warning mechanisms, and learning from the international experience of mature markets like EU-ETS. Further research could explore the impact of specific policy changes on market risk and investigate the correlations between different carbon markets more deeply.

Summary updated

Abstract

In today’s environmentally conscious world, carbon trading has emerged as a widely accepted economic instrument to mitigate the externalities resulting from deteriorating environmental problems. Consequently, the use of market-based mechanisms to address environmental issues has reached a global consensus. Many countries are implementing progressive steps by establishing carbon markets to promote low-carbon development and meet their carbon reduction targets. However, the inherent risks in carbon trading markets may hamper the formation of a reasonable carbon price signal, leading to inadequate stimulation of low-carbon technology investments and potential failure to achieve national emission reduction goals. Therefore, managing the risks associated with carbon trading markets is crucial. This study focuses on measuring the risk of China’s carbon market, with the primary aim of exploring carbon price fluctuation patterns and precisely measuring market risks. The risks associated with China’s carbon market are quantified and analyzed using the exponential generalized autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity (EGARCH) model, extreme value theory (EVT), and the value at risk (VaR) method. Results show that (1) the effect of external shocks on each carbon market is asymmetrical, and positive shocks exert considerable leverage effects on carbon price fluctuations. (2) EVT can be used to effectively fit the risks in the carbon markets. The risks of each carbon market show different characteristics. The risk of Hubei and Guangdong carbon markets is relatively small, and the dynamic VaR is nearly ±0.2. (3) Compared with the performance of the Chinese carbon market, the performance of the European Union Emission Trading Scheme is more stable, and its dynamic VaR for most of the period is within ±0.1, which is considerably lower than the VaR of other Chinese carbon markets. This study also proposes suitable policy implications to ensure the healthy and sustainable development of China’s carbon market.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{duan2023research,
  author = {Yanzhi Duan and Chunlei He and Yao Li and Yue Wang and Nan Tang and Wang Zhong},
  title = {{Research on Risk Measurement of China’s Carbon Trading Market}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16237879},
}
Figure