Research on isolation property of prestressed thick rubber bearings

Lihua Zou, Kai Huang, Y.v.k. Sadasiva Rao, Runhua Guo, Zhixu XuJournal of Vibroengineering 2013

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Prestressed Rubber Bearing (PRB), a novel seismic isolator designed to overcome limitations of conventional Rubber Bearings (RBs). PRBs enhance vertical isolation and offer horizontal displacement limitation by incorporating thicker rubber layers and prestress tendons, demonstrating promising performance in both experimental and numerical studies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Conventional laminated Rubber Bearings (RBs) are widely used for seismic isolation, but they have several drawbacks. Firstly, their capacity for horizontal displacement limitation is inadequate, potentially leading to large displacements and overturning moments, especially in tall buildings. Secondly, their tensile strength is insufficient for certain applications. Thirdly, while thicker rubber layers can improve vertical isolation, they can also cause uneven settlement during construction. Current RBs often use thin rubber layers to mitigate this, compromising vertical isolation. This paper addresses these shortcomings by proposing and analyzing the Prestressed Rubber Bearing (PRB).

Methods

The authors developed a new seismic isolator, the Prestressed Rubber Bearing (PRB), by modifying conventional RBs. Key modifications include:

  • Amplified Rubber Layer Thickness: To enhance vertical isolation capacity.
  • Prestress Tendons: Incorporated to provide additional support and control.
  • Vertical Ducts: Included in the design.

The research involved:

  • Experimental Study: Vertical monotonic loading tests were conducted to determine the vertical stiffness of PRBs. This led to the development of a modified formula for vertical stiffness, addressing the underestimation by existing formulas (like Lindley's) for thick rubber layers.
  • Nonlinear Analytical Model: A detailed analytical model was developed for the horizontal stiffness of PRBs. This model accounts for the influence of prestress tendons, which alter the bearing's behavior compared to conventional RBs.
  • Numerical Investigation: A hypothesis cylinder PRB was simulated to investigate the influence of prestress tendons, vertical load, and rubber layer thickness on horizontal stiffness.
  • Response History Analysis: A hypothetical six-story shear type concrete structure was analyzed using recorded ground motion (El-Centro earthquake) to evaluate the isolation capacities of PRBs compared to conventional RBs and non-isolated structures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data from tested specimens and simulated ground motion data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Modified Vertical Stiffness: Existing formulas for vertical stiffness (like Lindley's) significantly underestimate the stiffness of bearings with thick rubber layers. The PRB's design, with thicker rubber, necessitates a modified formula that accounts for the increased constraint from steel plates.
  • Variable Horizontal Stiffness: Unlike conventional RBs, the horizontal stiffness of PRBs is not constant. It starts close to that of RBs but increases with horizontal displacement. This is a crucial finding, attributed to the horizontal component of the prestress tendons' internal force, which actively resists increasing displacements.
  • Combined Benefits: PRBs offer a dual advantage: effective seismic isolation (similar to RBs) and a significant capacity for horizontal displacement limitation. This limitation becomes more pronounced with increasing horizontal displacement and ground motion intensity.
  • Prestress Tendon Influence: The prestress tendons play a critical role in the PRB's behavior, contributing to both vertical support (reducing settlement issues during construction) and enhanced horizontal stiffness and displacement control.

Key Results

  • Vertical Stiffness: The modified formula for vertical stiffness, incorporating a regression-based modifying coefficient, showed better agreement with experimental results for thick rubber layers compared to Lindley's formula.
  • Horizontal Stiffness: Numerical investigations demonstrated that the horizontal stiffness of PRBs increases with horizontal displacement, a behavior distinct from conventional RBs. This increase is more pronounced with higher vertical loads and thinner relative rubber layers.
  • Isolation Performance: Response history analysis showed that structures with PRBs and RBs exhibited significantly reduced peak accelerations compared to non-isolated structures. While PRBs' peak acceleration reduction was slightly less than RBs, their peak displacement reduction was substantially better (about 40% smaller than RBs).
  • Displacement Limitation: The PRB's ability to limit horizontal displacement was highlighted, with peak displacements in PRB-equipped structures being significantly smaller than those in RB-equipped structures, especially under higher ground motion intensities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Applicability of Modified Formula: The authors note that the accuracy of the proposed modified formula for vertical stiffness depends on the number of regression samples. The derived modifying coefficient is based on a limited number of experimental samples and may only be directly applicable to PRBs with similar dimensions.
  • Iterative Solution for Horizontal Stiffness: The analytical solution for horizontal displacement and stiffness involves an iterative method due to the coupling of variables ($\Delta_3$ and $\phi$).
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests further experimental validation and refinement of the analytical models for a wider range of PRB configurations and seismic conditions. The study also points towards the potential of PRBs for improved seismic performance, particularly in limiting displacements.

Summary updated

Abstract

To overcome the shortages of current laminated rubber bearings (RB), a new kind of isolator called Prestressed Rubber Bearing (PRB) is presented in this paper, which is invented by appropriately amplifying the thickness of rubber layers in conventional RB and employing prestress tendons. Based on the experimental study, a modified formula for vertical stiffness of PRB is established. Then the nonlinear analytical model for PRB’s horizontal stiffness is developed and the corresponding formulas are derived. Through the response history analysis of structures, the isolation capacities of PRBs are investigated. The results show that the horizontal stiffness of PRB is variable with the displacment. PRB not only has effective isolation capacity as conventional RBs but also has the favorable capacity of horizontal displacement limitation and vertical up resistance.
BibTeX
@article{zou2013research,
  author = {Lihua Zou and Kai Huang and Y.V.K. Sadasiva Rao and Runhua Guo and Zhixu Xu},
  title = {{Research on isolation property of prestressed thick rubber bearings}},
  journal = {Journal of Vibroengineering},
  year = {2013},
}
Figure