Research on Optimization Method of Integrated Energy System Network Planning

Chun Sheng Yang, Shijun You, Yingzhu Han, Xuan Wang, Ji Li, Lu WangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the complex challenge of planning integrated energy systems (IES) by proposing a novel, multi-stage methodology. It combines a detailed, bottom-up load forecasting approach with an optimized site selection and network layout strategy, ultimately aiming to reduce construction costs and support China's "dual carbon" goals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global push towards decarbonization and the increasing demand for energy necessitate more efficient and integrated energy systems. Integrated Energy Systems (IES) offer a solution by combining multiple energy sources (electricity, gas, heating, cooling) and networks. However, planning these complex systems is significantly more challenging than traditional single-energy network planning. Existing methods often struggle with accurately predicting the diverse and coupled energy demands, optimizing the placement of energy stations, and designing efficient network layouts. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a comprehensive planning framework that accounts for these complexities, aiming to provide a practical and cost-effective solution for new IES developments.

Methods

The authors propose a three-pronged methodology:

  1. Bottom-Up Dynamic Multivariate Load Forecasting: Instead of relying on simpler macro-level predictions, this method uses a detailed, hour-by-hour (8760h/year) simulation for individual building types. It considers factors like building function, construction area, and energy consumption characteristics to predict electricity, cooling, and heating loads. This approach aims for higher accuracy by capturing the nuances of energy demand.
  2. P-Median Model with Dijkstra Algorithm for Site Selection and Network Layout: To determine the optimal locations for energy stations and the most efficient routes for energy distribution, the paper employs the P-median model. This model is combined with the Dijkstra algorithm to find the shortest paths between energy stations and load centers, minimizing network construction costs. The P-median problem is known for its complexity, and the authors mention using a modified enumeration method to solve it.
  3. Capacity Allocation Optimization: The final stage involves optimizing the capacity of the energy system's components. This is done by considering the complementary nature of different energy sources (natural gas, electricity, heat) and the specific energy demand characteristics of the area. The optimization objectives are defined to balance economy, energy saving, and environmental protection (the "3E" objectives).

Datasets

The study utilizes a case study from a community in Chongqing, China. The data includes:

  • Regional Planning Data: Information on the community's size, building area, and the types of buildings present (residential, office, commercial, hospital).
  • Simulated Load Data: Annual hourly load data (8760h) for electricity, heating, and cooling, generated using the Trnsys simulation software for typical building types.
  • Candidate Energy Station Locations and Load Centers: A defined set of potential sites for energy stations and identified load demand areas within the community.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather applies its methodology to a specific real-world scenario.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Granular Load Forecasting: The paper highlights that a detailed, bottom-up load prediction method is crucial for accurate IES planning. Neglecting the coupling and interaction effects between different energy forms in simpler prediction methods can lead to suboptimal system configurations.
  • Synergy in IES Planning: The research emphasizes that IES planning is not just about individual energy systems but about their integrated operation. The methodology explicitly considers the complementary characteristics of different energy sources to achieve better optimization.
  • Cost Reduction through Optimized Placement: The study demonstrates that strategic placement of energy stations and efficient network routing, guided by optimization models, can lead to significant reductions in infrastructure costs. This is a key takeaway for the economic viability of IES projects.
  • Balancing Multiple Objectives: The capacity optimization framework acknowledges that IES planning involves trade-offs between economic factors, energy efficiency, and environmental impact. The paper shows that different optimization goals (LCC, AEC, 3E) lead to different equipment capacity configurations.

Key Results

The core quantitative result is a 41% reduction in network construction cost achieved by the proposed optimization method compared to a baseline scenario using energy station 11. Specifically, the optimized site selection (energy station 4) resulted in a pipe network construction cost of 0.95 million USD, a substantial saving from the 1.63 million USD cost associated with energy station 11. The study also shows that the capacity configuration can vary significantly (up to 26% difference) depending on the optimization objective (e.g., Life Cycle Cost vs. Annual Energy Consumption).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Load Prediction: The paper acknowledges that multivariate load prediction for IES is significantly more difficult than for single energy systems due to the numerous influencing factors (climate, socio-economy, architectural design) and the multi-dimensional, multi-time scale nature of the problem.
  • NP-Hard Nature of Optimization: The P-median problem is NP-hard, meaning finding a guaranteed global optimum can be computationally intensive. While the paper uses a modified enumeration method, the scalability to very large or complex networks might be a consideration.
  • Generalizability of Case Study: While the Chongqing case study provides valuable validation, further studies on diverse geographical and urban contexts would strengthen the generalizability of the proposed method.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors implicitly suggest that further research could focus on refining the optimization models, exploring more advanced load forecasting techniques, and investigating the policy implications for local governments to support IES development. The paper also points out the need for more research on site selection, network path optimization, and capacity allocation for IES in actual projects.

Summary updated

Abstract

The development of an integrated energy system (IES) is conducive to promoting the transformation of the energy system and helping to achieve the ‘double carbon’ goal in China. The IES integrates cooling, heating, electricity, gas, and other energy resources, which is significantly more difficult than single energy network planning. This paper systematically sorts out the process of IES network planning and proposes an improved methodology. Firstly, the bottom-up dynamic multiple-load forecasting method of 8760 h a year is proposed as the basis of system configuration and capacity selection. Subsequently, a planning method for energy station location and route optimization using the Dijkstra algorithm is constructed by applying the P-median optimization model. Finally, when optimizing the capacity allocation of the IES, the complementary characteristics of natural gas, electricity and heat, as well as the corresponding energy demand characteristic, have been fully considered, so that the optimization objectives can be reasonably determined. Through the actual calculation, it is found that the optimization method proposed in this paper can reduce the construction cost of the network by 41%. The work combines the process of energy network planning and capacity configuration of IES, which provides a simple, easy and economical solution for IES planning in new areas.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2023research,
  author = {Chun Sheng Yang and Shijun You and Yingzhu Han and Xuan Wang and Ji Li and Lu Wang},
  title = {{Research on Optimization Method of Integrated Energy System Network Planning}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15118843},
}
Figure