Research on a Limit Analytical Method for a Low-Speed Micro Permanent Magnet Torque Motor with Back Winding

Shuangshuang Guo, Bo Zhao, Cunshan Zhang, Binglin Lu, Yukang Chu, Peng YangEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "back winding" permanent magnet torque motor (BWPMTM) design that simplifies manufacturing for small motors by slotting the stator on its outer surface. They also propose a "limit analytical method" to efficiently optimize motor parameters, considering key performance constraints like EMF, torque, temperature, and slot fill factor, significantly reducing design time.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Conventional permanent magnet torque motors (PMTMs) have stator slots on their inner surface. This design poses a significant manufacturing challenge, especially for small motors where the inner diameter is less than 40mm. Embedding winding coils into these tight inner slots becomes difficult, time-consuming, and costly, often requiring specialized robots or painstaking manual labor. This limits the practical application and miniaturization of high-performance PMTMs.

Methods

The core innovation lies in two areas:

  • Novel Motor Structure (BWPMTM): The researchers propose a "back winding" permanent magnet torque motor (BWPMTM) where the stator slots are moved to the outer surface. This seemingly simple change dramatically simplifies the winding process, allowing for easier embedding of coils from the outside. The absence of a stator yoke in this design also contributes to a potentially smaller motor size and higher torque density.
  • Limit Analytical Method for Optimization: To overcome the inefficiencies of traditional iterative design processes, the paper introduces a "limit analytical method." This approach directly solves for optimal motor parameters by considering four critical constraints:
  • No-load back EMF: Ensures the motor generates sufficient voltage at no load.
  • Torque: Guarantees the motor can deliver the required output torque.
  • Temperature: Prevents overheating under operational conditions.
  • Slot space factor: Maximizes the amount of winding wire that can fit into the stator slots, contributing to higher torque density. This method aims to find parameters that maximize torque density while satisfying all constraints, avoiding lengthy trial-and-error simulations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis, simulation, and experimental validation of a specific motor design.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Manufacturing Simplicity Drives Design: The most impactful insight is how a simple change in slot placement (outer vs. inner stator surface) can drastically improve manufacturability, especially for micro-motors. This highlights the importance of considering manufacturing constraints early in the design phase.
  • Direct Optimization is Powerful: The "limit analytical method" demonstrates that by carefully formulating constraints, it's possible to directly solve for optimal motor parameters, bypassing the need for extensive iterative simulations. This is a significant time and resource saver for motor designers.
  • Torque Density is Key: The paper consistently emphasizes maximizing torque density. The BWPMTM structure, by potentially allowing for a larger inner diameter within a given outer diameter, directly contributes to this goal.
  • Integrated Design Approach: The method's success in considering multiple, often competing, constraints (EMF, torque, temperature, slot fill) simultaneously is crucial. It shows that a holistic approach is necessary for achieving optimal performance.

Key Results

  • BWPMTM Prototype: A prototype of the BWPMTM was successfully built and tested.
  • FEM Simulation Validation: Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations were used to analyze electromagnetic and thermal performance, showing good agreement with theoretical predictions.
  • Experimental Verification: Experimental results for no-load back EMF and temperature distribution showed good agreement with FEM simulations, with maximum errors of 6.3% and 7% respectively, deemed acceptable.
  • Cogging Torque Reduction: The BWPMTM demonstrated a significant reduction in cogging torque (14 µNm) compared to a conventional structure (31 µNm), attributed to the closed slot design.
  • Torque Density Improvement: The BWPMTM achieved a torque density of 2 Nm/kg, which is a 30% improvement over a comparable commercial motor (1.54 Nm/kg).
  • Optimized Parameters: The limit analytical method successfully determined optimal motor parameters, leading to a design that fully utilized motor materials.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Locked-Rotor Condition Focus: While the paper analyzes locked-rotor conditions extensively for design, real-world operation involves dynamic states. Future work could explore the motor's performance under various load and speed conditions beyond locked-rotor.
  • Material Properties: The analysis relies on specific material properties. Variations in material quality or the use of different materials could impact performance.
  • Generalizability of the Method: While the limit analytical method is presented as a general approach, its application to other motor types might require adaptation. The authors suggest it can serve as a reference for other motor designs.
  • Further Optimization: Although the method achieves "limit" conditions, there might be room for further fine-tuning or exploring multi-objective optimization beyond just torque density.

Summary updated

Abstract

The conventional permanent magnet torque motor (PMTM) is slotted on the inner surface of the stator core. When the size of the stator core is small, the winding coils are difficult to embed into the slots. To solve the problem, a novel PMTM is presented, which is slotted on the outer surface of the stator core. As a result, the winding coils can be conveniently embedded into the slots from the outer surface of the stator core. The novel structure of the PMTM with back winding (BWPMTM) is introduced, and the advantage of the novel structure is analyzed. Furthermore, this paper proposes a limit analytical method to solve the optimal parameters of the motor which comprehensively considers four constraints: no-load back electromotive force (EMF), torque, temperature and slot space factor. The optimal parameters of the motor are directly solved to maximize torque density within the constrained range. This method avoids repeated iterative processes and greatly reduces the amount of calculation for PMTM design. Electromagnetic performance and thermal performance are analyzed based on the finite element model (FEM). Finally, the building of a prototype and the experimental results obtained with it are discussed. The rationality of the novel structure and the limit analytical method are verified.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2022research,
  author = {Shuangshuang Guo and Bo Zhao and Cunshan Zhang and Binglin Lu and Yukang Chu and Peng Yang},
  title = {{Research on a Limit Analytical Method for a Low-Speed Micro Permanent Magnet Torque Motor with Back Winding}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15134662},
}

Loading related content...

Figure