Research on Improving the Efficiency of School Enterprise Joint Training Mode

Lu Lu, Xin XuCreative 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the persistent "supply and demand mismatch" in the labor market for business graduates, where academic training fails to meet industry needs. The authors propose a multi-dimensional framework to improve the efficiency of school-enterprise joint training by addressing systemic failures at the institutional, corporate, and student levels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite decades of "school-enterprise cooperation," a significant gap remains between the skills business students graduate with and the practical competencies employers actually require. This mismatch creates a paradox: undergraduates struggle to find jobs due to a lack of practical experience, while employers complain they cannot find "applied talents" ready for the workforce.

The authors argue that current joint training modes are often "empty shells"—agreements that exist on paper but fail in practice. They identify a "structural contradiction" rooted in traditional teaching models that over-emphasize knowledge transfer while ignoring the volatile needs of the modern social and economic environment.

Methods

The paper employs a qualitative theoretical analysis, grounded in the "Triple Helix" model (the interdependent relationship between universities, industry, and government). The authors perform a literature review of existing training models—such as the "3 + 1 + 1" and "2.5 + 0.5 + 1" segmented culture modes—to identify why these mechanisms often lose efficiency.

The core of the paper is a tripartite analysis that deconstructs the problem into three levels:

  1. School Level: Examining pedagogical inertia and the lack of industry-aligned incentives.
  2. Enterprise Level: Analyzing the "economic man" assumption where companies prioritize short-term recruitment costs over long-term talent cultivation.
  3. Student Level: Investigating the lack of career maturity and the "formalism" of social practice assignments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical and conceptual research paper rather than an empirical study involving primary data or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Classroom Inertia" Trap: Many universities treat the classroom as both the starting and ending point of education. The authors argue that schools must "subvert the traditional solidified thought of classroom standards" and adopt a "going out and coming back" strategy.
  • The Executive-Executive Gap: While senior corporate leaders might support joint training in theory, the executive level (HR and line managers) often views it as a burden. Without dedicated departments or personnel for school coordination, joint training remains a "small branch" of recruitment rather than a strategic priority.
  • Scholarships vs. Engagement: The paper highlights that many enterprises believe their job is done once they remit scholarship funds. However, without following up on student progress or participating in curriculum design, these funds fail to improve practical abilities.
  • The "Double-Qualified" Team: A major bottleneck is the faculty. The authors suggest that schools should prioritize hiring teachers with actual industry experience to bridge the gap between theory and practice.

Key Results

The paper concludes with a set of strategic recommendations to revitalize the joint training mode:

  • For Schools: Reform the evaluation system to include practical teaching as a core metric. Establish "special research teams" to explore innovative collaborative mechanisms and share resources like training rooms and subject research with enterprises.
  • For Enterprises: Move beyond passive financial support. Companies should set up project competitions (e.g., product design or management challenges) to identify talent early and send professionals into classrooms to explain real-world production processes.
  • For Students: Shift from passive recipients of knowledge to active participants in their career development. The authors advocate for an "internship-social practice-employment" developmental model to ensure students understand industry requirements long before graduation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while rich discussions exist, the perspective has historically been too school-centric. However, this paper itself remains largely theoretical.

Limitations: * Lack of Empirical Data: The paper does not provide quantitative evidence or case studies to measure the "efficiency" it aims to improve. * Geographic Specificity: The analysis is heavily focused on the Chinese higher education system and the specific challenges of business management majors in that context.

Future Work: The authors suggest that further research should focus more on the "main training objects"—the students—and explore how to strengthen the "self-hematopoietic" (self-sustaining) ability of these joint training programs through better management decision-making and performance evaluation systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although the school enterprise joint training mode has been brought to practice for a few decades, the supply and demand mismatch of labor market still exists between enterprise employers and undergraduates in business. This means that the efficiency of this mode is not very satisfactory. This leads to a serious lag in the cultivation of students’ practical ability, innovation ability, practical ability and ability to adapt to the environment and the needs of social and economic development. This paper aims to discuss the efficiency improvement of the school enterprise joint training mechanism for business and management majored students, focusing on the three main levels of school-enterprise joint training: schools, enterprises and students.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2022research,
  author = {Lu Lu and Xin Xu},
  title = {{Research on Improving the Efficiency of School Enterprise Joint Training Mode}},
  booktitle = {Creative},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.4236/ce.2022.134083},
}
Figure