Research on Damage Identification in Transmission Tower Structures Based on Cross-Correlation Function Amplitude Vector

Qing Zhang, Xing Fu, Wenqiang Jiang, Hai JinSensors 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel two-step method for identifying damage in transmission towers using only time-domain vibration data. By analyzing changes in the "cross-correlation function amplitude vector" (CorV) and its derivatives, the method can detect and pinpoint structural damage without needing complex frequency analysis or operational downtime.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Transmission towers are vital infrastructure, but they are constantly exposed to environmental stressors like wind and earthquakes, leading to cumulative damage. Early detection of this damage is crucial to prevent catastrophic failures that could disrupt power supply and have significant economic consequences. Existing damage identification methods often rely on static analysis, which doesn't capture dynamic behavior, or require complex transformations from time-domain to frequency-domain data, which can introduce errors and reduce computational efficiency. This paper aims to provide a more direct and robust method for damage identification using readily available time-domain vibration data.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is a two-step approach:

  1. Damage Detection (Existence): This step utilizes the Cross-Correlation Function Amplitude Vector (CorV). The CorV is calculated between the response of a reference measuring point and all other measuring points on the tower. By comparing the CorV of a structure in a potentially damaged state to its healthy state, a metric called the CorV Assurance Criterion (CVAC) is computed. A CVAC value significantly less than 1 indicates that the structure has experienced damage. To facilitate comparison, the CorV is normalized.
  2. Damage Localization (Location): Once damage is detected, the method pinpoints its location. This involves calculating the relative change in the normalized CorV between the healthy and damaged states, denoted as $E_{cv}$. To enhance the sensitivity to localized damage, a first-order difference processing is applied to $E_{cv}$, resulting in a new metric, $E_{cv}$. Significant mutations or peaks in the $E_{cv}$ curve are indicative of the damaged structural elements.

The method is designed to work directly with time-domain responses (like acceleration or strain) without requiring transformations to the frequency domain.

Datasets

  • Numerical Simulation: A finite element model of an actual transmission tower in Jiangmen was created using ANSYS 2019 R2. Damage was simulated by reducing the stiffness of specific members. Various working conditions were defined, including healthy states and states with single and multiple damaged elements.
  • Experimental Data: A scaled model of the transmission tower was fabricated and tested in a laboratory. Damage was simulated by weakening a specific bar. Displacement responses were collected under healthy and damaged conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Time-Domain Simplicity: The most significant insight is the ability to perform damage identification directly from time-domain signals. This bypasses the complexities and potential error sources associated with frequency-domain analysis.
  • CorV as a "Dynamic Fingerprint": The CorV effectively captures the dynamic characteristics of the structure. Changes in its components directly reflect alterations in structural integrity.
  • CVAC for Damage Detection: The CVAC provides a clear, quantifiable measure of structural damage. A value deviating significantly from 1 is a strong indicator of damage.
  • First-Order Difference for Localization: Applying a first-order difference to the relative CorV change ($E_{cv}$) amplifies localized damage signatures, making it easier to pinpoint the affected elements.
  • Robustness to Noise and Response Type: The method demonstrated reasonable resilience to noise interference and was effective when using both acceleration and strain responses, suggesting broad applicability.

Key Results

  • Damage Detection: The CVAC value consistently decreased when damage was introduced, effectively indicating the presence of damage. For instance, in numerical simulations, CVAC values dropped from near 1 to values like 0.999974 (single damage) and 0.999908 (multiple damage).
  • Damage Localization: The first-order difference of $E_{cv}$ showed distinct peaks at the locations of simulated damage. In numerical simulations, damage to element No. 5 was accurately identified, and in the experimental test, damage to unit No. 7 was located.
  • Comparison with Existing Methods: The proposed method outperformed a displacement modal difference method in identifying damage location, as the latter struggled to distinguish between healthy and damaged states from displacement modes alone.
  • Noise Tolerance: The method could still identify damage location with up to 10% added noise, demonstrating good anti-noise performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Misjudgments at Extremes: The paper notes that misjudgments can occur at the base of the tower when using acceleration responses (due to low signal amplitude) and at the top when using strain responses.
  • Adjacent Element Confusion: The first-order difference method can sometimes lead to misjudgments of adjacent elements, especially when damage is localized.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest future work should focus on developing a more comprehensive index to mitigate the impact of these misjudgments, particularly at the tower's base and top. Further research could also explore finer element division and increased sensor density for improved localization accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Transmission towers constitute critical power infrastructure, yet structural damage may accumulate over their long-term service, underscoring the paramount importance of research on damage identification. This paper presents a cross-correlation function amplitude vector (CorV) method for damage localization based on time-domain response analysis. The approach involves calculating the CorV of structural members before and after damage using dynamic response data, employing the CorV assurance criterion (CVAC) to quantify changes in CorV, and introducing first-order differencing for damage localization. Taking an actual transmission tower in Jiangmen as the engineering backdrop, a finite element model is established. Damage conditions are simulated by reducing the stiffness of specific members, and parameter analyses are conducted to validate the proposed method. Furthermore, experimental validation in a lab is performed to provide additional confirmation. The results indicate that the CVAC value of the damaged structure is significantly lower than that in the healthy state. By analyzing the relative changes in the components of CorV, the damage location can be accurately determined. Notably, this method only requires acquiring the time-domain response signals of the transmission tower under random excitation to detect both the existence and location of damage. Consequently, it is well suited for structural health monitoring of transmission towers under environmental excitation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025research,
  author = {Qing Zhang and Xing Fu and Wenqiang Jiang and Hai Jin},
  title = {{Research on Damage Identification in Transmission Tower Structures Based on Cross-Correlation Function Amplitude Vector}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/s25154659},
}
Figure