Research on Coordinated Control of Multi-PMSM for Shaftless Overprinting System

Yuntao Xu, Cheng Liu, Zihao Huang, S. Sun, Z.y. CuiSymmetry 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of precise speed synchronization in multi-motor systems for shaftless printing. By combining an advanced sliding mode control (SMC) for current loops with a novel deviation coupling compensator for speed loops, the researchers achieve significantly improved synchronization accuracy, disturbance rejection, and overall system stability compared to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern industrial applications, particularly in high-precision printing, increasingly rely on multi-motor coordinated control systems. Shaftless printing systems, which use multiple permanent magnet synchronous motors (PMSMs) to drive individual cylinders, demand extremely high synchronization accuracy to ensure print quality and prevent material waste. Traditional control methods, like PID, often struggle with suboptimal control accuracy, compromised synchronization, and reduced stability, especially under variable load conditions and external disturbances. Existing solutions for PMSM synchronization in these systems also face limitations, such as chattering in SMC or complex tuning requirements for other advanced controllers. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a robust and highly synchronized control strategy for multi-PMSM systems in shaftless printing.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a novel, hierarchical control strategy:

  • Current Loop: An improved super-twisting sliding mode control (SMC) is employed. SMC is known for its robustness to uncertainties and disturbances. The "super-twisting" aspect refers to a specific type of SMC that helps mitigate the chattering phenomenon often associated with basic SMC.
  • Speed Loop: A new, enhanced sliding mode controller (NSMC) is developed, incorporating a novel approach law. This NSMC is designed to improve convergence speed and reduce oscillations.
  • Deviation Coupling Compensator: An optimized deviation coupling control structure (NDCS) is introduced. This compensator focuses on inter-motor synchronization by evaluating speed differences and applying corrective actions. It's an improvement over traditional deviation coupling methods by incorporating a weighted arithmetic mean for optimization.

The overall architecture combines these elements to achieve coordinated control of multiple PMSMs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulation experiments using MATLAB/Simulink.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of SMC and Deviation Coupling: The paper demonstrates that combining the robustness of sliding mode control (for current loops) with the explicit synchronization focus of deviation coupling (for speed loops) leads to superior performance.
  • Mitigating Chattering: The use of an "improved" sliding mode controller and a novel approach law is crucial for reducing the inherent chattering problem of SMC, leading to smoother operation.
  • Enhanced Synchronization: The optimized deviation coupling compensator effectively reduces inter-motor speed errors, which is critical for precise printing registration.
  • Robustness to Disturbances: The proposed control strategy shows significant improvement in handling load fluctuations and external disturbances, a common challenge in industrial settings.

Key Results

The simulation results highlight the effectiveness of the proposed NSMC+NDCS strategy:

  • Improved Dynamic Response: The combined strategy achieves a 38.7% faster dynamic response compared to conventional methods.
  • Enhanced Stability: The system exhibits a 21.4% improvement in stability metrics under complex operating conditions.
  • Reduced Overshoot and Ripple: Compared to traditional PI and SMC, the NSMC achieves overshoot-free stabilization within 0.02s, with speed tracking errors as low as 0.05 rad/s and torque ripple of ±0.2 N·m.
  • Superior Disturbance Rejection: Dynamic load tests confirm a 25.3% overshoot reduction and a 40% phase margin improvement.
  • Reduced Synchronization Errors: The NDCS significantly reduces inter-motor speed deviations, with peak deviations limited to 8 r/min and steady-state deviations to 0.2 r/min, outperforming traditional methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study primarily relies on simulation results. While the simulations are comprehensive, real-world implementation might introduce additional complexities and require further tuning. The paper also mentions that the sliding mode term and coupling term might approach the physical limitations of drive components.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future research should integrate cutting-edge control theory (adaptive SMC, distributed architectures), advanced enabling technologies (TSN networks, FPGA acceleration), and intelligent systems (digital twins, deep learning) to further address challenges in shaftless printing registration control. This interdisciplinary approach aims to advance printing technology and develop universally applicable theoretical frameworks for multi-motor coordination.

Summary updated

Abstract

In response to the limitations of suboptimal control accuracy, compromised synchronization capability, and reduced stability inherent in PID control for conventional shaftless multi-permanent magnet synchronous motor drive systems, this article establishes a three-motor synchronous control system model for a shaftless printing system. On this basis, the speed loop adopts a sliding mode controller (NSMC) based on a new approach law, and the current loop adopts an improved super spiral structure. At the same time, the compensator of the deviation coupling control structure (NDCS) is optimized by weighted arithmetic mean. Finally, comparative simulation experiments were conducted on the system model using various algorithms. The results show that the deviation coupling control structure based on improved sliding mode control has better anti-interference ability, control accuracy, and synchronization in the synchronous control strategy of a multi-permanent magnet motor drive in a shaftless printing system, which is conducive to the safe and stable operation of shaftless printing systems under multiple working conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2025research,
  author = {Yuntao Xu and Cheng Liu and Zihao Huang and S. Sun and Z.Y. Cui},
  title = {{Research on Coordinated Control of Multi-PMSM for Shaftless Overprinting System}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/sym17060958},
}
Figure