Research on High Sensitive D-Shaped FBG Hydrogen Sensors in Power Transformer Oil

Ying-Ting Luo, Hong-Bin Wang, Guo-Ming Ma, Hong-Tu Song, Cheng-Rong Li, Jun Jiang2016 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel D-shaped Fiber Bragg Grating (DFBG) sensor coated with palladium for highly sensitive detection of dissolved hydrogen in power transformer oil. This sensor leverages curvature changes induced by hydrogen absorption, offering a more robust and potentially faster alternative to traditional dissolved gas analysis (DGA) methods for monitoring transformer health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Power transformers are critical infrastructure, and their health is often assessed by monitoring dissolved gases in their insulating oil. Dissolved hydrogen is a key indicator of electrical faults like overheating or partial discharge. Traditional methods, such as Dissolved Gas Analysis (DGA), are accurate but require complex sample separation, have long response times, and can be prone to errors. While Fiber Bragg Gratings (FBGs) offer advantages like small size and immunity to electromagnetic interference, enhancing their sensitivity for dissolved hydrogen detection in oil has been a challenge. Existing FBG-based sensors often rely on refractive index changes, which can be affected by other oil components. This paper aims to address the need for a more sensitive, direct, and field-deployable hydrogen sensor for power transformers.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the fabrication of a D-shaped FBG. Unlike standard cylindrical FBGs, the D-shaped fiber has a flattened side created by mechanical polishing. This D-shape makes the FBG highly sensitive to bending or curvature. The researchers then coated the polished surface of the D-FBG with a hydrogen-absorbing material, specifically a palladium (Pd) and silver (Ag) alloy, using magnetron sputtering.

The mechanism for hydrogen detection is not based on refractive index changes, but rather on the physical expansion of the palladium coating when it absorbs hydrogen. This expansion induces stress on the D-shaped FBG, causing it to bend and thus shift its Bragg wavelength. The fabrication process involved precise mechanical polishing of the FBG cladding to a specific residual thickness and then magnetron sputtering of the sensing film under controlled vacuum conditions. The experimental setup involved a gas mass flow controller to introduce controlled concentrations of hydrogen and nitrogen into transformer oil, with the D-FBG sensor and a reference FBG immersed in the oil. The wavelength shifts were monitored using an interrogator.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilized controlled hydrogen concentrations introduced into transformer oil, and the results were validated against gas chromatographic (GC) analysis of oil samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Curvature-based sensing for hydrogen: The paper demonstrates that by leveraging the D-shape of the FBG, hydrogen detection can be achieved through curvature changes induced by the volume expansion of a hydrogen-absorbing coating, rather than relying on refractive index changes. This offers a more direct and potentially more robust sensing mechanism in complex oil environments.
  • D-shaped FBG as a sensitive platform: The non-circular symmetry of the D-shaped fiber inherently makes it more sensitive to external stresses like bending, which is crucial for amplifying the effect of the hydrogen-absorbing material's expansion.
  • Palladium as an effective hydrogen absorber: The use of a Pd/Ag alloy coating proved effective in absorbing hydrogen and inducing sufficient mechanical stress to cause measurable wavelength shifts in the D-FBG.
  • Potential for field deployment: The small size, robustness (due to the polyimide coating protecting the FBG head), and immunity to electromagnetic interference of FBGs, combined with this novel sensing mechanism, make it a promising candidate for in-situ monitoring in power transformers.

Key Results

  • The fabricated D-shaped FBG hydrogen sensor achieved a high sensitivity of 1.96 µL/L per 1-pm wavelength shift.
  • The sensor exhibited a linear measuring characteristic in the range of low hydrogen concentrations in transformer oil, with a fitting curve showing a high coefficient of determination ($R^2 = 0.980$).
  • The accuracy of the D-FBG sensor was found to be better than ±12% of reading ±7.2 µL/L (H2 equivalent), which is considered good for monitoring applications.
  • X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis confirmed that the palladium-based sensing film remained crystalline after hydrogen absorption and desorption cycles, indicating stable sensing performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Response Time: While the paper mentions the response time of the gas properties was less than 4 seconds, the specific response time of the D-FBG sensor to dissolved hydrogen in oil is not explicitly detailed.
  • Long-term stability and fouling: The paper focuses on the initial performance and membrane stability. Long-term performance in a real transformer environment, including potential fouling or degradation of the sensing film, would require further investigation.
  • Cross-sensitivity: While the paper states that the D-FBG and reference FBG were placed close to the oil-filled chamber to mitigate temperature-strain cross-sensitivity, a detailed analysis of cross-sensitivity to other gases or oil degradation products is not presented.
  • Comparison with conventional DGA: While the D-FBG sensor shows higher sensitivity than some existing fiber sensors, the paper acknowledges it cannot yet match the sensitivity of conventional DGA techniques in all aspects. Future work could focus on further enhancing sensitivity and exploring multiplexing capabilities for simultaneous detection of multiple gases.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{luo2016research,
  author = {Ying-Ting Luo and Hong-Bin Wang and Guo-Ming Ma and Hong-Tu Song and Cheng-Rong Li and Jun Jiang},
  title = {{Research on High Sensitive D-Shaped FBG Hydrogen Sensors in Power Transformer Oil}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/s16101641},
}
Figure