Research on Mechanical Behavior and Energy Evolution of Coal and Rocks with Different Thin Spray-On Liners Thickness under Uniaxial Compressive Loading

Yixin Zhao, Xiang Fu, Yangyang Shi, Bowen Zhao, Xingyu Fu, Xiufeng Zhang, Yang ChenSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the effectiveness of Thin Spray-On Liners (TSLs) in enhancing the mechanical strength and energy absorption of coal and rock under uniaxial compression. The research demonstrates that increasing TSL thickness significantly boosts the Uniaxial Compressive Strength (UCS) of coal and sandstone, with coal showing the most substantial improvement, while also influencing the energy dissipation characteristics of these materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep excavation in mining operations, particularly in coal mines, faces significant challenges from high ground stress, hydraulic pressure, and temperature, leading to frequent disasters like rock bursts. Traditional support methods such as rock bolts, mesh, and concrete have limitations. Thin Spray-On Liners (TSLs) have emerged as a promising alternative due to their potential for improved impact energy bearing and absorption. However, a comprehensive understanding of how TSL thickness affects the mechanical behavior and energy evolution of different rock types, specifically coal and sandstone, under uniaxial compressive loading was lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically analyzing these effects.

Methods

The researchers conducted laboratory experiments using uniaxial compressive loading on samples of white sandstone, yellow sandstone, and coal. These samples were coated with TSLs of varying thicknesses (2 mm, 3 mm, 4 mm, and 5 mm), alongside uncoated control samples. The TSLs themselves were prepared by blending two reactive components (A and B) and then sprayed onto the rock and coal specimens. The mechanical properties of the TSL material itself were characterized through tensile testing and SEM analysis to understand its microstructure and failure mechanisms.

For the rock and coal specimens, the core experimental technique was the Uniaxial Compressive Strength (UCS) test, performed using an MTS E45.305 loading system. This system allowed for the recording of stress-strain data, which was then used to analyze the mechanical behavior and energy evolution. Specifically, the study focused on calculating and comparing the total energy, elastic energy, and dissipative energy absorbed by the specimens during the loading process. Energy calculations were performed using Origin software, based on established formulas for elastic and dissipative energy derived from the stress-strain curves.

Datasets

The study utilized three types of rock materials:

  • Coal: Obtained from the Zhaogu coal mine in Henan Province, China.
  • Yellow Sandstone: Obtained from Zigong, Sichuan Province, China.
  • White Sandstone: Obtained from Zigong, Sichuan Province, China.

These materials were prepared into cylindrical specimens (D = 50 mm, H = 100 mm) for testing. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relied on laboratory-prepared samples of these geological materials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TSL Microstructure Matters: The SEM analysis revealed that the interaction between the hard and soft segments of the TSL forms a physical cross-linking, which is crucial for its improved mechanical strength. Incomplete reaction or structural defects (like bumps observed in one sample) significantly weaken the TSL.
  • Confining Pressure Effect: TSLs act to impart a confining pressure-like effect on the rock and coal, effectively compacting internal fractures and improving their resistance to deformation and failure.
  • Strength vs. Energy Absorption Trade-off: While TSLs significantly increase the UCS, their effect on energy absorption capacity is nuanced. For coal, both strength and energy absorption increase with TSL thickness. However, for sandstones, the energy absorption capacity tends to decrease with increasing TSL thickness, suggesting a shift in failure mechanism.
  • Coal's Unique Response: Coal, being anisotropic, shows a more pronounced improvement in UCS with TSL coating compared to sandstones. The energy absorption in coal also increases significantly with TSL thickness, indicating a greater benefit from TSL application in coal seams.

Key Results

  • UCS Improvement: The UCS of coated white sandstone, yellow sandstone, and coal increased by 4.6%, 25.51%, and 43.75%, respectively, with increasing TSL thickness.
  • Coal Strength Enhancement: For coal, TSL coating with 2 mm, 3 mm, and 4 mm thickness improved peak stress by 34.56%, 43.75%, and 34.75%, respectively.
  • Energy Evolution:
    • For yellow sandstone, total and dissipative energies increased with TSL thickness, while elastic energy remained largely unchanged.
  • For coal, total, elastic, and dissipative energies increased significantly (2-3 times) with TSL coating, indicating enhanced energy absorption.
  • For white sandstone, total and dissipative energies increased, but elastic energy remained relatively constant, with a less pronounced overall energy absorption increase compared to coal.
  • Energy Absorption Capacity: The energy-absorbing capacity of coal was found to be greater than that of yellow or white sandstone.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Thickness Range: The study explored TSL thicknesses up to 5 mm. Further investigation into thicker coatings or different application methods might reveal different performance characteristics.
  • Specific Rock Types: The study focused on specific types of sandstone and coal. The behavior of TSLs on other rock formations or coal seams with different geological characteristics might vary.
  • Dynamic Loading: The experiments were conducted under quasi-static uniaxial compression. The performance of TSLs under dynamic loading conditions (e.g., impact or blast) was not evaluated, which is a critical aspect for rock burst prevention.
  • Debonding/Delamination: The paper notes that TSL reinforcement can be weakened if debonding or delamination occurs. Future work could focus on understanding and preventing these failure modes.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: While the study suggests a suitable coating thickness of 2-3 mm for cost and operation, a detailed economic analysis comparing TSLs with traditional methods would be beneficial for practical implementation.

The authors suggest that TSL performance can be adjusted based on on-site requirements, implying a need for further field-specific research and optimization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Compared with the traditional supporting materials such as the bolts, mesh, and concrete, thin spray-on liners (TSLs) have the advantages of improving impact energy bearing and absorption capacity of rocks. In this study, the uniaxial compressive mechanical response feature of white sandstone, yellow sandstone, and coal with different coating thickness of TSLs were investigated through laboratory tests and theoretical analysis. The hard segments and soft segments of TSLs induced microphase separation, and formed the physical cross-linking. The hard segment evenly dispersed in the soft segment, which improved the mechanical strength of the TSLs. The confining pressure was affected by the TSL-coated coal and rocks, which improved the mechanical strength of the rocks and coal under UCS loading. It was discovered that the uniaxial compressive strength (UCS) increases with an increase in the TSL coating thickness, and UCS increments of the coated white sandstone, yellow sandstone and coal were 4.6%, 25.51%, and 43.75%, respectively. The energy absorption capacities of the coated coal, and yellow and white sandstones gradually decreased with an increase in their TSLs coating thickness. Meanwhile, the energy-absorbing capacity of a coated rock reduced gradually as rock coating decreases. Furthermore, the energy-absorbing capacity of coal is greater than that of yellow sandstone or white sandstone. By increasing the coating thickness, the total and dissipative energies in the yellow sandstone, white sandstone, and coal specimens were gradually increased, and energy increment was significantly more in coal (2–3 times), while the elastic energy remained nearly unchanged.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2022research,
  author = {Yixin Zhao and Xiang Fu and Yangyang Shi and Bowen Zhao and Xingyu Fu and Xiufeng Zhang and Yang Chen},
  title = {{Research on Mechanical Behavior and Energy Evolution of Coal and Rocks with Different Thin Spray-On Liners Thickness under Uniaxial Compressive Loading}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14105909},
}
Figure