Research on Gendered Consumption Behavior among Idol Group Fans: Social Driving Forces and Emotional Differences

Chengyu LiuLecture Notes in Education Psychology and Public Media 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the sociological and psychological drivers behind gendered spending habits in K-pop fandom. It reveals that while female fans utilize consumption as a form of "emotional labor" to foster a sense of belonging, male fans approach it as a strategic tool to build social capital and signal personal taste.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

K-pop has evolved from a musical genre into a massive global "fan economy" where emotional investment directly translates into economic capital. While market data consistently shows that female fans spend more frequently on idol-related products, the underlying why remains under-researched.

The author addresses the gap between simple consumption statistics and the complex socio-cultural roots of these behaviors. Specifically, the paper explores how traditional gender roles and social structures are reproduced within fan communities, influencing how different genders rationalize their spending and perform their identities as fans.

Methods

The researcher employed a qualitative research design centered on semi-structured in-depth interviews.

  • Interview Structure: Sessions lasted between 30 and 60 minutes, using open-ended questions to allow participants to express nuanced feelings about motivation, social influence, and gender roles.
  • Analysis: The study utilized thematic analysis and comparative analysis. The author coded interview transcripts to identify recurring patterns and then contrasted the experiences of male vs. female participants through the lenses of Social Identity Theory (SIT) and Affective Labor Theory.

Datasets

As a qualitative study, this paper does not use large-scale quantitative datasets or benchmarks. Instead, it relies on a targeted sample of four Chinese K-pop fans:

  • Sample Size: $n=4$ (2 male, 2 female).
  • Demographics: Participants aged 18–24, either current undergraduate students or recent graduates.
  • Socio-economic Status: Relatively high-income backgrounds (family annual income between 400,000 and 600,000 RMB).
  • Geographic Diversity: Participants were located in Beijing, Hangzhou, and Melbourne, providing a mix of domestic and international perspectives.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Consumption as "Emotional Labor": For female fans, spending is often an extension of emotional labor—activities like data ranking, voting, and attending events to support the idol’s success. This labor is a way to reinforce their social identity and gain a sense of collective belonging.
  • Rationality as Gender Performance: Male fans often frame their consumption as "rational" or "strategic" to align with traditional masculine archetypes. They prioritize items with "long-term value" or "collectibility" (like limited-edition vinyl) over the more frequent, interaction-based spending seen in female fans.
  • Social Capital vs. Spiritual Fulfillment: Male participants (e.g., "Adios") admitted that posting concert photos feeds "vanity" and highlights social status. In contrast, female participants (e.g., "Liangren") described spending as a way to meet "spiritual needs" and seek emotional comfort, even if it meant cutting back on other life expenses.
  • The "Unfair Cycle": The paper suggests that the fan economy may reproduce gender inequality. The intense emotional labor of female fans is often undervalued or dismissed as "irrational," while the strategic, collection-oriented consumption of male fans receives more social recognition as a legitimate hobby.

Key Results

  • Spending Thresholds: Male fans demonstrated higher price sensitivity. One participant explicitly stated he would stop purchasing tickets if the price became "too high," indicating a utility-based approach to fandom.
  • Group Dynamics: Female fans were more likely to engage in "socially oriented consumption," such as attending performances they weren't personally interested in just to accompany friends and maintain community ties.
  • Identity Construction: Both genders use K-pop consumption to build self-esteem, but the mechanism differs: females build it through affiliation and support, while males build it through distinction and aesthetic taste.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: With only four participants, the findings are exploratory and cannot be generalized to the entire global K-pop fan base.
  • Homogeneity: The participants share similar socio-economic backgrounds (wealthy students), which may skew the results toward luxury or high-discretionary spending.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that future research should use quantitative methods to verify these gendered patterns across larger, more diverse populations (different regions, ages, and income levels) to see if these sociological drivers hold true at scale.

Summary updated

Abstract

The global expansion of K-pop idol culture reveals distinct gender differences in fan consumption behaviors. K-pop, as a global cultural phenomenon, has not only driven transformations in music, fashion, and consumption behavior but also established a distinct fan economic model. The consumption patterns of K-pop fan groups exhibit pronounced gender characteristics on a global scale. However, the current literature has yet to explore in depth the social, emotional, and psychological mechanisms behind these gender differences. As K-pop idol culture spreads globally, fan consumption demonstrates apparent gender differences. This study focuses on Chinese fans of K-pop idol groups. It employs in-depth interviews with two male and two female fans to explore the gendered differences in idol-related consumption and their underlying social, emotional, and psychological factors. Findings reveal that female fans prioritize emotional investment and a sense of belonging, leading to higher consumption frequency and expenditure. In contrast, male fans display a more rational consumption pattern, using their spending to showcase social capital and personal taste, emphasizing a balance between economic rationality and aesthetic value. These results may contribute to the academic discourse on idol culture and fan economics, providing a more comprehensive understanding of gendered consumption characteristics among fans.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025research,
  author = {Chengyu Liu},
  title = {{Research on Gendered Consumption Behavior among Idol Group Fans: Social Driving Forces and Emotional Differences}},
  booktitle = {Lecture Notes in Education Psychology and Public Media},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.54254/2753-7048/2025.21335},
}
Figure