TL;DR
This paper investigates how to boost Green Total Factor Productivity (GTFP) in China by examining the interplay of technology, organization, and environment using a configurational approach (fsQCA). It reveals distinct pathways to high GTFP, emphasizing that achieving it isn't a one-size-fits-all solution but depends on specific combinations of these factors, with regional variations in strategy.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Globally, and particularly in rapidly developing economies like China, there's a critical need to balance economic growth with environmental sustainability. Green Total Factor Productivity (GTFP) is a key metric for this, reflecting how efficiently resources are used while minimizing negative environmental impacts. However, simply increasing individual factors like technology or better management doesn't guarantee higher GTFP. The challenge lies in understanding the complex, synergistic relationships between various influencing factors and how these combinations lead to either improved or stagnant GTFP. Previous research often focused on individual factors or linear relationships, overlooking the "causal complexity" and configurational nature of GTFP enhancement. This paper aims to address this by exploring how different combinations of technological, organizational, and environmental conditions lead to high GTFP, and conversely, what configurations result in low GTFP, particularly within the diverse regional context of China.
Methods
The study employs Fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA), a method well-suited for exploring complex causal relationships in small to medium-sized datasets. Unlike traditional regression analysis that looks for net effects of individual variables, fsQCA examines how combinations of conditions (antecedents) lead to an outcome (GTFP). The authors integrate the Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) theoretical framework to categorize these antecedent conditions into three main areas:
- Technical Conditions: Innovation capacity and information construction.
- Organizational Conditions: Industrial structure and environmental regulation.
- Environmental Conditions: Degree of openness and economic level.
The study first calibrates data for these six antecedent conditions and the GTFP outcome variable into fuzzy sets (scores between 0 and 1). It then uses fsQCA to identify necessary and sufficient configurations of these conditions that lead to high GTFP and non-high GTFP. This approach allows for the identification of multiple pathways to the outcome and accounts for "causal asymmetry" (i.e., the causes of high GTFP might differ from the causes of non-high GTFP).
Datasets
The study utilizes data from 30 Chinese provinces (municipalities and autonomous regions) for the period 2016-2018. The data for the variables were compiled from various official sources, including:
- China Statistical Yearbook
- China Environmental Statistical Yearbook
- China Science and Technology Statistical Yearbook
- China Energy Statistical Yearbook
- EPS database
Tibet was excluded due to missing data. The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather uses existing provincial-level data to apply its analytical framework.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Configurational Complexity: GTFP enhancement is not driven by a single factor but by specific combinations of technology, organization, and environment. This moves beyond simple linear causality.
- Causal Asymmetry: The pathways to achieving high GTFP are different from the pathways that lead to non-high GTFP. This highlights that simply reversing the conditions for high GTFP might not lead to its decline, and vice-versa.
- Substitutability: Under certain circumstances, different conditions can act as substitutes. For example, strong innovation capacity might compensate for a less developed information network, or robust environmental regulation might substitute for a less advanced industrial structure. This offers flexibility in strategy development.
- Regional Specialization: GTFP enhancement strategies show significant spatial distribution. Eastern and central China tend to leverage both organizational and technical support, while western China primarily relies on organizational management.
Key Results
The study identified seven configurations leading to high GTFP and five configurations leading to non-high GTFP.
Paths to High GTFP:
- Type of Organizational Management: Characterized by high industrial structure and high environmental regulation. This path is prevalent in eastern and central China.
- Type of Technical Support: Characterized by high innovation capacity and high information construction. This path is also found in eastern and central China.
Paths to Non-High GTFP:
- Organizational Management Deficit and Environmental Support Deficiency: Marked by a lack of environmental control and transparency, often seen in underdeveloped western regions.
- Organizational Management Imbalance and Technological Support Deficiency: Characterized by low information construction, weak industrial structure, and excessive environmental regulation, found in central and western China.
The overall solution consistency for high GTFP was 0.880, meaning 88% of the identified configurations lead to high GTFP, accounting for 71.7% of cases. For non-high GTFP, the consistency was 0.869, covering 70.4% of cases.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Limited Antecedent Variables: fsQCA can become computationally intensive with too many antecedent variables. This study included a "modest number," but future work could explore more.
- Provincial-Level Focus: While the study provides insights for provinces, more granular, city-specific studies might be needed for tailored policy recommendations.
- Lack of Temporal Analysis: The study used cross-sectional data (2016-2018). Future research should incorporate time-series data to analyze the temporal evolution of GTFP and its drivers using fsQCA.
Future research could also explore more complex scenarios, include additional cases, and investigate more specific fsQCA application directions within this field.
Summary updated