Research in the field of evaluation of anfo explosive preparation installations, Tests and results

Ștefan Ilici, Edward Gheorghiosu, Daniela Rus, Ciprian JiteaMATEC 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details the rigorous testing and certification protocols required for mobile and fixed ANFO (Ammonium Nitrate/Fuel Oil) explosive manufacturing units in Romania. By validating toxic gas emissions, impact sensitivity, and friction resistance, researchers ensure that cost-effective, on-site explosive production meets strict European safety standards.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of large-scale rock extraction and mining, explosives are a massive line item. Traditionally, explosives were manufactured off-site, leading to high costs associated with specialized storage, armored transport, and constant security escorts. To slash these overheads, the industry has shifted toward ANFO (Ammonium Nitrate/Fuel Oil), a low-power explosive that can be mixed on-site using Mobile Explosive Manufacturing Units (MEMUs).

However, "mixing on-site" introduces significant variables. If the ratio of precursors is off, or if the mixture isn't perfectly homogenized, the resulting explosive might be unstable, overly sensitive to friction, or—conversely—fail to detonate properly. Furthermore, poor-quality mixtures can release dangerous levels of toxic gases upon detonation. This paper addresses the need for a standardized evaluation framework to certify that these local installations produce explosives that are both effective and safe for civilian use.

Methods

The researchers at INSEMEX (Romania’s National Institute for Research and Development in Mine Safety) utilized several standardized European testing protocols to evaluate ANFO produced by local companies:

  • Toxic Gas Measurement: Detonations were performed in a 15 $m^3$ gas chamber. Using the Testo 350 XL analyzer and specialized software, the team measured the resulting concentrations of $CO$, $CO_2$, $NO$, and $NO_x$.
  • Impact Sensitivity (BAM Hammer): This test determines the minimum energy required to trigger a reaction by dropping a weight (5 kg) from varying heights onto a small sample of the explosive.
  • Friction Sensitivity (Julius Peters Device): This evaluates how the explosive reacts to mechanical stress. A porcelain pin is dragged across a sample on a porcelain plate with a specific force (360 N) to see if a reaction occurs.
  • Precursor Verification: The team audited the mechanical components of the MEMUs—such as the helical conveyors and diesel injection circuits—to ensure they accurately deliver the required 93–96% ammonium nitrate to 4–7% diesel ratio.

Datasets

While not a "dataset" in the computational sense, the paper provides comprehensive experimental data from tests conducted on Romanian installations. This includes:

  • Gas Emission Tables: Detailed ppm and l/kg measurements for three separate test detonations.
  • Sensitivity Logs: A 26-trial log of impact tests showing the transition from "No Reaction" (FR) to "Reaction" (R).
  • Technical Specifications: The physical dimensions and capacities of a standard Mercedes-Benz truck-mounted MEMU (e.g., 10,000 kg nitrate capacity, 700 l diesel capacity).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The 20-Joule Threshold: Through repeated BAM hammer tests, the researchers identified the impact sensitivity of their ANFO samples at 20.0 J. This provides a clear safety benchmark for handling the material on-site.
  • The "Work Permit" as a Safety Tool: Beyond the chemistry, the paper emphasizes the administrative side of safety. A standardized "Work Permit" system is mandatory, requiring signatures from the truck operator, the shooting supervisor, and management before every use.
  • Environmental Sensitivity: The authors highlight that moisture is a primary enemy of ANFO quality. Even slight humidity in the raw materials or the environment can inhibit sensitivity, leading to incomplete detonations and higher toxic gas yields.
  • Regulatory Alignment: The work serves as a bridge between technical engineering and EU law (Directive 2014/28/EU), showing exactly how a mobile truck is transformed from a simple vehicle into a "certified manufacturing facility."

Key Results

  • Toxic Gases: The average amount of carbon monoxide ($CO$) produced was 29.35 l/kg, while nitrogen oxides ($NO_x$) averaged 14.42 l/kg. These figures are critical for determining ventilation requirements in mining environments.
  • Mechanical Stability: The explosive showed no reaction to friction at a force of 360 N across six consecutive tests, confirming it is safe for transport through the pneumatic pipes used in boreholes.
  • Detonation Velocity: The certified installations produced ANFO with a detonation speed of $\ge$ 2000 m/s, ensuring sufficient power for rock demolition.
  • Certification Models: The paper concludes with a blueprint for a "Certificate of Conformity," providing a standardized template for other EU-based notified bodies.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper focuses primarily on the certification and verification of existing technology rather than the development of new explosive chemistries.

One noted limitation is the sensitivity of the mixture to environmental factors; while the paper mentions the harmful influence of moisture, it does not propose specific mechanical upgrades to MEMUs to mitigate high-humidity environments. Future research could explore real-time sensors within the mixing auger to adjust diesel ratios dynamically based on the porosity and moisture content of the ammonium nitrate prills.

Summary updated

Abstract

The technical-economic efficiency of rock extraction works depends significantly on the drilling and blasting works as well as the adjacent costs. The cost of the explosive is an important component in these and the generalization of the widespread use of the use of bulk explosives (ANFO) has generated a significant reduction in the cost. Making the explosive close to the place of use in fixed or semi-stationary installations on the quarry stage eliminates the costs related to storage or long-term storage, transport, escort, security. However, installations for the manufacture of ANFO type explosives must consistently produce a simple quality explosive mixture. The quality lies in the participation of the precursors as well as in the degree of homogenization, stability and a good behavior to external stimuli that can lead to sensibility to initiation stimuli or inhibition of sensitivity where the harmful influence of moisture in the raw material or environment must be emphasized. The paper presents tests and results obtained in recent years for such installations used by several companies in Romania performed under the supervision of INSEMEX specialists. These assessments were completed with the certification of explosives manufacturing facilities for the specified operating parameters as well as for explosives.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ilici2021research,
  author = {Ștefan Ilici and Edward Gheorghiosu and Daniela Rus and Ciprian Jitea},
  title = {{Research in the field of evaluation of anfo explosive preparation installations, Tests and results}},
  booktitle = {MATEC},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1051/matecconf/202134201003},
}

Loading related content...

Figure