TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel approach to allocating drainage rights in flood-prone regions by integrating the DPSIR framework with a game theory-enhanced matter-element extension model. This method aims to provide a more equitable and effective distribution of drainage rights, crucial for mitigating flood impacts and enhancing regional flood control efficiency.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The increasing frequency and intensity of floods, exacerbated by global warming, pose significant threats to socio-economic development, ecological stability, and public safety. In regions like the Sunan Canal in China, rapid urbanization and economic activity lead to complex water management challenges, including conflicts over drainage during heavy rainfall events. Existing flood control measures, primarily engineering-based, are often insufficient. This paper addresses the need for a robust and fair system for allocating "drainage rights" – the right to discharge floodwater – to manage these conflicts, reduce flood losses, and optimize regional flood control benefits. The challenge lies in developing a comprehensive model that accounts for diverse influencing factors and their relative importance.
Methods
The authors propose a multi-stage methodology:
- DPSIR Framework for Indicator System: They adapt the Driving force-Pressure-State-Impact-Response (DPSIR) model to construct an index system for drainage rights allocation. This framework helps to systematically identify and categorize factors influencing drainage rights, considering environmental, economic, and social aspects.
- Game Combination Weighting for Indicator Weights: To determine the importance of each indicator, they combine subjective weights (derived from the Analytic Hierarchy Process - AHP) and objective weights (from the Entropy Weight Method). Game theory is then employed to optimally combine these weights, minimizing discrepancies and achieving a more rational weighting scheme.
- Improved Matter-Element Extension Model for Allocation: This model is used to evaluate and allocate drainage rights. It involves defining a "classical domain" for drainage priority levels and then calculating the "closeness" of each region to these levels. This closeness measure, weighted by the previously determined indicator weights, ultimately determines the proportion of drainage rights allocated to each region.
Datasets
The study utilizes data from the south Jiangsu canal region (specifically Zhenjiang, Changzhou, Suzhou, and Wuxi) for the period 2017–2021. The data sources include statistical yearbooks, water resources bulletins, soil and water conservation bulletins, and national disaster reduction network data. Qualitative indicators were determined through expert consultation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Holistic Approach: The DPSIR framework provides a structured way to consider the complex interplay of factors (environmental, economic, social) affecting flood risk and drainage needs.
- Bridging Subjective and Objective Weights: Combining AHP (expert opinion) with Entropy (data-driven) through game theory offers a more robust and less biased approach to assigning indicator weights compared to using either method alone.
- Drainage Rights as a Tool: The concept of drainage rights is presented as a critical non-engineering measure for flood management, enabling more equitable distribution of responsibilities and benefits.
- Economic and Ecological Dominance: The study highlights that ecological and economic factors (driving force system) are the most influential in determining drainage rights allocation, underscoring the need for integrated development strategies.
Key Results
The study found that drainage rights allocation is significantly influenced by social, economic, and ecological aspects, with the driving force system (ecological and economic factors) being the most influential. The order of drainage rights quota size for the studied regions from 2017 to 2021 was consistently: Wuxi, Suzhou, Changzhou, and Zhenjiang. Wuxi and Suzhou, being more economically developed, received the largest share, followed by Changzhou, with Zhenjiang receiving the least. This suggests that more developed regions, with higher economic activity and population density, require greater drainage capacity and thus higher drainage rights.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Limitations: While the study uses data from 2017-2021, the authors acknowledge that the data range could be extended for more comprehensive analysis.
- Expert Subjectivity: Despite efforts to mitigate it, the AHP component still relies on expert judgment, which can introduce some level of subjectivity.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that their methodology provides a reference for drainage rights trading and can be further applied to improve flood control and drainage systems. Future research could explore dynamic allocation models and incorporate more granular data.
Summary updated