Research on a Novel Combined Cooling and Power Scheme for LNG-Powered Ship

Xiu Xiao, Xiaoqing Xu, Zhe Wang, Chenxi Liu, Ying HeJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel integrated system for LNG-powered ships that simultaneously recovers waste heat from the engine and the "cold energy" from liquefied natural gas (LNG). By cascading this energy through cooling, power generation, and desalination systems, the scheme significantly boosts energy efficiency and offers substantial economic benefits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) is increasingly used as a cleaner fuel for ships, but its storage at extremely low temperatures (-162°C) means a significant amount of "cold energy" is released as it warms up to be used. This cold energy is typically wasted. Simultaneously, ships generate waste heat from their main engines. This paper addresses the challenge of efficiently utilizing both these energy sources on board to improve overall energy efficiency, reduce environmental impact, and enhance economic viability for LNG-powered vessels. Existing solutions often focus on single aspects like power generation, neglecting the broader energy demands of a ship, such as cooling and fresh water production.

Methods

The researchers proposed a comprehensive system called ORC-TCS-ACS-SDS, integrating:

  • Dual Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) systems: To convert waste heat and LNG cold energy into electricity.
  • High and Low-Temperature Cold Storage (TCS): To store and utilize the cold energy for various onboard needs.
  • Air Conditioning (ACS) system: To provide cooling for the ship's interior.
  • Seawater Desalination System (SDS): To produce fresh water using the cold energy.

Key methodological steps included:

  1. Working Fluid Selection: Identifying optimal working fluids for the ORC systems by considering both thermodynamic efficiency and economic factors.
  2. Thermodynamic and Exergy Analysis: Evaluating the system's performance using established thermodynamic principles and exergy analysis to pinpoint energy losses.
  3. Adaptive Weighted Particle Swarm Optimization (AWPSO): Employing this advanced optimization algorithm to maximize the system's net power output by adjusting key operational parameters. This method was chosen to overcome the limitations of traditional optimization techniques that can get stuck in local optima.
  4. System Simulation: Using Aspen Hysys software to model and simulate the integrated system.
  5. Economic Analysis: Evaluating the system's economic feasibility through metrics like total investment cost, cost recovery factor, power generation cost, annual net interest rate, and investment payback period.
  6. Model Validation: Comparing simulation results with literature data to ensure the model's reliability.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training datasets. However, it utilizes:

  • LNG composition data: Provided in Table 5, detailing the components of liquefied natural gas.
  • Main engine parameters: Provided in Table 2 and Table 6, crucial for system input.
  • VLCC ship parameters: Provided in Table 1, defining the target vessel.
  • Literature data: Used for model validation (Table 8), comparing simulation results against experimental data from previous studies on ORC, ACS, and SDS systems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cascading Cold Energy is Key: The paper demonstrates that effectively utilizing LNG's cold energy across multiple temperature zones (low, middle, and high) is crucial for maximizing its thermodynamic and economic benefits.
  • Integrated Systems Outperform Single-Purpose Solutions: Combining power generation, cooling, and desalination into a single system significantly enhances overall energy utilization and economic returns compared to focusing on just one aspect.
  • Working Fluid Choice Matters Immensely: The selection of appropriate refrigerants for the ORC systems (R32 and R134a were chosen) has a substantial impact on both thermodynamic performance and economic viability.
  • Optimization is Essential: Advanced optimization techniques like AWPSO are vital for fine-tuning complex, interconnected systems to achieve peak performance, especially when dealing with non-linear relationships between parameters.
  • Seawater Desalination as a Valuable Byproduct: Utilizing the cold energy for seawater desalination not only provides a valuable resource (fresh water) but also contributes significantly to the system's overall economic benefit.

Key Results

  • Maximum Net Power Output: The optimized ORC-TCS-ACS-SDS system achieved a maximum net power output of 725.78 kW.
  • Energy Efficiency: The overall exergy efficiency of the system was 58.63%.
  • Economic Benefits:
    • Annual net interest rate: $115,300.
  • Investment payback period: 10.8 years.
  • Maximum economic benefit of electricity generated in January: $5308.
  • Fresh Water Production: The system can supply fresh water for 11-14 days per month, depending on the season, meeting a significant portion of the target vessel's demand.
  • Model Validation: The simulation model showed a deviation of within 3.16% compared to literature experimental data, indicating its reliability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Heat Exchanger Optimization: The paper identifies heat exchangers, particularly the condenser in ORC1, as having high exergy losses. Future work should focus on optimizing their structure and heat transfer performance.
  • Dynamic Operation: The current analysis primarily focuses on steady-state conditions. Future research could explore the system's performance under dynamic operating conditions, considering variations in ship load, speed, and ambient temperature.
  • Specific Ship Type Focus: While the study uses a 300,000-ton VLCC as a target, further research could investigate the applicability and optimization of this scheme for different types and sizes of LNG-powered vessels.
  • Environmental Impact of Working Fluids: While the paper mentions criteria for working fluid selection, a deeper dive into the environmental impact (e.g., Global Warming Potential) of the chosen refrigerants could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cold energy recovery in LNG-powered vessels can not only improve the utilization efficiency of energy, but also benefit environmental protection. This paper put forward a new cascade scheme for utilizing flue gas waste heat and LNG cold energy comprehensively. The scheme was integrated by a dual organic Rankine circulation system (ORC), a high- and low-temperature cold storage system (TCS), an air conditioning system (ACS) and a seawater desalination system (SDS). The working medium of the dual ORC system was firstly determined by considering exergy efficiency and economic index simultaneously. On this basis, the adaptive weighted particle swarm optimization algorithm was employed to enhance thermodynamic performance of the scheme with the net output power as the optimization objective. The maximum net power and annual net interest rate can reach 725.78 kW and $115,300, respectively. Furthermore, the economic benefit of the scheme was analyzed by referring to the running track and the operation condition of the target ship. The results showed that the proposed scheme is a potential large-scale cryogenic technology and can bring considerable economic benefits to ship navigation.
BibTeX
@article{xiao2023research,
  author = {Xiu Xiao and Xiaoqing Xu and Zhe Wang and Chenxi Liu and Ying He},
  title = {{Research on a Novel Combined Cooling and Power Scheme for LNG-Powered Ship}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11030592},
}
Figure