Research on a Partial Aperture Factor Measurement Method for the AGRI Onboard Calibration Assembly

Xiaolong Si, Xiuju Li, Hongyao Chen, Shiwei Bao, Heyu Xu, Liming Zhang, Wenxin HuangSensors 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for measuring the Partial Aperture Factor (PAF) for the AGRI sensor's onboard calibration system. This is crucial for accurately calibrating large-aperture remote sensing instruments, and their method achieves a measurement uncertainty of approximately 2.04%, providing a vital reference for future calibration efforts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate radiometric calibration is fundamental for the reliability of remote sensing data. While pre-launch calibration is essential, most sensors rely on on-orbit calibration. For large-aperture sensors, traditional full-aperture onboard calibration methods can be complex and space-intensive. The AGRI sensor on the FengYun-4 satellite uses a partial aperture onboard calibration scheme to address this. A key parameter for this scheme is the Partial Aperture Factor (PAF), which quantifies how much light is transmitted through the partial aperture compared to the full aperture. Accurately determining the PAF is critical for the overall radiometric calibration accuracy of the AGRI, but measuring it precisely, especially when direct simulation of the same radiance input for both the imaging and calibration paths is difficult, presents a significant challenge.

Methods

The authors propose a method to measure the AGRI's PAF using the onboard Solar Diffuser Reflectance Degradation Monitor (SDRDM) as a reference radiometer. The core idea is to establish a relative response relationship between the AGRI and the SDRDM under controlled laboratory conditions.

  1. Linear Response Relationship: They first establish a linear relationship between the AGRI and SDRDM response counts when both observe the same radiance source at various intensity levels. This is achieved using a large-aperture integrating sphere as a stable radiance source.
  2. BRDF Correction: Using the known Bidirectional Reflectance Distribution Function (BRDF) of the solar diffuser (SD) in the calibration assembly, they calculate the relative reflectance ratio between the AGRI's and SDRDM's observation directions. This allows them to correct for differences in how the SD reflects light towards each instrument.
  3. PAF Calculation: By combining the established linear response relationship and the BRDF correction, they simulate the AGRI's full-aperture response to the radiance input. The PAF is then determined by comparing this simulated full-aperture response to the actual measured response of the AGRI's calibration optical path.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on laboratory measurements and instrument characterization data rather than external datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Onboard Components: The ingenious use of the SDRDM, an existing onboard component, as a reference radiometer for measuring the PAF significantly simplifies the measurement process and avoids the need for external calibration equipment beyond the laboratory setup.
  • Bridging the Gap: The method effectively bridges the gap between the AGRI's imaging path and its calibration path by establishing a relative response calibration, overcoming the difficulty of applying the exact same radiance input to both simultaneously.
  • Uncertainty Analysis is Crucial: The paper emphasizes the importance of a thorough uncertainty analysis for the PAF measurement, highlighting that this factor is a major contributor to the overall onboard calibration uncertainty.

Key Results

  • The proposed method successfully measured the PAF for AGRI bands B1, B2, and B3.
  • The measurement repeatability of the PAF was found to be better than 0.26%.
  • The overall measurement uncertainty for the PAF was determined to be approximately 2.04%.
  • The study identified several sources of uncertainty, including the stability and uniformity of the integrating sphere and solar simulator, relative SD BRDF measurements, and stray light.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Band Coverage: The AGRI has six solar reflective bands, but the SDRDM only has three monitoring bands. This means the PAF for bands B4-B6 had to be calculated indirectly using band ratios, which might introduce additional uncertainty.
  • System-Level Dependence: Some aperture factor tests cannot be fully decoupled from the remote sensor itself, necessitating system-level tests.
  • On-Orbit Verification: The study focused on laboratory tests under a 0° declination incidence angle. The paper acknowledges that whether the aperture factor changes under different solar incidence angles during actual on-orbit operations needs further testing and verification. This is a critical area for future research to ensure the robustness of the calibration throughout the satellite's mission.

Summary updated

Abstract

A partial aperture onboard calibration method can solve the onboard calibration problems of some large aperture remote sensors, which is of great significance for the development trend of increasingly large apertures in optical remote sensors. In this paper, the solar diffuser reflectance degradation monitor (SDRDM) in the onboard calibration assembly (CA) of the FengYun-4 (FY-4) advanced geostationary radiance imager (AGRI) was used as the reference radiometer. It was designed for measuring the partial aperture factor (PAF) for the AGRI onboard calibration. First, the linear response count variation relationship between the two was established under the same radiance source input. Then, according to the known bidirectional reflection distribution function (BRDF) of the solar diffuser (SD) in the CA, the relative reflectance ratio coefficient between the AGRI observation direction and the SDRDM observation direction was calculated. On this basis, the response count value of the AGRI and the SDRDM was used to realize the high-precision measurement of the PAF of the AGRI B1~B3 bands by simulating the AGRI onboard calibration measurement under the illumination of a solar simulator in the laboratory. According to the determination process of the relevant parameters of the PAF, the measurement uncertainty of the PAF was analyzed; this uncertainty was greater than 2.04% and provided an important reference for the evaluation of the onboard absolute radiometric calibration uncertainty after launch.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{si2022research,
  author = {Xiaolong Si and Xiuju Li and Hongyao Chen and Shiwei Bao and Heyu Xu and Liming Zhang and Wenxin Huang},
  title = {{Research on a Partial Aperture Factor Measurement Method for the AGRI Onboard Calibration Assembly}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=rBXuWEppE5},
}
Figure