Research on Influencing Factors of Cost Control of Centralized Photovoltaic Power Generation Project Based on DEMATEL-ISM

Jun Zhang, Jing Li, Jiawei YouSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the persistent challenge of high costs in large-scale solar power projects by identifying and analyzing the complex web of factors influencing cost control throughout the project's entire lifecycle. By combining DEMATEL and ISM methodologies, the research reveals that national policies and market dynamics are the most fundamental drivers, while bidding, contract management, and operational aspects like transmission and maintenance are the most direct levers for cost reduction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Centralized photovoltaic (PV) power generation projects, crucial for the transition to clean energy, are often hampered by high costs. While technological advancements are reducing hardware expenses, the overall project cost remains a significant hurdle for industrial development. Existing research often focuses on isolated aspects or stages of these projects, lacking a holistic view of how various factors interact and influence cost control across the entire project lifecycle – from initial planning to long-term operation and maintenance. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a comprehensive framework for understanding and managing these cost-influencing factors.

Methods

The authors employ a hybrid approach, combining two powerful analytical techniques:

  • DEMATEL (Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory): This method is used to map the complex relationships between influencing factors. It helps quantify the direct and indirect influence each factor has on others, as well as identify key drivers and their causal relationships. DEMATEL allows for the calculation of "cause degree" and "centrality," which are crucial for understanding a factor's role.
  • ISM (Interpretive Structural Modelling): This technique is then used to build a hierarchical structure of these influencing factors. ISM helps to visualize the relationships and categorize factors into different levels of influence (e.g., deep, transitional, shallow), providing a clearer understanding of the action paths for cost control.

By integrating DEMATEL and ISM, the researchers aim to overcome the limitations of each individual method, leveraging DEMATEL's quantitative insights and ISM's structural representation to create a robust model.

Datasets

The study relies on data collected through a questionnaire survey administered to 20 experts in the field of centralized photovoltaic power generation. These experts came from diverse backgrounds, including universities, construction units, design consulting units, and investment firms. A total of 17 valid questionnaires were collected, representing an 85% effective response rate. This data was used to construct the direct influence matrix, which then served as the input for the DEMATEL and ISM analyses. No pre-existing datasets were used; the data was generated specifically for this study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Lifecycle Approach: The paper emphasizes that effective cost control requires looking beyond individual project phases and considering the entire lifecycle, from decision-making to operation and maintenance.
  • Interconnectedness of Factors: The research highlights that cost control isn't about isolated actions but about understanding how various factors (policy, market, technical, managerial) influence each other.
  • Policy as the Deepest Root: The finding that national policies and standards are the most profound influencing factors is significant. It suggests that systemic, top-down interventions are fundamental to achieving cost control.
  • Bidding and Contracts as Central Levers: The identification of bidding and contract management as having the highest centrality underscores their critical role in shaping project costs and managing risks.
  • Direct Impact of Operational Factors: The study pinpoints transmission, electricity storage, and equipment repair/maintenance as the most direct factors influencing cost, offering immediate targets for operational efficiency improvements.

Key Results

The study identified 20 influencing factors, categorized into controllable (decision, design, construction, operation & maintenance stages) and uncontrollable factors.

  • Most Profound Influencing Factors (Cause Degree):
    • National policies and standards (X18): Cause degree of 2.155
    • Market changes (X19): Cause degree of 1.586
  • Factor with Highest Centrality:
    • Bidding and contract management (X11): Centrality of 7.120
  • Most Direct Factors Affecting Cost Control:
    • Transmission and storage of electricity (X16)
    • Equipment repair and maintenance (X17)
  • Hierarchical Structure: The ISM analysis revealed a multi-level structure, with "deep factors" like national policies and market changes at the bottom, influencing "transitional factors" such as bidding and contract management, which in turn affect "shallow factors" like transmission and maintenance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size and Scope: The study's reliance on a limited number of experts and questionnaires might affect the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the findings. The research primarily focused on project construction units, design units, and related fields, with less detailed input from upstream/downstream enterprises, supervision units, and equipment suppliers.
  • Micro-Cost Composition: The paper lacks a detailed analysis of the micro-cost composition of projects, which could provide more granular insights.

For future work, the authors suggest:

  • Strengthening Data Collection: Expanding the survey to include a wider range of participants and increasing the sample size.
  • Economic Modeling: Establishing economic calculation models and conducting sensitivity analyses to better understand the impact of individual or multiple factors on final costs.
  • Risk Control Focus: Investigating cost control from a risk management perspective, including analyzing risk sources, processes, and results.

Summary updated

Abstract

The high cost of centralized photovoltaic power generation projects is an important problem affecting industrial development, which needs to be solved urgently. It is particularly important to explore the influencing factors of cost control and the interaction between them. This paper takes a centralized photovoltaic power generation project as the research object, and determines the index system of influencing factors of cost control from the perspective of the life cycle. Secondly, the logical relationship between influencing factors is judged by the method of combining DEMATEL (decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory) and ISM (interpretive structural modelling). Finally, the multi-order recursive interpretation structure model is obtained, and the action mechanism between various factors is obtained. The results show that national policies and standards are the most profound influencing factors, and their cause degree reaches 2.155; the reason degree of market changes is the second, which is 1.586; bidding and contract management are the factors with the highest centrality, which is 7.120; and transmission and the storage of electricity and equipment repair and maintenance are the most direct factors affecting cost control. Finally, some suggestions are put forward for different types of influencing factors. The research results can better help photovoltaic power generation enterprises solve the problem of cost control.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024research,
  author = {Jun Zhang and Jing Li and Jiawei You},
  title = {{Research on Influencing Factors of Cost Control of Centralized Photovoltaic Power Generation Project Based on DEMATEL-ISM}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16135289},
}
Figure