Research on Flood Discharge and Energy Dissipation of a Tunnel Group Layout for a Super-High Rockfill Dam in a High-Altitude Region

Haichao Zhang, Luchen Zhang, Shiqiang Wu, Fuming Wang, Zhenggang Zhan, Xueyu Zheng, Heng Zhang, Wei BaoWater 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates flood discharge and energy dissipation strategies for a super-high rockfill dam in a high-altitude region, focusing on the challenges posed by large intersection angles between discharge tunnels and the downstream river, as well as the impact of low atmospheric pressure. Through physical model testing, the study demonstrates that a "transverse diffusion and downturned flip bucket" approach significantly improves energy dissipation, reduces hydraulic pressure, and enhances downstream flow connection compared to conventional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Super-high rockfill dams, particularly those in high-altitude environments, present unique engineering challenges for flood discharge and energy dissipation. A primary issue is the "large angle" layout, where the axis of the flood discharge structure (like spillway tunnels) is significantly misaligned with the downstream river channel. This misalignment creates difficulties in ensuring a smooth flow connection and effective energy dissipation within the limited space of a plunge pool. Compounding this is the high-altitude environment, characterized by lower atmospheric pressure. This low pressure can alter the trajectory and behavior of the water jet (nappe), increasing its fall distance and potentially reducing the effectiveness of energy dissipation structures. Existing design specifications often overlook this low-pressure effect, leading to potential safety concerns. This paper aims to address these combined challenges by proposing and evaluating optimized flood discharge and energy dissipation layouts for such demanding conditions.

Methods

The core of this research relies on comprehensive hydraulic physical model testing. A 1:80 scale model of the RM hydropower project's flood discharge system was constructed and tested. The model included the upstream river channel, dam, spillway tunnels, flood discharge tunnel, plunge pool, and downstream river channel.

Key measurement techniques included:

  • Flow pattern observation: Photographed to understand water movement.
  • Trajectory distance and nappe width measurement: Using rulers and plumb lines to quantify the water jet's path and spread.
  • Hydrodynamic pressure measurement: Employing pressure sensors to record both time-averaged and fluctuating pressures on the plunge pool's bottom slab and side walls.
  • Velocity distribution measurement: Using an optical fiber propeller current meter to assess flow speeds downstream.

The study compared three main flip bucket types: upturned, horizontal, and downturned. Optimization efforts focused on modifying the flip bucket geometry and adopting a "transverse diffusion and downturned flip bucket" approach to address the identified problems. The influence of low atmospheric pressure was also investigated, with a modified flip distance formula developed and validated.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on physical model test data generated specifically for the RM hydropower project.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Low pressure is a significant factor: The paper highlights that reduced atmospheric pressure at high altitudes demonstrably increases the nappe's trajectory distance, a factor often neglected in standard design.
  • Conventional flip buckets are insufficient: For large angle layouts, traditional upturned flip buckets lead to a long nappe fall, insufficient energy dissipation space, high impact pressures, and poor downstream flow connection.
  • "Transverse diffusion and downturned flip bucket" is a superior solution: This optimized approach dramatically shortens the nappe falling point, significantly increases the effective energy dissipation area, reduces fluctuating pressures, and ensures a smooth connection with the downstream river.
  • Energy dissipation is spatially limited: Even with large plunge pools, the effective energy dissipation area can be a small fraction of the total, leading to high localized energy dissipation power per unit volume, which is a safety concern.
  • Atomization is a critical environmental consideration: Flood discharge can create significant rain and fog downstream, impacting the project and surrounding areas. The downturned flip bucket method substantially reduces the longitudinal range of this atomization.

Key Results

  • Nappe trajectory reduction: The optimized "transverse diffusion and downturned flip bucket" scheme reduced the nappe falling point by approximately 11 meters compared to conventional methods, considering low-pressure effects.
  • Effective energy dissipation area increase: This optimized scheme increased the effective energy dissipation space by 159% (compared to the conventional upturned flip bucket) and by 16% (compared to the horizontal flip bucket scheme).
  • Hydrodynamic pressure reduction: The RMS of the maximum fluctuating pressure on the plunge pool bottom slab and side walls was reduced by up to 74% with the downturned flip bucket compared to the upturned flip bucket.
  • Energy dissipation rate: The downturned flip mode achieved the highest energy dissipation rate of 80.2%, compared to 79.8% for the horizontal flip and 79.4% for the upturned flip mode.
  • Flood discharge atomization reduction: The longitudinal range of the heavy rainstorm area caused by atomization was reduced by 21-43% with the downturned flip mode compared to the upturned flip mode.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low-pressure influence is preliminary: While the study considers the impact of low pressure, it acknowledges that further comprehensive research into its effects on flood discharge flow characteristics is needed.
  • Scale effect: The paper mentions that scale effects have little impact on the macroscopic characteristics studied, but it's a general limitation of physical modeling.
  • Future work: The authors suggest further comprehensive studies on the impact of low pressure on flood discharge flow characteristics. They also imply that the proposed "transverse diffusion and downturned flip bucket" scheme provides a viable solution for similar high-altitude, large-angle discharge scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Under the condition of a large dip angle between the flood discharging structure axis and the downstream cushion pool centerline, the downstream flow connection for the discharging tunnel group is poor, and the lower air pressure in high-altitude areas increases its influence on the trajectory distance of the nappe, further increasing the difficulty of predicting the flood discharge and energy dissipation layout. Based on the RM hydropower project with the world’s highest earth-rockfill dam, this paper studies the problem of a large included angle flip energy dissipation layout of a tunnel group flood discharge using the method of the overall hydraulic physical model test. The test results show that the conventional flip outlet mode has a long nappe falling point, a serious shortage of effective energy dissipation space, a large dynamic hydraulic pressure impact peak value on the bottom slab and side wall of the plunge pool, a poor flow connection between the outlet of the plunge pool and the downstream river channel, and a low energy dissipation rate. Considering the influence of a low-pressure environment, when the “transverse diffusion and downward incidence” outflow is adopted, the nappe falling point shrinks by 11 m, the energy dissipation form of the plunge pool is greatly improved, the effective energy dissipation space is increased by 159%, the RMS of the maximum fluctuating pressure is reduced by 74%, the outflow is smoothly connected with the downstream river, the energy dissipation rate is increased by 0.8%, and the protection range of flood discharge atomization is significantly reduced. This effectively solves the safety problems of large included angle discharge return channels and the energy dissipation and erosion prevention of super-high rockfill dams.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2021research,
  author = {Haichao Zhang and Luchen Zhang and Shiqiang Wu and Fuming Wang and Zhenggang Zhan and Xueyu Zheng and Heng Zhang and Wei Bao},
  title = {{Research on Flood Discharge and Energy Dissipation of a Tunnel Group Layout for a Super-High Rockfill Dam in a High-Altitude Region}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/w13233408},
}
Figure