Research on Key Competences Needs of Volunteers in Ecological Citizen Science Projects based on Grounded Theory

Ziyue Li2020 · DOI

Abstract

This paper selects 5 typical cases of ecological citizen science projects and tries to use grounded theory analysis to explore the core quality requirements of ecological citizen science projects on volunteers. The study obtained 56 initial concepts, 12 categories and their corresponding knowledge, skills, physical and mental will and values of 4 main categories. The results of this study can play a role in the assessment of the impact of ecological citizen science projects on the quality of volunteers, and also provide help for the recruitment of volunteers for citizen science projects.

Introduction

Ecological research often requires massive data collection across vast geographic areas and long timeframes. Citizen science (CS) projects, where the public participates in scientific research, have emerged as a solution to this "big data" challenge. However, a significant hurdle remains: data reliability. While CS projects often enhance volunteer knowledge, the data produced can sometimes lack the precision of professional scientific work. Currently, there is no standardized framework to assess whether a volunteer possesses the "key competencies" required for specific ecological tasks. This research aims to fill that gap by defining the core qualities of a competent ecological volunteer.

Methodology

The researchers employed Grounded Theory, a qualitative methodology designed to develop theories through systematic data analysis. The process involved three coding stages:

  1. Open Coding: Raw data from project descriptions and news were decomposed into 56 initial concepts.
  2. Axial Coding: These concepts were grouped into 12 distinct categories based on their relationships.
  3. Selective Coding: These categories were integrated into a core theoretical framework comprising four main categories: Knowledge, Skills, Will, and Values.

A Theoretical Saturation Test was conducted using a hold-out set (1/3 of the data) to ensure no new categories emerged, confirming the model's completeness.

Case Studies

The study analyzed five representative ecological citizen science projects, selected for their maturity and detailed volunteer requirements. These projects range from snail identification to high-difficulty environmental monitoring.

Table 1: Overview of the five ecological citizen science projects analyzed in the study.

Key Competency Framework

The research resulted in a hierarchical framework of volunteer needs, categorized into four main domains (B1-B4) and twelve sub-categories (A1-A12).

Table 2: The hierarchical framework of key competencies for ecological citizen science volunteers.

B1: Knowledge

This domain includes basic literacy (often English for international projects), domain-specific expertise (e.g., ornithology or geography), and prior experience in relevant projects.

B2: Skill

Skills encompass research ability (using specific tools), information technology proficiency (data collection and analysis), learning ability (participating in training), collaboration, and wild survival skills (first aid and motor skills).

B3: Will of Body and Mind

Volunteers must possess the physical fitness to adapt to tough outdoor conditions and a "spirit of discovery"—the courage and fearlessness required to explore the unknown.

B4: Values

Values are functional requirements for data accuracy. A "sense of mission" ensures patience and carefulness, while "social responsibility" promotes honesty and respect for nature.

Discussion and Conclusion

The study highlights that "learning to learn" is a critical competency; volunteers must be able to adapt to specific project protocols through training. Furthermore, digital literacy is now inseparable from research ability, as most modern projects rely on digital platforms for data entry. Finally, values like patience and honesty are not just ethical traits but are essential for ensuring the scientific integrity of the data collected.

While this framework identifies what competencies are needed, future work should focus on developing a quantitative scale to measure these attributes. This would allow project managers to more effectively recruit, filter, and train the next generation of "citizen scientists."

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper selects 5 typical cases of ecological citizen science projects and tries to use grounded theory analysis to explore the core quality requirements of ecological citizen science projects on volunteers.The study obtained 56 initial concepts, 12 categories and their corresponding knowledge, skills, physical and mental will and values of 4 main categories.The results of this study can play a role in the assessment of the impact of ecological citizen science projects on the quality of volunteers, and also provide help for the recruitment of volunteers for citizen science projects.
BibTeX
@misc{li2020research,
  author = {Ziyue Li},
  title = {{Research on Key Competences Needs of Volunteers in Ecological Citizen Science Projects based on Grounded Theory}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.23977/eeim2020027},
}
Figure