Research on an Intelligent Fault Diagnosis Method for Small Modular Reactors

Changan Ren, Jichong Lei, Jie Liu, Jun Hong, Hong Hu, Xiao‐Yong Fang, Cannan Yi, Zhiqiang Peng, Xiaohua Yang, Tao YuEnergies 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel deep learning approach, specifically a CNN-BiLSTM model, for intelligent fault diagnosis in Small Modular Reactors (SMRs). By simulating SMR operational data and training the model, they achieved a high diagnostic accuracy of 97.33%, demonstrating its potential for enhancing SMR safety and enabling autonomous control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) represent a new generation of nuclear power technology, offering advantages like increased automation and intelligence. However, their unique design specifications and safety systems differ significantly from traditional commercial nuclear power plants. This means that existing fault diagnosis techniques, developed for conventional reactors, are not directly applicable to SMRs. The challenge is to develop specialized, intelligent fault diagnosis systems that can accurately identify anomalies and potential failures in these advanced SMR designs, thereby improving operational safety and reducing the reliance on manual intervention.

Methods

The researchers employed a data-driven approach using a deep learning framework. They simulated various operational conditions and accident scenarios for the System-integrated Modular Advanced ReacTor (SMART) SMR using the PCTRAN/SMR V1.0 software.

The core of their methodology involved comparing four different neural network architectures for fault diagnosis:

  • CNN (Convolutional Neural Network): Effective for extracting spatial hierarchies from data.
  • LSTM (Long Short-Term Memory): Suitable for processing sequential data and capturing temporal dependencies.
  • CNN-LSTM: Combines CNN for feature extraction and LSTM for temporal analysis.
  • CNN-BiLSTM: An extension of CNN-LSTM that uses Bidirectional LSTMs. This allows the model to process sequential data in both forward and backward directions, capturing dependencies from both past and future states, which is crucial for understanding complex temporal patterns.

The data was preprocessed using min-max normalization to scale features and then split into training, validation, and testing sets. One-hot encoding was used for operational conditions. The models were trained and evaluated using accuracy and categorical cross-entropy loss.

Datasets

The study utilized simulated data generated by the PCTRAN/SMR V1.0 software. Six operational conditions were simulated:

  • Normal operation
  • In-containment loss of coolant
  • Ex-containment loss of coolant
  • Containment steam pipe rupture
  • Main pump failure
  • Turbine trip

Six key parameters were extracted as features: nuclear power, pressurizer pressure, pressurizer water level, coolant flow rate, average coolant temperature, and steam generator pressure. The data was sampled into 5-second segments with a time length of 7 seconds for each data point. The dataset was divided into training (70%), validation (10%), and testing (20%) sets, totaling 3000 data sets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SMRs are fundamentally different: The study highlights that SMRs exhibit distinct operational parameter trends compared to traditional PWRs, especially under fault conditions. This underscores the necessity for SMR-specific fault diagnosis models.
  • Bidirectional processing is key: The superior performance of the CNN-BiLSTM model suggests that considering temporal dependencies in both forward and backward directions is critical for accurately diagnosing faults in complex dynamic systems like SMRs.
  • Deep learning for autonomous control: The high accuracy achieved by the CNN-BiLSTM model provides strong evidence for its potential to support autonomous control systems in SMRs, reducing human error and enhancing safety.

Key Results

The study compared the performance of four deep learning models:

  • CNN Model: Achieved a prediction accuracy of 83.67%.
  • LSTM Model: Achieved a prediction accuracy of 91.83%.
  • CNN-LSTM Model: Achieved a prediction accuracy of 92.67%.
  • CNN-BiLSTM Model: Achieved the highest prediction accuracy of 97.33%.

The CNN-BiLSTM model demonstrated superior generalization capabilities and stability, with similar accuracies in both training and validation. Confusion matrices indicated that while some fault types were harder to distinguish (e.g., different types of coolant loss), the CNN-BiLSTM model was most effective at differentiating between various operational modes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge two primary limitations:

  1. Limited Generalizability: The study focused exclusively on the SMART SMR design. The findings may not be universally applicable to all SMR designs.
  2. Simulated Data: The data used for training and validation was generated from simulation software (PCTRAN/SMR). While the simulation aligns with real-world trends, there might be variations in individual parameter values compared to actual operational data.

For future work, the authors suggest:

  • Model Migration: Investigating how to adapt or transfer models trained on one SMR design to others.
  • Real Accident Data: Utilizing authentic accident records from actual SMR operations to validate and refine the models, moving beyond simulation data. This would significantly enhance the robustness and real-world applicability of the fault diagnosis systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Small modular reactors (SMRs) are currently advancing towards increased degrees of automation and intelligence, with intelligent control emerging as a prominent trend in SMR development. SMRs exhibit significant variations in design specifications and safety auxiliary system design as compared to conventional commercial nuclear power reactors. Consequently, defect diagnostic techniques that rely on commercial nuclear power plants are not appropriate for SMRs. This study designed a defect detection system for the System-integrated Modular Advanced ReacTor SMR by utilizing the PCTRAN/SMR V1.0 software and a deep learning neural network structure. Through the comparison of several neural network designs, it was discovered that the CNN-BiLSTM model, which utilizes bidirectional data processing, obtained a fault diagnostic accuracy of 97.33%. This result confirms the accuracy and effectiveness of the fault diagnosis system. This strongly supports the eventual implementation of autonomous control for SMRs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2024research,
  author = {Changan Ren and Jichong Lei and Jie Liu and Jun Hong and Hong Hu and Xiao‐Yong Fang and Cannan Yi and Zhiqiang Peng and Xiaohua Yang and Tao Yu},
  title = {{Research on an Intelligent Fault Diagnosis Method for Small Modular Reactors}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/en17164049},
}
Figure