Research on active and passive schemes for safety improvement of nuclear energy hydrogen production system

Qunxiang Gao, Qi Sun, Ping Zhang, Gang Zhao, Wei PengFrontiers in Nuclear Engineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluates three safety strategies—two passive and one active—designed to prevent combustible hydrogen clouds from reaching nuclear power plants in integrated hydrogen production facilities. Using large-scale numerical simulations, the researchers demonstrated that while all methods significantly reduce hydrogen diffusion distances, an active fan array is the most effective, followed closely by a centralized semi-cylindrical barrier.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "Hydrogen Economy" relies on efficient, low-carbon production. Coupling nuclear power plants (NPPs) with hydrogen production facilities is a promising solution, but it introduces a major safety headache: the risk of high-pressure hydrogen leakage.

If a storage tank (typically pressurized to around 8 MPa) leaks, it creates a high-velocity jet that can form a combustible cloud. If this cloud reaches the NPP, the consequences could be catastrophic. While simply increasing the distance between the two plants improves safety, it also leads to significant heat loss in the high-temperature helium delivery pipelines. The challenge is to find a way to "shrink" the danger zone—the distance at which hydrogen concentration stays above the 4% flammability limit—allowing for safer, more compact plant layouts.

Methods

The authors employed Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to simulate leakage scenarios on an extensive spatial scale (a 600m x 600m x 200m domain). They utilized the SIMPLEC algorithm to solve velocity and pressure fields and the Shear Stress Transport (SST) $k-\omega$ turbulence model, which is known for its accuracy in predicting flow separation and jet behavior.

The study compared three specific safety improvement schemes:

  1. Scheme 1 (Passive Distributed): A "forest" of conical soil mounds (2m high) arranged to break up the hydrogen jet.
  2. Scheme 2 (Passive Centralized): A single, large semi-cylindrical obstacle (20m wide) placed 30m from the leak source.
  3. Scheme 3 (Active): A 10m x 10m fan array that blows air against the direction of the leak to create a reverse airflow.

Datasets

As this is a numerical simulation study, it does not use a training dataset in the traditional machine learning sense. However, the authors validated their CFD model against experimental data from Hu et al. (2018), which measured helium jet concentrations impinging on obstacles. The simulation matched the experimental trends with a maximum absolute error of less than 2%, confirming the model's reliability for high-pressure gas leakage scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Staggered vs. Aligned: In the passive mound scheme (Scheme 1), a staggered arrangement is significantly more effective than a linear one. The staggered mounds force the hydrogen jet to divide and dilute repeatedly, whereas a linear gap can act as a "highway" for the gas.
  • The Buoyancy Shift: At low wind speeds (1 m/s), obstacles do more than just block the gas; they kill the jet's momentum, allowing hydrogen's natural buoyancy to take over. This causes the combustible cloud to rise safely into the air rather than spreading horizontally toward the NPP.
  • Active Intervention: The active fan array (Scheme 3) provides the most dramatic reduction in diffusion distance by creating a "virtual wall" of air. However, the paper notes that this requires a constant power supply and monitoring, whereas passive schemes are "set and forget."
  • Wind Speed Sensitivity: Diffusion distances more than double when ambient wind speeds increase from 1 m/s to 15 m/s, highlighting that safety distances must be calculated based on worst-case weather conditions.

Key Results

The study measured the "diffusion distance"—the maximum range where hydrogen concentration exceeds the 4% flammability limit.

Scheme Low Wind (1 m/s) High Wind (15 m/s)
No Mitigation (Baseline) ~Hundreds of meters ~Hundreds of meters
Scheme 1 (Mounds) 123 m 282 m
Scheme 2 (Barrier) 56 m 100 m
Scheme 3 (Fans) 46 m 79 m

The active fan array (Scheme 3) was the clear winner, reducing the danger zone to just 79 meters even in high-wind conditions. However, the centralized barrier (Scheme 2) performed remarkably well for a passive solution, keeping the cloud within 100 meters.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for further refinement:

  • Topography: The current model assumes a flat ground surface (aside from the obstacles). Real-world terrain and other plant buildings would likely complicate the flow field.
  • Idealized Obstacles: The study uses perfect geometric shapes. Future research could look at more "natural" obstacles or optimize the specific curvature of the barriers.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis: While Scheme 3 is the most effective, it is also the most expensive to build and maintain. A comprehensive study would need to weigh the construction costs against the safety gains.
  • Environmental Factors: The impact of varying humidity or temperature gradients in the atmosphere was not explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nuclear hydrogen production has the advantages of large-scale and low carbon emissions, and is expected to play an active role in the energy transition process. However, the storage and transportation of hydrogen pose potential risks of leakage and diffusion when connected to high-pressure hydrogen storage tanks and pipelines. To address this concern, this study focused on designing three distinct safety improvement schemes tailored for potential hydrogen leakage accidents. These schemes encompassed a passively distributed arrangement of obstacles (Scheme 1), a passively centralized arrangement of obstacles (Scheme 2), and an active fan array blowing (Scheme 3). Numerical simulation methods were applied on extensive spatial scales for relevant calculations. The results revealed that all three schemes effectively reduced the diffusion distance of combustible hydrogen. Specifically, at lower ambient wind speeds, Scheme 1, Scheme 2, and Scheme 3 achieved the shortest diffusion distances of 123 m, 56 m, and 46 m, respectively. Meanwhile, at higher ambient wind speeds, the corresponding distances were 282 m, 100 m, and 79 m. These results collectively offer valuable insights to mitigate the risk of leakage accidents in nuclear hydrogen production systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2024research,
  author = {Qunxiang Gao and Qi Sun and Ping Zhang and Gang Zhao and Wei Peng},
  title = {{Research on active and passive schemes for safety improvement of nuclear energy hydrogen production system}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Nuclear Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fnuen.2024.1381737},
}
Figure