Research on Optimization Method for Parts Selection of Remanufactured Products Under Dimensional Accuracy Constraints

Xing Shixiong, Zhigang Jiang, Shuo Zhu, Hua ZhangJournal of Mechanical Engineering 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Effective selection of parts from diverse sources—reused, remanufactured, and new—is critical for ensuring the quality and cost-effectiveness of remanufactured products. This research proposes a multi-objective optimization model that addresses the impact of dimensional tolerances on quality loss and total cost. By implementing a hierarchical accuracy grading mechanism, the method ensures that remanufactured assemblies meet or exceed the precision of original equipment manufacturer (OEM) standards. An Enhanced Cooperative Co-evolutionary Algorithm (ECCA) is employed to navigate the trade-offs between cost and quality. The approach is validated through a case study of a machine tool feed box, demonstrating significant improvements in dimensional accuracy while maintaining cost efficiency.

1. Introduction

Remanufacturing plays a pivotal role in the circular economy by extending the lifecycle of industrial components. However, the inherent heterogeneity of parts—stemming from varying wear levels and recovery sources—presents a significant challenge for assembly. Unlike traditional manufacturing, remanufacturers must integrate reused parts, remanufactured parts (repaired to spec), and new components. Achieving the required dimensional accuracy in the final assembly (the "dimension chain") while minimizing costs requires a sophisticated selection strategy.

2. Methodology

The proposed framework utilizes a three-tier accuracy grading mechanism (Levels I, II, and III). Level III corresponds to standard OEM specifications, while Levels I and II represent higher precision achieved through advanced remanufacturing techniques. This allows for "upgrading" product quality during the remanufacturing process.

The selection process is structured across three levels: product, component, and part. As illustrated in Figure 1, the system evaluates the accuracy constraints and cost implications at each level to ensure the final assembly meets the design tolerance ($T_{0def}$).

Hierarchical selection process for remanufactured parts across product, component, and part levels.

The optimization model balances two primary objectives:

  • Quality Loss Function: Measures the deviation from ideal precision across the assembly's dimension chain.
  • Total Cost Function: Accounts for disassembly, cleaning, testing, surface repair, machining, and purchasing new components.

To solve this multi-objective problem, the researchers developed an Enhanced Cooperative Co-evolutionary Algorithm (ECCA). This algorithm decomposes the complex dimension chain into sub-problems (increasing and decreasing links), optimizing them in parallel to find the global optimum.

3. Case Study and Results

The model was applied to the remanufacturing of a machine tool feed box transmission shaft assembly. The assembly consists of five components, including gears, shafts, and spacers, with a critical axial clearance requirement of 0.01 mm to 0.20 mm.

The optimization process generated a Pareto front, representing the set of optimal trade-offs between total cost and accuracy loss. As shown in Figure 2, the "optimal solution" identifies a configuration that significantly reduces accuracy loss without an exponential increase in cost.

Pareto front showing the trade-off between total cost and accuracy loss, highlighting the selected optimal solution.

In the optimized configuration, the system selected high-precision "Level I" remanufactured parts for the shaft and gears. This resulted in an axial clearance of 0.0102 mm—significantly tighter than the average new OEM product—at a total cost of 29.7 yuan.

4. Conclusion

This research demonstrates that remanufactured products can achieve superior dimensional accuracy compared to new products through strategic part selection. By leveraging a diverse inventory of parts and advanced optimization algorithms like ECCA, manufacturers can deliver high-quality, cost-effective products that support sustainable industrial practices. Future work will expand this model to include surface integrity and long-term reliability metrics.

Summary updated

Abstract

摘要: 合理选配再利用件、再制造件、新件等不同来源形式的零部件,是保障再制造产品质量与成本的关键环节。针对待选配零部件尺寸公差对再制造产品质量损失、成本的双重影响特征,通过设计零部件尺寸公差的精度分级机制,实现再制造产品各零部件尺寸精度不低于原新品,获取可行选配方案集;进一步以产品尺寸链精度不低于原新品为约束,建立关于零部件尺寸公差的再制造产品尺寸链精度损失函数、再制造产品总成本函数,构建面向再制造产品成本与质量协同优化的多目标选配优化模型,采用协同进化算法获取最终的选配优化方案,实现在全面提升再制造产品及其零部件尺寸精度的同时,降低产品成本。最后以某机床的再制造进给箱零部件优化选配为例,验证了所提出方法能够有效解决零部件来源形式多、尺寸精度与成本差异性大环境下,以不低于新产品尺寸精度为约束的再制造零部件选配优化问题。
BibTeX
@article{shixiong2022research,
  author = {XING Shixiong and Zhigang Jiang and Shuo Zhu and Hua Zhang},
  title = {{Research on Optimization Method for Parts Selection of Remanufactured Products Under Dimensional Accuracy Constraints}},
  journal = {Journal of Mechanical Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3901/jme.2022.19.221},
}
Figure