TL;DR
This paper tackles the critical challenge of inefficient information sharing in new energy vehicle (NEV) supply chains, which hinders sustainability and green development. It proposes a novel evolutionary game model integrating blockchain and traceability to optimize information collaboration, leading to reduced waste, lower emissions, and improved overall efficiency.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The transition to low-carbon transportation heavily relies on the efficient and sustainable operation of new energy vehicle (NEV) supply chains. However, these supply chains are plagued by issues like resource waste, duplicated production, and low logistics efficiency, largely stemming from poor information coordination. While the benefits of information collaboration are well-documented (reduced costs, improved quality, enhanced adaptability), its adoption remains low. This paper investigates the key factors hindering this adoption and proposes a solution to overcome these bottlenecks, aiming to foster a more sustainable and green NEV industry.
Methods
The research employs a multi-faceted approach:
- Modified Delphi Technique and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): These methods were used to identify and prioritize the main factors restricting information collaboration in NEV supply chains. Expert surveys were conducted to gather insights.
- Evolutionary Game Theory (EGT): To model the dynamic and boundedly rational decision-making of supply chain participants, EGT was utilized. This approach captures how strategies evolve over time through learning and imitation, moving beyond the assumption of perfect rationality in traditional game theory.
- Blockchain and Traceability Technology Integration: The proposed model integrates blockchain for enhanced security and trustworthiness, and traceability systems to ensure data integrity and standardization. This combination acts as a robust carrier for information collaboration.
- Jacobian Matrix Calculation: Used to analyze the stability of the evolutionary game model and identify equilibrium points.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on expert surveys and simulated case studies (Company T and Company X) with processed and anonymized data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Key Barriers Identified: The study pinpoints information quality, information security, and a lack of motivation among senior management as the primary obstacles to effective information collaboration in NEV supply chains.
- EGT for Realistic Dynamics: Applying evolutionary game theory is crucial because real-world decision-making is influenced by factors like information asymmetry and cognitive biases, not just pure rationality.
- Blockchain as a Trust Enabler: Blockchain's inherent properties of decentralization, security, and immutability are vital for building trust and enabling secure information sharing in a complex, multi-stakeholder supply chain.
- Traceability as a Data Foundation: Integrating traceability systems provides a standardized and high-quality data backbone, essential for effective information collaboration.
- Synergy and Initial Conditions Matter: The success of collaborative strategies is significantly influenced by the initial synergy ratio and the effectiveness of incentive/punishment mechanisms.
Key Results
- Significant Impact of Information Quality: Information quality was found to have a statistically significant positive impact on information collaboration and supply chain performance, both directly and indirectly.
- Information Collaboration as a Mediator: Information collaboration partially mediates the relationship between information quality and supply chain performance.
- Evolutionary Game Model Validation: The proposed evolutionary game model, integrating blockchain and traceability, demonstrated its effectiveness in optimizing information collaboration. Case studies of Company T (mature) and Company X (emerging) showed that with appropriate parameter settings and mechanisms, the system can evolve towards stable, fully collaborative states.
- Company T's Success: Company T, with its mature collaboration mechanisms, effectively leveraged incentives and punishments to achieve stable cooperation, even with lower initial synergy ratios.
- Company X's Challenges: Company X, being in an earlier stage, faced challenges due to weaker incentive mechanisms and insufficient synergistic benefits to overcome the risks of non-collaboration, often converging to non-synergistic states.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Standardization: A lack of unified data standards across the NEV supply chain hinders comprehensive data coverage and information provision.
- Blockchain Costs: The current high cost of blockchain technology adoption poses a barrier to widespread implementation.
- Generalizability: The study used two case companies, and further verification with a broader range of companies is needed to assess generalizability.
- Model Simplification: The supply chain is a complex network, and the model, while incorporating key factors, might simplify some relationships.
- Future Directions: Future research should expand on research elements, network levels, market share, and enterprise scale. Multi-objective optimization (collaboration efficiency, cost, profit) and practical implementation through industry-wide blockchain alliances are also suggested.
Summary updated