Research on fuzzy PID Shared control method of small brain-controlled uav

Na Dong, Wenqi Zhang, Zhongke GaoarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Brain-controlled unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) interpret human neural signals via Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCI) to execute flight commands. Despite their potential, current BCI systems suffer from limited recognition accuracy, high latency, and a restricted command set, leading to suboptimal flight performance. This paper proposes a shared control framework utilizing a Fuzzy PID assistant controller to facilitate cooperative control between the human operator and an automated system. By evaluating real-time flight status and adjusting a switching rate, the system dynamically balances autonomous and manual control. Simulation results for a rectangular trajectory tracking task demonstrate that this hybrid approach significantly improves system stability and control performance.

Introduction: The BCI Bottleneck

Controlling robots through neural signals offers transformative possibilities, particularly for individuals with motor impairments. However, the high-frequency, high-precision adjustments required for stable quadrotor flight are often beyond the capabilities of current BCI technology. The researchers identify three primary challenges:

  1. Low Recognition Accuracy: EEG signals are inherently noisy and easily misinterpreted.
  2. High Latency: Processing neural signals into actionable commands introduces significant delay.
  3. Limited Command Sets: Humans can only reliably trigger a few distinct mental states, which is insufficient for the nuanced adjustments required for stability.

To address these, the authors move toward a Shared Control paradigm, where an automated "assistant" co-pilot smooths out high-level human intentions.

Proposed Shared Control Architecture

The core of the proposed system is a dual-loop control architecture that integrates human input with automated stability.

The overall shared control architecture, illustrating the integration of human EEG signals with an automated fuzzy controller via a switching mechanism.

As shown in the architecture above, the system evaluates environmental awareness and UAV state perception to inform motion planning. The resulting EEG signals are processed by a BCI and interface model. A critical component is the switching rate, which determines the balance between the human's high-level commands and the fuzzy controller's automated adjustments.

Dual-Loop Control Logic

The implementation details of the control loops are further refined using a combination of Fuzzy and standard PID controllers.

Detailed control block diagram showing the dual-loop structure: an outer loop for position control using Fuzzy PID and an inner loop for attitude control using standard PID.
  • Outer Loop (Position Control): This loop utilizes Fuzzy PID controllers for the $x, y,$ and $z$ coordinates. Unlike static PID controllers, the fuzzy logic adapts gains ($K_p, K_i, K_d$) in real-time based on linguistic rules (e.g., "If error is Large, then make $K_p$ Big"). This allows for aggressive response when far from the target and a gentle approach as the goal is reached.
  • Inner Loop (Attitude Control): Conventional PID controllers handle the rapid physics of maintaining orientation (pitch $\theta$, roll $\phi$, and yaw $\psi$).
  • Reverse Solution Module: This module translates desired global coordinates into specific motor speeds for the quadrotor frame.

Experimental Evaluation

The algorithm was verified in a virtual experimental environment designed to test trajectory tracking. The quadrotor was tasked with following a rectangular path at a constant height of 5 meters. The path consisted of two 200m straight segments and two 157m circular arcs. This specific geometry tests the system's ability to maintain stability during both linear flight and complex centrifugal maneuvers.

Key Insights and Results

The simulation results confirmed that the Fuzzy PID Shared Control method successfully navigated the trajectory. Key findings include:

  • Adaptive Tuning: The fuzzy logic effectively managed three stages of flight: an initial high-gain stage for speed, a balanced middle stage, and a late stage with increased integral gain to eliminate static error.
  • Robustness: The assistant controller compensated for the infrequent and coarse commands typical of BCI, maintaining a stable flight path where pure brain control would likely fail.
  • Linguistic Reasoning: By mapping parameters to seven fuzzy subsets (from "Negative Big" to "Positive Big"), the controller mimics human-like reasoning to optimize flight performance.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the shared control framework proves effective in simulation, real-world deployment faces hurdles such as environmental wind, sensor noise, and EEG signal degradation outside laboratory settings. Future work should focus on refining the mathematical thresholds for the switching rate and evaluating the cognitive load on human operators during extended shared-control missions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Brain-controlled unmanned aerial vehicle (uav) is a uav that can analyze human brain electrical signals through BCI to obtain flight commands. The research of brain-controlled uav can promote the integration of brain-computer and has a broad application prospect. At present, BCI still has some problems, such as limited recognition accuracy, limited recognition time and small number of recognition commands in the acquisition of control commands by analyzing eeg signals. Therefore, the control performance of the quadrotor which is controlled only by brain is not ideal. Based on the concept of Shared control, this paper designs an assistant controller using fuzzy PID control, and realizes the cooperative control between automatic control and brain control. By evaluating the current flight status and setting the switching rate, the switching mechanism of automatic control and brain control can be decided to improve the system control performance. Finally, a rectangular trajectory tracking control experiment of the same height is designed for small quadrotor to verify the algorithm.
BibTeX
@misc{dong2019research,
  author = {Na Dong and Wenqi Zhang and Zhongke Gao},
  title = {{Research on fuzzy PID Shared control method of small brain-controlled uav}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1905.12240},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.12240},
}
Figure